acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Grounded Continuation: A Linear-Time Runtime Verifier for LLM Conversations

Abstract

In a long conversation, an LLM may produce a fluent continuation that rests on premises the conversation has already abandoned. Context-manipulation attacks exploit precisely this weakness. We address this problem with a runtime verifier. An LLM Interpreter maps each utterance to one or more of eight epistemic operations, and then a symbolic engine applies these operations to a dependency map that records what every claim rests on and whether it still stands. Based on the dependency map, checking whether a continuation is grounded then reduces to a walk over the map, linear in its size and requiring no LLM call. Retraction propagates through the same map with a conflict-free guarantee and flags exactly the conclusions that lose support. Our experiments with five QA models demonstrate substantial improvements in QA accuracy at a low cost per query. On ReviseQA for belief revision and MemoryAgentBench's FactConsolidation split (MemAB-FC), the verifier outperforms a retrieval baseline and raises MemAB-FC single-hop accuracy from – to –. With the verifier, even the small 7B model overtakes unaided GPT-4o. When a GPT-4o Interpreter extracts every update from raw text rather than taking the benchmarks' structured updates, the verifier still outperforms the retrieval baseline. Moreover, on MemAB-FC, QA prompts remain compact at – tokens while the full-context baseline reaches K. Retraction queries take less than a microsecond at turns.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
Runtime verification, Neurosymbolic systems, Large language models, Interactional grounding, Argumentation frameworks, Belief revision

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_WHpWOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

In a long conversation sessions with an agent, LLMs can produce continuations that directly contradict earlier claims or alternatively produce continuations that depend on earlier conversation that was abandoned. The paper focuses on producing continuations that are grounded in premises that are valid. The paper proposes to map utterances to one or more of eight epistemic operation (with an LLM), which is then applied to a dependency graph by a symbolic engine. Then checking from grounded-ness of any continuation is walk on this dependency graph. This guarantee depends on correctly mapping claims and their dependencies into the graph.

Critical strengths
  • Simple Mechanism: The mechanism builds a dependency graph that can be checked against continuations in symbolic terms. This provides a simple and powerful mechanism which shows very good results
  • Promising Empirical Results: Evaluation results show that tracking premise validity can allows LLMs to self-correct providing higher results at least in QA.
Critical weaknesses
  • Unclear Framing: The abstract starts with "context-manipulation attacks" and then the intro follows up incorrect continuations which is a bizarre disconnect from the reader's perspective. It would be better for a consistent framing of the problem.
  • Indirect Evaluation of the Central Claim: The evaluation is indirectly measuring the impact of tracking premise validity on performance of various tasks. However, it does not directly measure whether the verifier correctly accepts supported candidate continuations and rejects unsupported ones, particularly when claim to record links and dependencies must be inferred. Such an evaluation would better establish the scope and reliability of the continuation verification claim.
Questions for authors
  1. Could you evaluate candidate answer or continuation sampled from the QA tasks and independently label whether their claims are supported by the currently valid premises?
  2. Report how often unsupported continuations are rejected?
  3. Can you also report how often valid continuations are accepted?
4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer WHpW

Thank you for your careful review and for the clear questions! We ran the evaluation you asked for and answer your three questions first, then the two weaknesses.

Q1. Evaluating answers sampled from the QA tasks against independent labels.

Yes. We took the 3,280 distinct answers that the QA models gave in the submitted MemAB-FC experiments and labelled each one valid or unsupported (grounded and ungrounded in the paper). An answer is valid if a chain of records that still stand states its value, and unsupported otherwise. The labels come from the benchmark's own record of which facts were replaced, without running the verifier, and we reviewed a sample of 100 labels by hand against the records, stratified by label, and found all 100 correct.

We then ran the check of Definition 2.2 on every answer. Verifier (native) takes the records from the benchmark's structured updates, and Verifier (end-to-end) has the Interpreter build them from raw text. The end-to-end arm covers 6K and 32K, as in Table 8 of the revision.

QuestionsValid answers acceptedUnsupported answers rejected
Verifier (native)single-hop1.000 (406 / 406)1.000 (468 / 468)
Verifier (native)multi-hop1.000 (334 / 334)1.000 (2,072 / 2,072)
Verifier (end-to-end)single-hop0.995 (201 / 202)1.000 (185 / 185)
Verifier (end-to-end)multi-hop0.989 (175 / 177)0.994 (997 / 1,003)

The native arm takes its records from the same structured updates that the labels are derived from, so its score confirms that the implementation follows Definition 2.2. The end-to-end arm measures the method: the Interpreter builds the records from raw text, and every error of this arm comes from a record that it built wrongly. Section 4.4 of the revision reports this evaluation, and Table 4 gives the same counts as precision and recall.

Q2. How often unsupported continuations are rejected.

Given the benchmark's records, every unsupported answer is rejected. When the Interpreter builds the records from raw text, all 185 unsupported single-hop answers and 997 of the 1,003 unsupported multi-hop answers (0.994) are rejected. These are the last column of the table in Q1.

Q3. How often valid continuations are accepted.

Given the benchmark's records, every valid answer is accepted. When the Interpreter builds the records from raw text, 201 of the 202 valid single-hop answers (0.995) and 175 of the 177 valid multi-hop answers (0.989) are accepted. These are the third column of the table in Q1.

W1. Framing of the problem.

We agree. We removed the sentence on context-manipulation attacks from the abstract, so the abstract and the introduction now open with the same problem: continuations that rest on premises the conversation has abandoned. The introduction presents context manipulation as one source of such continuations.

W2. Direct evaluation when claim-to-record links and dependencies must be inferred.

Both cases are covered. The end-to-end arm in the table in Q1 is the case where the dependencies are inferred: 0.989–0.995 of the valid answers are accepted and 0.994–1.000 of the unsupported ones are rejected. For the link, which the paper calls association, both arms of that table use the entities and the relation named in the question. When GPT-4o infers the link instead, naming the record that an answer rests on without seeing which records still stand, no unsupported answer is accepted, and 0.961 of the valid single-hop answers (390 of 406) and 0.485 of the valid multi-hop answers (162 of 334) are accepted, pooled over the four stream lengths. Valid multi-hop answers are accepted less often because the LLM has to find the record at the end of a chain of facts.

The link is also inferred on free-form continuations. We wrote 86 of them on the two conversations of Section 3, the Phase 2 debugging session and the Phase 3 architecture deliberation (Appendix B.2 and B.3), 29 valid and 57 unsupported. With GPT-4o linking each continuation to a record, the check accepts all 29 valid continuations and rejects 54 of the 57 unsupported ones. When each continuation is instead linked to the record that shares the most words with it, the check accepts 26 of the 29 and rejects 48 of the 57, so the LLM link improves both. The protocol and the results under inferred links, per stream length and for two further LLMs, are in Appendix D.4 of the revision.

The list of revisions is in the general response. We are glad to run further checks during the discussion period.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up to Reviewer WHpW

Dear Reviewer WHpW,

Thank you for the time and care you put into reviewing our paper.

Your comments changed the paper for the better. Your questions on how often valid continuations are accepted and unsupported ones are rejected led to the new Section 4.4, a direct evaluation of the grounding check. Your point on the framing led us to revise the abstract so that it presents the same problem as the introduction. Your question on inferred links also pushed us to test the case where an LLM performs the association (Appendix D.4).

If anything in our response or the revised paper is still unclear or unconvincing to you, we would be glad to hear it. Your feedback is valuable to us either way.

Thank you again.

Reviewer_WHpWOpenReview ↗

Thanks for addressing my concerns

I thank the authors for addressing the concerns raised and doing the requested additional analysis.

The end-to-end arm in the table in Q1 is the case where the dependencies are inferred: 0.989–0.995 of the valid answers are accepted and 0.994–1.000 of the unsupported ones are rejected.

Such high numbers are incredible and somewhat hard to believe. It might be worthwhile to dig deep here and understand where such high numbers are coming from.

Again, thanks for all the work and I currently retain my recommendation.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer WHpW

Thank you for reading our response and for raising this point. The end-to-end arm reaches 0.989–1.000 on MemAB-FC answers because the verdict of the check follows directly from the dependency map, and on MemAB-FC the Interpreter builds that map almost exactly.

Given a dependency map, the check of Definition 2.2 is a walk over the map without an LLM call, so its verdicts can be wrong only where the map is wrong. We compared the end-to-end map with the benchmark's structured updates fact by fact. At 6K, the two agree on the standing of all 455 facts. At 32K, they agree on 2,294 of the 2,310 facts (99.3%). The nine errors of the end-to-end arm all come from records that the Interpreter built wrongly. The same agreement explains Table 8, where the end-to-end arm is within 1.5 points of the native arm in QA accuracy. MemAB-FC states each fact in one short sentence, and a replacement restates the subject and relation with a new value, so the Interpreter's task is comparatively well defined.

The same evaluation gives lower numbers where the task is harder, so the evaluation itself is not lenient. When GPT-4o also performs the association, recall is 0.43–0.55 on multi-hop questions (Table 12), and on the free-form continuations we wrote, the check rejects 54 of the 57 ungrounded ones (Section 4.4).

Thank you again for your careful engagement with our work.

Reviewer_gyfvOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a runtime verifier for interactional grounding in long LLM conversations: whether a continuation still rests on commitments that the conversation has not abandoned. An LLM Interpreter maps each utterance to one or more of eight epistemic operations (OBSERVE, HYPOTHESIZE, SUPPORT, UNDERMINE, REVISE, EXPAND-AWARENESS, RESOLVE, QUESTION), and a symbolic engine applies them to a dependency map that combines a DEL plausibility model, a labelled Dung argumentation framework, commitment records and support links. Given the record associated with a candidate continuation, the grounding check is a walk over the map, linear in its size and with no LLM call; retraction queries traverse the same links in reverse. The paper proves a standing invariant, conflict-free selective retraction, exact iterated retraction, and per-turn tractability under structural restrictions. Experiments with five QA models on ReviseQA, MemoryAgentBench FactConsolidation (MemAB-FC) and BEAM compare the verifier against LLM-only and RAG baselines, in a native arm that takes the benchmarks' structured updates and an end-to-end arm in which a GPT-4o Interpreter extracts every update from raw text.

Critical strengths
  1. The formal guarantees are complete for the stated setting. The paper proves conflict-free selective retraction (Proposition 2.3), exactness of the iterated affected set (Corollary 2.4), and a linear-time grounding walk and retraction query (Lemma 2.1, Proposition 2.5, the latter under the structural restrictions A1–A3). Because the check does not depend on the LLM once the dependency map is built, its correctness holds by construction, which is what a runtime verifier needs.

  2. The experiments are solid and the gains are consistent. On MemAB-FC the native verifier raises single-hop accuracy from RAG's 0.46–0.95 to 0.94–0.98 and multi-hop from 0.04–0.13 to 0.64–0.74, and all five QA models benefit. The end-to-end arm, in which GPT-4o extracts every update from raw text, stays within 2.26 points of native on ReviseQA and within 1.5 points on MemAB-FC (6K and 32K streams, three QA models), which supports robustness to interpretation errors. The native arm's QA prompts are only 97–174 tokens, against 753–811 for RAG.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The strongest results come from the native setting, in which the engine takes the benchmarks' structured, near-oracle updates. On BEAM, the only fully end-to-end benchmark, the gain is much smaller and partly absent: where every premise still stands, the verifier scores 0.347 against RAG's 0.353, with no significant difference for any QA model; it leads significantly on three of five models only where a premise was revised (0.249 against 0.202). The end-to-end arm also uses only GPT-4o as the Interpreter, although Table 2 shows that Interpreters differ widely (Phase 2 F1 from 0.59 to 0.91 under the same prompt), so robustness to weaker Interpreters is not shown.

  2. The evaluation does not match the paper's framing. The experiments compare only against RAG and LLM-only. Conversational memory systems that revise facts, such as Mem0 and Zep, appear only in the related work and a capability table (Table 10), not in any experiment. The introduction and threat model motivate the verifier with context-manipulation attacks, but no attack scenario is evaluated, so the threat model is disconnected from the evidence. More basically, the runtime check in the title, deciding whether a candidate continuation is grounded (Definition 2.2), is never evaluated: the experiments measure QA accuracy with the maintained state as evidence, retraction closure and latency. The step that associates a continuation with a record is assumed in Appendix A, and it is the step most exposed to an adversary.

Questions for authors
  1. (Clarification) Can you report a direct comparison with a conversational memory system that revises facts, such as Mem0 or Zep, on MemAB-FC or BEAM? Both retire superseded facts, so this comparison would show how much of the gain comes from dependency tracking rather than from fact revision alone.

  2. (Clarification) The introduction and threat model refer to context-manipulation attacks. Have you evaluated whether the verifier flags adversarially crafted continuations in any of the cited attack settings? If not, I suggest scoping the threat-model claims to match the evidence.

  3. (Clarification) Can you evaluate the grounding check itself, for example precision and recall on a labelled set of grounded and ungrounded continuations, including the step that associates each continuation with a record? This is the capability in the title, and the answer would materially affect my assessment.

4 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer gyfv – Part I

Thank you for your thoughtful and positive feedback on our work! We sincerely appreciate your insights and your recognition of the formal guarantees and the experimental results. We have run the experiments you asked for and address your specific comments below, beginning with Q3, which you note would materially affect your assessment.

Q3 (and W2). Direct evaluation of the grounding check, including the association step.

On labelled MemAB-FC answers the check of Definition 2.2 reaches precision 0.967–1.000 and recall 0.989–0.995 when the Interpreter builds the records from raw text. On free-form continuations that an LLM associates with a record, it reaches precision 0.906 and recall 1.000.

The first set is the 3,280 distinct answers that the QA models gave in the submitted MemAB-FC experiments, labelled grounded or ungrounded from the benchmark's own record of which facts were replaced. The end-to-end arm covers 6K and 32K, as in Table 8 of the revision.

Single-hop precisionSingle-hop recallMulti-hop precisionMulti-hop recall
Verifier (native)1.0001.0001.0001.000
Verifier (end-to-end)1.0000.9950.9670.989

The native arm takes its records from the same structured updates that the labels are derived from, so its score confirms that the implementation follows Definition 2.2. The end-to-end arm measures the method: the Interpreter builds the records from raw text, and every error of this arm comes from a record that it built wrongly.

In both arms each answer is associated with a record through the entities and the relation named in its question. When GPT-4o performs the association instead, without seeing which records still stand, no ungrounded answer is accepted, and recall is 0.961 on single-hop and 0.485 on multi-hop questions, pooled over the four stream lengths. Recall is lower on multi-hop questions because the LLM has to name the record at the end of a chain of facts. Appendix D.4 of the revision gives the results per stream length and for two further LLMs (Table 12).

The second, smaller set is 86 free-form continuations that we wrote on the two conversations of Section 3, the Phase 2 debugging session and the Phase 3 architecture deliberation (Appendix B.2 and B.3), 29 grounded and 57 ungrounded, each associated with a record by GPT-4o. The check accepts all 29 grounded continuations and rejects 54 of the 57 ungrounded ones. Of the 30 that present something nobody said as already agreed, it rejects 28. When each continuation is instead associated with the record that shares the most words with it, the check accepts 26 of the 29 and rejects 48 of the 57, so the LLM association improves both. Section 4.4 of the revision reports both sets (Table 4).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer gyfv – Part II

Q1 (and W2). Comparison with Mem0 and Zep, and how much of the gain comes from dependency tracking.

We ran Mem0 [1] and Graphiti, the open-source engine of Zep [2], as two further arms on MemAB-FC. Verifier (native) is ahead of both on single-hop and multi-hop questions for every stream length and QA model, significantly in 35 of 36 comparisons (exact McNemar, p < 0.05). The lead is 0.18–0.24 on single-hop questions and 0.50–0.56 on multi-hop questions.

The table follows Table 1 of the paper: each cell is single-hop / multi-hop accuracy, pooled over the 6K, 32K and 64K streams (300 questions per hop type and QA model). Mem0 is run with an extraction prompt that keeps every fact, which favours it: under its default prompt it scores 0.51–0.53 / 0.07–0.10.

QA modelRAGMem0GraphitiVerifier (native)
Qwen2.5-14B0.753 / 0.0900.757 / 0.2100.760 / 0.2100.940 / 0.773
Gemma-3-12B0.923 / 0.0930.800 / 0.2870.780 / 0.2400.987 / 0.787
GPT-4o-mini0.703 / 0.0700.740 / 0.2400.783 / 0.2100.980 / 0.773

Mem0 and Graphiti revise facts and do not track dependencies. On single-hop questions, where fact revision alone decides the answer, the verifier is ahead because they revise facts with an LLM: Mem0 still holds the replaced value for 23–29% of the replaced facts, and Graphiti for 6–9%. On multi-hop questions, where the answer depends on a chain of facts, they reach 0.21–0.29 and the verifier reaches 0.77–0.79. The standing control of Table 7 in Appendix D.2 attributes this difference to dependency tracking: it keeps the verifier's fact revision, retrieves records without following dependencies, and reaches 0.23–0.29 on the same streams and QA models. Section 4.2 of the revision reports this comparison (Table 2), with the protocol and the per-length results (Table 10) in Appendix D.2.

W1. Results outside the native setting, and robustness to weaker Interpreters.

With GPT-4o as Interpreter, the end-to-end arm is within 1.5 points of the native arm on MemAB-FC and within 2.26 points on ReviseQA (Section 4.3). We reran the end-to-end arm on MemAB-FC with two weaker Interpreters, GPT-4o-mini and a local Qwen2.5-32B, everything else unchanged. Relative to the native arm, accuracy drops by 0.5–3 points on single-hop and 7–7.5 points on multi-hop questions with GPT-4o-mini, and by 7–8 and 12–14 points with Qwen2.5-32B. Multi-hop accuracy stays at 0.62–0.74 with either Interpreter, against 0.02–0.09 for RAG.

Section 4.3 of the revision reports this result, and the table is Table 9 in Appendix D.2. Each cell is single-hop / multi-hop accuracy on MemAB-FC, pooled over the 6K and 32K streams (200 questions per hop type and QA model). The last three columns are Verifier (end-to-end) with the named Interpreter.

QA modelRAGVerifier (native)GPT-4oGPT-4o-miniQwen2.5-32B
Qwen2.5-7B0.445 / 0.0200.980 / 0.7350.975 / 0.7400.950 / 0.6600.900 / 0.615
Qwen2.5-14B0.745 / 0.0750.945 / 0.7950.940 / 0.8000.940 / 0.7200.875 / 0.670
Gemma-3-12B0.920 / 0.0850.990 / 0.8050.985 / 0.8200.980 / 0.7350.920 / 0.665

BEAM is a general open-domain benchmark that is not built around revision, and we include it to check the verifier on ordinary conversations. Where every premise still stands, the verifier and RAG do not differ significantly for any of the five QA models. Where a premise was revised, the verifier scores 0.249 against 0.202, and the difference is significant for three of the five QA models.

Q2 (and W2). Threat model and attack settings.

We have not evaluated the verifier in the cited attack settings, and we accept the suggestion. The revision scopes the claims to the property. The abstract no longer introduces the problem through attacks, and the introduction presents context manipulation as one source of ungrounded continuations.

The list of revisions is in the general response. We are glad to run further checks during the discussion period.

References

[1] Chhikara, P., Khant, D., Aryan, S., Singh, T., and Yadav, D. Mem0: Building Production-Ready AI Agents with Scalable Long-Term Memory. ECAI 2025.

[2] Rasmussen, P., Paliychuk, P., Beauvais, T., Ryan, J., and Chalef, D. Zep: A Temporal Knowledge Graph Architecture for Agent Memory. arXiv:2501.13956, 2025.

Reviewer_gyfvOpenReview ↗

Response to the authors

Thank you for the detailed response and the additional experiments.

Your answers address my concerns.

  • Q3 / W2: Section 4.4 now evaluates the grounding check directly. On the 3,280 labelled MemAB-FC answers, you report precision 0.967–1.000 and recall 0.989–0.995 for the end-to-end arm. On the 86 free-form continuations with LLM association, you report precision 0.906 and recall 1.000. This is the evaluation I asked for.
  • Q1: you added Mem0 and Graphiti on MemAB-FC (Table 2). The verifier is ahead in 35 of 36 comparisons, and the standing control attributes the multi-hop difference to dependency tracking.
  • W1: the results with GPT-4o-mini and Qwen2.5-32B as the Interpreter (Table 9) show the cost of a weaker Interpreter: 7–7.5 and 12–14 points on multi-hop questions.
  • Q2: you state that the attack settings were not evaluated, and the revision scopes the claims to the property. This removes the mismatch between the threat model and the evidence.

I keep my rating at 3 (weak acceptance).

We sincerely thank Reviewer gyfv for the positive feedback and we are glad that our response addresses your concerns. Your comments made our evaluation more direct and our comparisons more convincing. We appreciate your time and support.

Reviewer_qFxSOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a hybrid framework to improve grounding and consistency in long-running LLM conversations. It does this with an approach that combines an interpreter with a symbolic engine that maintains a dependecy map of claims. This enable a runtime verification of whether generated continuations remain grounded in valid conversational, as well as the identification of conclusions affected by retracted premises. Experiments are conducted on three QA benchmarks and demonstrate improvements over RAG baselines.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a clear limitation of LLMs, and the proposed combination of LLMs with symbolic engine allows for more interpretable decisions, and it does it being computationally efficient. The line of research is interesting and overall this paper can be of valuable for the community.

Critical weaknesses

While I appreciate the idea behind the paper, I believe it requires substantial improvements before I can recommend acceptance.

  • the paper is not ready to follow. It introduces too many theoretical concepts without sufficient intuition, making it difficult to identify the actual novelty. For instance, the distinction between existing symbolic reasoning mechanisms and the authors' specific contributions could be articulated more clearly.
  • The other main weakness that I found is on the evaluation. While improvements are clear, I did not see how it would perform when compared to existing systems that are cited as related work section (e.g. Mem0). What does it prevent you to run a comparison?
Questions for authors
  • When the dependency map does not come with a known record association, how does total latency and cost compare across different conversation lengths?
  • Related to my point on the novelty of this paper, what are the components responsible for the improvements?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qFxS – Part I

Thank you for your review and for the concrete questions! We ran the comparison you asked for and address your comments in order.

W1. Intuition for the formal concepts, and what is new relative to existing symbolic mechanisms.

In plain terms, the verifier keeps a record of every claim made in the conversation, together with two pieces of information: whether the claim still stands, and which earlier claims it rests on. A continuation is grounded if the claim it builds on still stands and so does everything that claim rests on (Definition 2.2).

The dependency map of Definition 2.1 has four components. Two of them hold exactly these two pieces of information, and the check reads only these two. The other two record what has been observed and who committed to which claim. Section 3 and Appendix B.2 follow a debugging conversation through these definitions.

On novelty, truth-maintenance systems already record justifications and retract what depends on a withdrawn premise, and we build on them. In those systems a problem solver supplies the justifications in a formal language. Our contribution is to maintain them for a conversation in natural language:

  1. Eight operations through which an LLM Interpreter writes each utterance into the map, so that a program and not the LLM tracks dependencies.
  2. A guarantee that the records in good standing stay conflict-free under these operations and that a retraction flags exactly the conclusions that lose support (Lemma 2.2, Proposition 2.3, Corollary 2.4).
  3. Groundedness as a property of a continuation that is checked at every turn in linear time and without an LLM call (Proposition 2.5).

The "Formal foundations" paragraph of Section 5 in the revision states this distinction. The comparison with Mem0 in W2 and the component analysis in Q2 below measure what the dependency tracking adds.

W2. Comparison with existing systems such as Mem0.

Thank you for this suggestion. We have now run the comparison, with Mem0 [1] and Graphiti, the open-source engine of Zep [2], as two further arms on MemAB-FC. Verifier (native) is ahead of both on single-hop and multi-hop questions for every stream length and QA model, significantly in 35 of 36 comparisons (exact McNemar, p < 0.05).

The table follows Table 1 of the paper: each cell is single-hop / multi-hop accuracy, pooled over the 6K, 32K and 64K streams (300 questions per hop type and QA model). Mem0 is run with an extraction prompt that keeps every fact, which favours it: under its default prompt it scores 0.51–0.53 / 0.07–0.10.

QA modelRAGMem0GraphitiVerifier (native)
Qwen2.5-14B0.753 / 0.0900.757 / 0.2100.760 / 0.2100.940 / 0.773
Gemma-3-12B0.923 / 0.0930.800 / 0.2870.780 / 0.2400.987 / 0.787
GPT-4o-mini0.703 / 0.0700.740 / 0.2400.783 / 0.2100.980 / 0.773

Mem0 and Graphiti revise facts and do not track dependencies, and on multi-hop questions, where the answer depends on a chain of facts, they reach 0.21–0.29 against 0.77–0.79 for the verifier. Q2 below isolates this component. Section 4.2 of the revision reports this comparison (Table 2), with the protocol and the per-length results (Table 10) in Appendix D.2.

References

[1] Chhikara, P., Khant, D., Aryan, S., Singh, T., and Yadav, D. Mem0: Building Production-Ready AI Agents with Scalable Long-Term Memory. ECAI 2025.

[2] Rasmussen, P., Paliychuk, P., Beauvais, T., Ryan, J., and Chalef, D. Zep: A Temporal Knowledge Graph Architecture for Agent Memory. arXiv:2501.13956, 2025.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer qFxS – Part II

Q1. Latency and cost across conversation lengths when the record association is not given.

Per query the verifier takes 0.05 ms at 6K and 1.8 ms at 262K without an LLM call. Latency grows linearly with the conversation, and the number of tokens per query stays at 97–174. When an LLM performs the association, it adds one call of 0.68 s and about 460 tokens at every length.

Each MemAB-FC stream is a sequence of facts, and its name gives its length in tokens. The verifier finds the record from the entities and the relation named in the question, then walks the dependency map and renders the selected records. The table gives the median time of these steps over 100 questions on one CPU core, next to the retrieval step of RAG on the same stream.

StreamVerifier (single-hop / multi-hop)RAG retrieval
6K0.045 / 0.059 ms4.8 ms
32K0.15 / 0.21 ms17.7 ms
64K0.28 / 0.38 ms33.8 ms
262K1.46 / 1.81 ms136 ms

The verifier is 75–121 times faster than retrieval at every length. In tokens, it sends 97–174 per query at every length, against 753–811 for RAG and up to 114.5K for LLM-only (Section 4.6). Appendix E.2 of the revision adds the latency table.

When the dependency map is itself built from raw text, the Interpreter makes one call of about 210 tokens per incoming fact, 96.6K tokens for the 6K stream and 494.7K for the 32K stream. This cost is paid once per stream, and the per-query savings over LLM-only recover it after 16.3 and 15.3 of the 100 queries (Section 4.6).

When an LLM performs the association, it adds one call per checked answer. We timed 100 such calls with GPT-4o on MemAB-FC, 25 per stream length. A call takes 0.68 s (median) and 454 input and 10 output tokens, and both stay flat from 6K to 262K because the LLM always reads about 20 candidate records. Choosing these candidates takes 6 ms at 6K and 143 ms at 262K.

Q2. Which components are responsible for the improvements.

The improvement comes from the dependency map. Knowing which records still stand produces the single-hop gain, and knowing what each record rests on produces the multi-hop gain.

The method pairs an LLM Interpreter with a symbolic engine. The Interpreter maps each utterance to the eight operations, and the engine applies them to the dependency map. The map records two things: whether each record still stands, and which records it rests on. Three arms isolate these one at a time, each differing from the previous one in a single respect.

  • RAG does not use the map. It retrieves the top-50 facts from the whole stream with TF-IDF.
  • Verifier + TF-IDF is the control arm of the paper (Table 7 in Appendix D.2). It uses the same retriever and the same number of facts as RAG, restricted to the records that still stand.
  • Verifier (native) uses the same map and selects the records by following the dependencies from the entities in the question.

Each cell is single-hop / multi-hop accuracy on MemAB-FC, pooled over the four stream lengths (400 questions per hop type and QA model).

QA modelRAGVerifier + TF-IDFVerifier (native)
Qwen2.5-7B0.463 / 0.0400.930 / 0.1200.975 / 0.642
Qwen2.5-14B0.760 / 0.0830.968 / 0.2000.943 / 0.713
Gemma-3-12B0.917 / 0.0830.983 / 0.2530.983 / 0.733
GPT-4o-mini0.708 / 0.0650.980 / 0.2280.970 / 0.715
GPT-4o0.950 / 0.1300.975 / 0.3050.978 / 0.738

Restricting retrieval to the records that still stand brings every QA model to 0.93–0.98 on single-hop questions. Following the dependencies raises multi-hop accuracy from 0.12–0.31 to 0.64–0.74. On the streams and QA models of W2, Verifier + TF-IDF reaches 0.23–0.29 on multi-hop questions, the level of Mem0 and Graphiti (0.21–0.29), which revise facts without tracking dependencies.

That leaves the Interpreter. When it builds the map from raw text in place of the benchmark's structured updates, accuracy stays within 1.5 points (Table 8 of the revision). RAG and Verifier (native) are the arms of Table 1, and Table 7 gives all three arms per stream length.

The list of revisions is in the general response. We are glad to run further checks during the discussion period.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Follow-up to Reviewer qFxS

Dear Reviewer qFxS,

We are grateful for your review and the concrete questions you raised.

Your suggestion to compare with existing systems led us to run Mem0 and Graphiti as two further baselines (Section 4.2). The verifier is ahead of both for every stream length and QA model. Your question on latency led us to measure it at every stream length (Appendix E.2). Your request to clarify what is new relative to existing symbolic mechanisms also helped us state the distinction from truth-maintenance systems more clearly (Section 5). The general response lists all changes in the revised paper.

We would be grateful to know whether our response resolves your concerns, or whether any points still need clarification. Your comments will help us improve the paper either way.

Thank you again.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Response

Dear Reviewers, ACs, SACs and PCs,

We sincerely thank you for your careful reviews and constructive suggestions. We are encouraged that the reviewers recognised the formal guarantees, the simplicity of the mechanism and the empirical results. Below we summarise how we addressed the concerns, and then list the changes to the paper.

Concerns shared by several reviewers

  1. Direct evaluation of the grounding check (Reviewers gyfv and WHpW). We evaluated the check itself against labels, on answers from the MemAB-FC experiments and on authored continuations, including the case where an LLM performs the association. Given the benchmark's records the check makes no error, and it makes few when the Interpreter builds the records from raw text.
  2. Comparison with memory systems (Reviewers gyfv and qFxS). We ran Mem0 and Graphiti, the open-source engine of Zep, on MemAB-FC. The verifier is ahead of both for every stream length and QA model.

Concerns of individual reviewers

  1. Weaker Interpreters (Reviewer gyfv). We reran the end-to-end verifier with GPT-4o-mini and Qwen2.5-32B as the Interpreter. With either one, the verifier remains far ahead of RAG on multi-hop questions.
  2. Latency and cost (Reviewer qFxS). We measured the query latency at every stream length. The verifier needs no LLM call per query and is faster than the retrieval step of RAG at every length, and its number of tokens per query does not grow with the stream.
  3. Novelty and components (Reviewer qFxS). The related work now states the distinction from truth-maintenance systems, and our response isolates the contribution of each component.

Summary of changes (all marked in red in the revised PDF)

  • Abstract: removed the sentence on context-manipulation attacks. Introduction: added one sentence.
  • Section 4.2: added the comparison with Mem0 and Graphiti (Table 2).
  • Section 4.3: added the result with two weaker Interpreters.
  • Section 4.4 (new): direct evaluation of the grounding check (Table 4).
  • Section 5: added one sentence on truth-maintenance systems.
  • Appendix D.2: added the protocol of the memory systems and Tables 9 and 10.
  • Appendix D.4 (new): the two labelled sets and the results under LLM association (Table 12).
  • Appendix E.2: added the query latency (Table 15).

The method, the definitions and the submitted results are unchanged. The results and further details are in our point-by-point responses.

Your comments led to a more direct evaluation of our central claim, a stronger set of baselines and a clearer presentation, and the paper is better for them. Thank you again for your time and dedication in reviewing our submission.

Sincerely,

The Authors

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.