- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies source distributions in equivariant generative robot policies and argues that an equivariant transport mechanism alone is insufficient to guarantee an equivariant policy. The paper formalizes source compatibility, shows that equivariance error in the source is preserved by an invertible equivariant flow, and characterizes compatible source distributions for translation, rotation, and gripper components. Based on this analysis, the authors introduce GARLIC, which uses an end-effector-anchored translational source, an observation-independent rotational source corresponding to the Haar measure on SO(3), and an equivariant geometric-algebra flow-matching policy.
However, I have several substantial concerns regarding the practical novelty and the empirical interpretation of the method. In particular, the current experiments do not sufficiently isolate whether the observed gains come from source compatibility itself or simply from using a more informative and easier conditional action prior whose mass is located closer to the demonstrated target actions. In addition, the practical benefit over standard coordinate canonicalization / relative-action formulations is not yet clearly established, and the real-world and OOD evaluations are too limited to support some of the broader generalization claims.
Critical strengths
Please identify one or two critical strengths of the paper that support acceptance. For each, explain briefly why it is consequential to your overall assessment. The goal is not to enumerate every positive point, but to identify and substantiate the considerations that most strongly determine your recommendation. Enter “None” if no substantive strength can be identified.
The paper identifies an important and often overlooked component of equivariant generative policies. The observation that end-to-end equivariance depends not only on the denoiser / velocity field but also on the source distribution is conceptually useful. The separation between source compatibility and equivariant transport provides a clear framework for analyzing generative robot policies.
Critical weaknesses
Please identify one or two critical weaknesses of the paper that support rejection. For each, explain briefly why it is consequential to your overall assessment. The goal is not to enumerate every negative point, but to identify and substantiate the considerations that most strongly determine your recommendation. Enter “None” if no material weakness can be identified.
1. The practical advantage over coordinate canonicalization or relative-action formulations is unclear
The proposed translational source is anchored at the current end-effector position. However, in robotic manipulation, world-frame and end-effector-frame actions can be converted through the current robot pose. Therefore, the proposed source construction appears closely related to defining the action generation process in an end-effector-relative coordinate system and then transforming the result back to the world frame.
The paper provides a useful theoretical interpretation of this design, but it is unclear whether GARLIC offers a practical advantage over conventional canonicalization or relative-action representations.
A matched comparison between:
- GARLIC with a world-frame anchored source, and
- an end-effector-frame canonicalized policy using the same or similar backbone
would be important for establishing the practical novelty of the method.
2. Source compatibility is confounded with a better and easier action prior
GARLIC centers its translational source at the current end-effector position instead of the world origin. This change does two things simultaneously:
- it improves source compatibility with geometric transformations;
- it places the source closer to typical robot actions.
The second factor can independently make the flow-matching problem easier. A source initialized near the current end-effector may require a shorter and simpler transport to reach the demonstrated action trajectory. This can improve optimization, sample efficiency, and finite-step inference even without considering equivariance.
Therefore, the comparison between a fixed world-origin Gaussian and an end-effector-anchored source does not isolate the effect of source compatibility. The paper would be significantly stronger if it included controlled experiments using multiple compatible sources with different distances to the target actions, or compatible and incompatible sources with approximately matched source-target distances. Without such experiments, it remains unclear whether the performance gains mainly come from equivariance or from using a more favorable conditional action prior.
Figure 1 illustrates an object-anchored source, while GARLIC actually anchors the source at the robot end-effector. An object-anchored source can already provide task-relevant spatial information because the source is located near the manipulated object. This makes it difficult to separate the benefit of equivariance from the benefit of placing the source near the desired action region.
Questions for authors
Ask only questions whose answers could materially affect your assessment. Distinguish clarification requests from suggestions for future work.
#1. How much of GARLIC's improvement comes from source compatibility, and how much comes from placing the source closer to the target action distribution?
#2. Can the authors compare several compatible sources that have substantially different distances to the demonstrated actions?
#3. Can the authors compare GARLIC against an end-effector-frame canonicalized policy using a matched architecture?
4 comments
Q3. Comparison with end-effector-frame canonicalization
Thank you for suggesting this comparison. We evaluate coordinate-frame canonicalization using 2 backbones, DP3 and GATr. To separate the roles of the frame’s origin and its orientation, we fix the origin at the end-effector position , while its orientation is defined by the world axes, end-effector axes , or a random rotation sampled uniformly from for every training sample and policy call. The table (Table 8 in the revision) reports ID/OOD success rates (%).
| Backbone | World axes | End-effector axes | Random axes |
|---|---|---|---|
| DP3 | 44.3±6.7 / 9.3±6.4 | 42.7±1.2 / 41.3±3.0 | 39.6±8.5 / 41.3±7.0 |
| GATr | 84.7±5.1 / 83.2±4.7 | 83.7±3.9 / 84.2±4.5 | 84.3±4.3 / 84.6±4.8 |
With the equivariant GATr backbone, canonicalization and GARLIC achieve comparable performance. The world-axes entry is GARLIC itself: a frame at with no rotation places the source at , which is the anchored source. The end-effector-axes entry is the canonicalization suggested in the review. We agree with the reviewer that the two are closely related. With an equivariant backbone they are in fact the same policy: the frame orientation cancels and only its origin remains (Remark 2, Appendix A.6 of the revision).
To see this, consider a frame with origin and orientation . Sampling the translational source in this frame as and transforming it to world coordinates gives
\sim\mathcal N(p_{ee},\sigma^2I).$$ Because the Gaussian is isotropic, this distribution does not depend on $Q$. Similarly, the 6D rotational source $\mathcal N(0,\sigma^2 I_6)$ is unchanged by $Q$, so the induced rotation remains Haar-distributed. Thus, every frame orientation induces the same source, which is GARLIC's anchored source. Since GATr is equivariant, canonicalization (expressing the observation in the frame, generating there, and mapping the action back) gives the same policy as generating directly in the world frame from this source. In other words, with an equivariant backbone, the anchored source is a canonicalization that needs only an anchor point and no orientation. The table agrees: the three GATr entries are separately trained models, and their success rates match across frame orientations. **With the non-equivariant DP3 backbone, the frame orientation matters.** Without an equivariant backbone, the orientation no longer cancels. With world axes, OOD success falls to 9.3%. Making the orientation equivariant, either exactly with the end-effector axes or in distribution with a random rotation, removes the ID–OOD gap (41.3% OOD in both cases), but success remains about half that of GATr. **Practical implications.** With a matched equivariant backbone, GARLIC and end-effector-frame canonicalization perform the same; the practical difference is in what each requires. End-effector-frame canonicalization needs a full pose to define its frame, whereas the anchored source needs only a single equivariant point. Centroid-anchor (Q2) shows this directly: the point-cloud centroid defines no orientation, yet it matches GARLIC (84.9 / 83.5 vs 84.7 / 83.2). This matters in settings where no end-effector pose is observed, such as generating grasp poses from an object point cloud: the centroid still provides an anchor, and no frame orientation has to be estimated. The source view thus shows what canonicalization actually requires: it separates the frame into an origin and an orientation, and identifies when each is needed. That an anchor alone can suffice is implicit in practices such as centroid centering (Yang et al., CoRL 2024); our analysis states it explicitly and gives the condition under which it holds. The reviewer's question led us to make this explicit; the comparison is now in Section 6.7 (Table 8) of the revision, with the formal statement in Remark 2 and its proof in Appendix A.6. The review also mentions relative-action formulations. We ran this comparison with the same GATr backbone (65.5 / 64.7 versus 84.7 / 83.2 for GARLIC); details are in our response to Reviewer eGSi (W1/Q1) and in Section 6.5 (Table 6) of the revision. ## Scope of the OOD and real-world evaluations The OOD experiments test robustness to $SE(2)$ transformations of the whole scene. The real-robot experiments test generalization to unseen object placements with a fixed base, and deployment on physical hardware. We revised the abstract and the conclusion to state this scope explicitly. Beyond the original OOD results on four tasks, the experiments added in this response use the same OOD evaluation to examine the importance of source compatibility (Q1), the difference between a compatible source and an informative one (Q1, Q2), and what canonicalization requires of the frame orientation (Q3). Together they provide further empirical evidence for our theory.Response To Authors
The author addressed some of my concerns, and I am inclined to raise our rating.
Thank you for your time and thoughtful review. The revised manuscript includes the experiments and discussions you suggested, which helped us improve our paper.
Thanks for your careful reading and the insightful suggestions. We answer each question below. All success rates are computed over 15 checkpoints: the last 5 epochs of each of 3 training seeds.
Q1. Contributions of source compatibility and proximity
We agree that the contributions of compatibility and proximity should be better isolated. We ran both controlled experiments proposed in the review: compatible and incompatible sources at matched distances (this section), and compatible sources at different distances (Q2). Here we compare GARLIC with 3 alternative source distributions:
We measure proximity as the mean distance between each source center and the corresponding demonstrated action position. The table reports in-distribution (ID) and out-of-distribution (OOD) success rates, with Δ=OOD−ID.
In short, at matched distance compatibility accounts for 10.5 to 31.7 points in ID and 19.8 to 51.4 in OOD, whereas proximity accounts for 2.3 points when the source is compatible and 23.5 when it is not.
Source compatibility contributes to performance beyond proximity to the target actions. At comparable distances, the compatible sources substantially outperform their incompatible counterparts. Shifted-anchor outperforms Fixed Gaussian by 31.7 points in ID and 51.4 in OOD, despite their similar distances (0.429 m vs 0.475 m). Similarly, GARLIC outperforms Mean-centered by 10.5 points in ID and 19.8 in OOD, despite having a larger mean distance to the targets (0.230 m vs 0.205 m). The compatible sources also exhibit smaller ID–OOD performance gaps, consistent with the benefits of equivariance.
The effect of proximity depends on compatibility. Between the two compatible sources, increasing the distance from 0.230 m (GARLIC) to 0.429 m (Shifted-anchor) reduces ID success by only 2.3 points. In contrast, moving the incompatible Fixed Gaussian from the origin to the mean training action reduces its distance from 0.475 m to 0.205 m and improves ID success from 50.7% to 74.2%. This supports the reviewer's point that a source closer to the targets can make the flow-matching problem easier, consistent with prior work on informative sources (Lee et al., ICLR 2022; Chen et al., RSS 2024). Proximity therefore matters mainly when compatibility is absent.
We attribute this pattern to sample efficiency. A compatible source makes the policy equivariant, which improves sample efficiency (Wang et al., CoRL 2024; Yang et al., CoRL 2024), so the policy learns well wherever the source is placed. Without compatibility this benefit is lost, and an informative source helps instead.
We added this comparison as Section 6.6, with details in Appendix D.4.
Q2. Compatible sources at different distances
We compare 3 compatible sources at different distances from the demonstrated actions:
The 3 compatible sources perform comparably despite very different distances to the targets. Their mean distances range from 0.180 m to 0.429 m, while ID success varies by at most 2.5 points and OOD success by less than 1 point. In particular, Centroid-anchor is closer to the targets than GARLIC but performs the same. Among compatible sources, proximity thus has little effect on performance. This is consistent with the explanation in Q1.
Centroid-anchor also clarifies Figure 1. The object-anchored source in the figure illustrates the general construction of Corollary 2, which permits any equivariant anchor, including an object position, the point-cloud centroid, or the end-effector position. GARLIC uses the end-effector as a readily available anchor, while Centroid-anchor incorporates scene geometry directly into the source center. Their comparable performance shows that the benefit of a compatible source does not depend on anchoring at the end-effector or on placing the source close to the targets.