- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
this paper introduce MEMIG as a memory system which addresses some shorcomings of existing works and achive good numerical results.
Critical strengths
The studied topic is important.
numerical results are good.
Critical weaknesses
-
line 54-73, this figure is a bit liked generated by codex 6. (no evidence, just by experience), the same as figure 3.
-
line 226-239, it is unusual to put results direcly into the main method part.
-
The method is not very theoretical sound.
-
the main method is pretty descripitive, not very sound. no formulations. The proposed memory system is not clearly described.
-
do not use color in ur submission, not very formal.
-
Using "four steps" in your main method is somehow vague. consider at least use psedo codes.
-
Only GLM results. How about on opus 5.5?
-
the position of related work is strange somehow, and some important works are missing.
Questions for authors
-
what is the main method?
-
what about the results on more strong base models such as codex 6.1
-
what is the std of your experiments.