acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

TGPED: Task-Generalized Procedural Error Detection and Explanation using Large Language Models with Procedural Grounding

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

In this paper, we address temporal action segmentation, error detection, and error explanation within a single unified framework across multiple procedural tasks. Existing approaches typically require a separately trained model to segment actions for each task, limiting their scalability and practicality. Moreover, due to the limited availability of training videos containing errors, prior methods are often trained only on normal videos, preventing direct optimization for error detection and explanation. To address these limitations, we propose TGPED, a task-generalized framework for procedural error detection and explanation that avoids task-specific retraining while enabling direct optimization for error understanding. First, TGPED generates dense video captions and introduces Procedure-Grounded Temporal Segmentation (PGTS), which performs segmentation using Large Language Models (LLMs) together with generated procedural references that encode task-specific information, such as action semantics and valid action orderings. Second, we design a data generation pipeline to synthesize realistic sequences of erroneous actions, forming a cross-task training dataset. Finally, we formulate the generated sequences as inputs for fine-tuning an LLM-based error detector to jointly perform error detection and explanation. We evaluate TGPED on EgoPER and CaptainCook4D, achieving state-of-the-art performance on EgoPER and strong results on CaptainCook4D. Code will be released upon acceptance.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
error detection, procedural video understanding, multimodal large language models, error explanation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_uNEeOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes TGPED for procedural action segmentation, error detection, explanation, and omission localization across multiple tasks. PGTS uses frozen models and generated procedural references to organize timestamped video captions into action segments. A shared LLM detector is then fine-tuned on synthetic caption sequences containing errors, constructed from normal training videos. Experiments on EgoPER and five selected CaptainCook4D tasks evaluate all four capabilities. Task-specific and leave-one-task-out comparisons provide evidence for sharing the detector across tasks and transferring to held-out tasks when procedural references are available.

Critical strengths
  1. Reference-conditioned cross-task reuse. PGTS avoids training a separate segmentation model for each task, while the detector shares parameters across tasks. On EgoPER, leave-one-task-out detection F1 reaches 40.0, compared with 42.5 when all tasks are included. This supports reuse on held-out tasks given their procedural references.

  2. Useful supervision from normal videos. The synthetic-error pipeline enables direct training for detection and explanation without collecting real erroneous training videos. On EgoPER, fine-tuning improves end-to-end detection F1 from 30.1 to 42.5, providing meaningful evidence for the value of this supervision.

  3. Explicit localization of omitted steps. The method predicts both the missing action and where it should be inserted, making procedural feedback more actionable. On CaptainCook4D, omission localization F1 reaches 40.1 versus 19.8 for GTG2Vid at a time tolerance of 5% of the video length.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited novelty. The method appears primarily incremental, and the paper does not sufficiently distinguish its synthetic-error construction from related work such as PIE-V, leaving the specific methodological advance unclear.

  2. Generalization claims exceed the experimental evidence. The leave-one-task-out setting still constructs the target-task reference using normal videos and ground-truth action annotations from that task. Thus, deployment without target-task annotations is not fully validated.

  3. Insufficient controlled ablations and quantitative quality validation of synthetic supervision. Different synthesis strategies are not compared under controlled conditions. Although manual inspection is reported, quantitative quality assessments are missing, leaving the necessity of full-sequence supervision and the realism of synthetic errors uncertain.

  4. Insufficient validation of captions for fine-grained error detection. All downstream reasoning relies on captions, so omitted or misinterpreted visual details may directly cause detection failures. Robustness to caption noise and missing details is insufficiently evaluated, limiting confidence in practical reliability.

Questions for authors

see above

Reviewer_cvWMOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes TGPED, a task-generalized framework for procedural error detection and explanation. It introduces Procedure-Grounded Temporal Segmentation (PGTS), which uses dense video captions and procedural references for training-free action segmentation, and a pseudo-error generation pipeline to fine-tune a shared LLM-based error detector. Experiments on EgoPER and CaptainCook4D demonstrate competitive performance in action segmentation, error detection, explanation, and omission localization, as well as cross-task generalization.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses

A. Limited Methodological Novelty. The framework relies heavily on existing LLM/VLM capabilities without substantial technical innovation. The procedural reference generation pipeline lacks clear motivation, as its advantages over directly using video frames and action annotations with VLMs remain unclear. Similarly, pseudo-error synthesis through sequence modification and subsequent SFT are standard engineering practices rather than novel contributions specific to procedural error detection.

B. Insufficient Experimental Validation. The paper lacks comprehensive comparisons with general-purpose and specialized VLM-based error detection methods, making it difficult to attribute improvements to the proposed framework rather than the underlying foundation models. Moreover, the method underperforms existing approaches on several metrics (Tables 1 and 3), and some critical ablations are missing, such as procedural reference generation. These limitations weaken the experimental justification for the proposed method.

Questions for authors

A. Motivation and Justification of the Framework Design. Could the authors clarify the motivation behind each key component of the proposed framework, particularly procedural reference generation and pseudo-error synthesis? The current methodology primarily describes the implementation steps without sufficiently explaining the rationale behind these design choices or their specific advantages for procedural error detection.

B. Comparison with General-Purpose and Specialized VLMs. Could the authors provide comparisons with general-purpose VLMs (e.g., ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and GLM) and additional VLM-based procedural mistake detection methods?

Reviewer_NmX7OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

In this paper, the authors present a method for error detection and explanation for carrying out tasks which are demonstrated though egocentric videos. The proposed method, TGPED, starts from dense video captioning of video demonstrates of a task, and then prompting an LLM with some heuristics for grouping actions within the video to define a reference "procedure" for the task. References collected from across tasks are then augmented with pseudo errors and used to fine tune an error detector. During inference the dense captions are grouped into actions with a similar LLM prompting strategy with heuristics and then the fine tuned model is used for error detection and explanation generation.

The authors use a Qwen3.6-27B at inference for both action grouping and a fine-tuned version for error detection, and GPT-5.6 Terra for reference procedure generation during training. They evaluate this method on EgoPER and CaptainCook4D and demonstrate improvements across action segmentation, error detection, and explanation. The authors also provide ablations demonstrating the utility of their contributions.

Overall I found that the paper required substantial effort to read. I appreciated that the authors manage to generalize a method across egocentric procedural tasks, but I think the broader claim of task-generalization overstates the contribution. Additionally, I have some concerns with the justification provided for the design decisions and with some of the results, which I point out in the sections below.

Critical strengths
  • The proposed method generalizes across procedural egocentric cooking tasks without requiring a large amount of tuning on dataset/procedure specific training data.
  • The pseudo error generation procedure for dataset augmentation is well-designed with careful consideration for error types.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The broader claim of task generalization/zero shot seems like a stretch. According to section 4.1.4 on implementation, procedural references are constructed from all the training data. I think the narrower claim of not requiring tuning on source procedure data may still be defensible, but not this broader claim.
  2. Missing/errors in some results. Results for baselines AMNAR and EgoPED are missing in Table 1. Table 4 shows AXG-Reasoner performance as lower than that of the original paper. While the authors are using a different base model, this reflects a lack of sufficient efforts in baseline reproduction.
Questions for authors
  1. For assessing the generalization/zero-shot claim, is it possible for this approach to work on a procedure that does not have any demonstration in the training data? If so how? Either provide a good justification or generalization to other datasets/tasks without having access to the videos.
  2. What is the reason for the discrepancy between AXG-Reasoner's performance in the original paper and your reproduction? Replacing the base model with a ostensibly stronger base model should improve their results.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.