- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents MOVE (Model’s own Visual Errors), a framework that turns the policy’s own regional errors into corrective supervision. MoVE contrasts corrected and error-preserving regional conditions to refine credit within a sampled response, and distills corrected targets to supervise objects absent from it. MOVE is pluggable and can directly extends on GRPO, DAPO etc.. Across 2B and 4B model families, experiments demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed approach MOVE.
Critical strengths
- The paper introduce a novel approach called MOVE which is a framework that turns the policy’s own regional errors into corrective supervision. MoVE contrasts corrected and error-preserving regional conditions to refine credit within a sampled response, and distills corrected targets to supervise objects absent from it.
- MOVE is pluggable and can directly extends on GRPO, DAPO etc..
- Across 2 model sizes, MOVE demonstrate performance improvement, although not consistent.
Critical weaknesses
- The performance gain is very marginal and not significant and not consistently improving when comparing with baseline such as GRPO etc.
- The tested on model families are very small, generalization to bigger model is questionable.
Questions for authors
- Could you demonstrate the significance of your methods?
- Can the improvement be still gained from a larger model family?
Thank you for the detailed response and additional ablations. The results provide useful evidence that EC and CRSD improve performance beyond the tested alternatives. However, they do not fully rule out that the gains arise partly from coordinate-hint consistency or answer-revealing privileged supervision, rather than genuinely visual credit assignment. The clarification regarding the partially off-policy auxiliary objective is reasonable, though the associated distribution mismatch remains insufficiently analyzed. Therefore, my concerns are partially resolved, and I will maintain my current rating.