acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

ExecVLA: Following Fine-Grained Execution Constraints in Vision-Language-Action Models with Bi-Level Action Representation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

We study fine-grained execution-constraint following in vision-language-action (VLA) models. Given an invariant task goal, the policy must follow instruction-specified execution constraints, including interaction targets, motion patterns, spatial relations, and terminal configurations. This setting exposes a limitation of goal-oriented VLAs: trajectories that complete the same task are not interchangeable when the instruction specifies how the task must be executed. We propose ExecVLA, a framework that separates a goal-oriented component from an execution-specific component through a bi-level action representation and supervised bi-level reasoning tokens. We further introduce explicit goal-invariance and execution-predictability objectives so that the goal-level representation remains stable across executions of the same goal, while the execution-level representation retains the constraints that distinguish those executions. We construct execution-constraint-following datasets in simulation and on a Realman-75 robot, with goal and fine-grained reasoning annotations. Experiments on LIBERO and the real robot show improved goal completion and, more importantly, substantially more reliable adherence to instruction-specified execution constraints.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Execution-Aware, VLA

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_feAiOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

Existing VLA models often focus on completing the task but may not follow fine-grained requirements. The authors formulate this problem as "execution-constraint following". They use the "bi-level RVQ-VAE" to decompose actions into "goal-level" and "execution-level", where the former represents the task objective and the latter represents execution constraints. The authors also construct datasets with fine-grained execution constraints, including LIBERO-based simulation datasets and a real-world Realman-75 robot dataset, and achieve promising results on these benchmarks.

Critical strengths
  1. The authors focus on the problem of fine-grained execution constraints in VLA models. Rather than merely requiring robots to finish high-level task goals, this setting further requires the model to understand the task details.
  2. I believe this paper shows substantial human involvement; at least in some aspects, the authors did not simply delegate all of the work to AI.
Critical weaknesses

The authors do not provide an AI USE STATEMENT. Meanwhile, the paper contains several serious inconsistencies and figure issues, which raise substantial concerns about whether the manuscript was carefully checked, including:

  1. Figure 4 cheats reviewers and contains multiple inconsistencies between the bar heights and the reported values. Numbering the groups from left to right, with 1–3 on the top row and 4–5 on the bottom row:
  • In (1), there are visible image-editing artifacts around 76.5 and minor similar artifacts above 71.2 (I believe this is strong evidence for subjective editing);
  • In (2), the bar labeled 63.2 is clearly below the midpoint of 50 and 75, i.e., 62.5;
  • In (3), the bar labeled 61.5 is lower than the 61.5 bar in (2);
  • In (4), the bar labeled 92.6 is higher than the one labeled 93.2;
  • In (5), the bar labeled 92.2 is higher than the 93.2 bar in (4).
  1. The method name is inconsistent across figures. Figure 1 refers to the proposed method as “Kinematics-Aware VLA (Ours),” while the paper uses “ExecVLA”; Figure 4 instead uses “KineVLA (Ours).”

For the paper:

  1. The mathematical formulation is not sufficiently clear, and this's not conducive to the understanding of the paper:
  • LsepL_{sep} is introduced but not defined.
  • The roles and architectures of fTf_T and fAf_A are not specified.
  • tt is used for both robot time steps and text/action token positions, while TT denotes sequence length but also appears in the undefined TiT_i, which seems to refer to text or reasoning.
Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors explain the inconsistencies between the reported values and the bar heights in Figure 4? Please provide the exact numerical results and clarify how the figure was generated.
  2. Could the authors provide a more detailed analysis of the individual contributions of Lgoal−invL_{goal-inv} and LexecL_{exec}?
  3. Given the number of inconsistencies identified above, could the authors commit to a thorough re-check of the manuscript, including the figures, notation, and methodological descriptions, and ensure that these issues are carefully addressed in the revision?
Reviewer_hSuuOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies language-specified execution constraints that distinguish trajectories sharing a coarse task goal. The authors propose ExecVLA, which decouples actions into a goal-level and an execution-level via a bi-level RVQ-VAE and aligns them with supervised bi-level reasoning tokens plus a conditional mutual information regularizer to tie reasoning to motion. They also curate execution-constraint-rich datasets in simulation and on a Realman-75 robot and show consistent gains in execution-constraint adherence with matched goal success relative to chosen but somewhat outdated baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. The implementation is well-motivated. Introducing a bi-level residual vector-quantized action representation explicitly separates goal identity from execution-specific details, rather than relying on single-level tokenizers that entangle both.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Motivation and incremental contribution are insufficiently established. A coarse command leaves execution underdetermined; adding explicit constraints changes the conditioning information. Diffusion Policy[1] already models multiple valid action modes, although multimodality alone does not guarantee language controllability. The paper therefore needs to establish an advantage over standard language-conditioned BC, rather than broadly characterizing existing VLAs as rigid and goal-only. While the baselines do receive the same detailed instructions, demonstrations, and fine-tuning steps, the missing controls are matched structured-text supervision and training-data scaling. Many reasoning labels in Table 10 largely decompose or restate the input instruction. Table 2 does not distinguish the proposed bi-level design from a single-level policy trained with the same structured annotations. The discussion also omits closely related, execution-sensitive approaches such as action-space reasoning (ACoT[2]) and embodied chain-of-thought (ECoT[3]), and methods which also investigate on the “how to do” dimension (e.g., PRTS[4]). Consequently, both the novelty and the broad claims about current VLAs remain under-supported.

  2. The central method is difficult to follow and understand, and the experimental support is limited. Equation (4) defines both latents from the same action chunk, yet Section 3.1 simultaneously freezes the goal encoder and fine-tunes an undefined shared encoder. It is unclear when and through which parameters the goal-invariance loss is optimized; action reconstruction in Stage I alone does not establish goal invariance. Equation (9) omits reasoning from the action-conditioning history, while Eq. (11) permits a shared-context matching shortcut rather than establishing conditional mutual information. The semantic tokenizer losses lack separate ablations. Table 6 improves over GR00T by only one success per 40-trial family, without uncertainty estimates. ECSR criteria and the different Seen results in Tables 3 and 4 are insufficiently explained. Repeated citation-format errors in Sections 1-3 and undefined KineVLA/Kine-LIBERO/Kine-Realman labels in Figure 4 further impede an already difficult presentation.

Reference

[1] Chi, Cheng, et al. "Diffusion policy: Visuomotor policy learning via action diffusion." The International Journal of Robotics Research 44.10-11 (2025): 1684-1704.

[2] Zhong, Linqing, et al. "Acot-vla: Action chain-of-thought for vision-language-action models." Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. 2026.

[3] Zawalski, Michał, et al. "Robotic control via embodied chain-of-thought reasoning." arXiv preprint arXiv:2407.08693 (2024).

[4] Zhang, Yang, et al. "PRTS: A Primitive Reasoning and Tasking System via Contrastive Representations." arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.27472 (2026).

Questions for authors
  1. At different controlled demonstration counts , how does ExecVLA compare with well-tuned BC and a single-level policy trained to predict the identical structured reasoning labels?

  2. Please give the complete tokenizer computation graph and stage-by-stage loss/parameter table: where does the shared encoder sit relative to E_g/E_e, when are same-goal/different-execution pairs used, and what remains trainable? Please also specify the text/action token ordering and justify the conditional-MI interpretation.

  3. How does the textual bi-level reasoning in ExecVLA compare to action-space reasoning (e.g., ACoT-style explicit action thoughts)? An in-depth discussion is also appreciated.

Reviewer_UnGWOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies execution-constraint following in VLA models: different instructions share a coarse task goal but require different interaction targets, motion patterns, spatial relations, or terminal configurations. ExecVLA combines a bi-level vector-quantized action representation with supervised goal-level and execution-level reasoning text. Goal-invariance and execution-predictability objectives encourage the intended division of information, while a contrastive text–action alignment objective encourages consistency between generated reasoning and actions. The authors construct simulation and real-robot datasets and report improvements in execution-constraint success, including evaluations on held-out attributes and attribute combinations.

Critical strengths
  1. The evaluation problem is meaningful. Distinguishing goal completion from adherence to execution requirements captures failures that ordinary task-success metrics can overlook. The examples involving grasp regions, trajectories, drawer opening extent, and final orientations make this motivation concrete.

  2. The experiments provide positive evidence across simulation and real hardware. Table 4 reports consistent improvements over the evaluated baselines. Table 3 additionally tests unseen attributes and unseen attribute combinations, with gains of 8.6 and 10.0 percentage points over the strongest respective baselines.

  3. The component analyses are useful. Table 2 shows incremental improvements from the representation, reasoning supervision, and alignment objective. Table 7 supports complementary roles for the two code streams, while the reasoning intervention experiment indicates that generated intermediate text affects execution.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The contribution relative to language-based action hierarchies is insufficiently established. RT-H already predicts fine-grained language motions from observations and task descriptions and conditions action prediction on these intermediate motions. ExecVLA introduces a different factorization, but the paper does not adequately explain or experimentally isolate its benefit over this closely related approach. In particular, a comparison using the same backbone and annotations, with a single language-motion intermediate layer and matched action-token capacity, would help establish whether the proposed bi-level structure is necessary. See RT-H: Action Hierarchies Using Language.

  2. The evidence supports complementarity more directly than disentanglement. Goal-level alignment and execution prediction encourage the desired information allocation, but do not establish that the execution representation excludes goal information or that the goal representation is insensitive to execution details. Table 7 shows that both streams are useful, but does not resolve this distinction. Controlled code-swapping experiments and separate ablations of the two representation objectives would strengthen the central claim. Similarly, performance degradation under random or mismatched reasoning establishes sensitivity to intermediate text, but does not by itself establish faithful, scene-dependent reasoning.

  3. The generalization evidence has a narrower scope than the broader motivation suggests. I appreciate the held-out attribute and composition evaluations in Appendix A.1. However, the exact held-out values, combinations, dataset coverage, and exclusion procedure across tokenizer training and VLA adaptation are insufficiently specified. These tests do not establish that a constraint learned in one scene or task family transfers to another without adaptation. The paper should more clearly distinguish within-benchmark attribute composition from cross-scene or cross-task transfer.

  4. Important implementation and evaluation details remain unclear. The method operates on short action chunks, yet the goal-invariance loss is described using trajectories sharing a goal. It is unclear how chunks from different executions are paired and how episode-level reasoning and execution labels are aligned with the current action phase. The description of freezing the goal encoder while fine-tuning shared modules also needs clarification. For evaluation, the execution-success predicates, tolerances, aggregation, and uncertainty estimates are not sufficiently documented. These details matter particularly for the 2.6-point real-robot improvement over the strongest baseline in Table 4.

Questions for authors
  1. Relation to hierarchical policies: What capability specifically requires the proposed goal/execution factorization rather than a scene-conditioned language-motion hierarchy? Can you provide a controlled comparison with an RT-H-style intermediate layer using the same annotations and backbone?

  2. Representation analysis: Can goal and execution codes be swapped between appropriately matched demonstrations to test whether execution attributes change while the intended goal is preserved? What are the individual contributions of the goal-invariance and execution-predictability losses?

  3. Generalization protocol: Which attribute values and combinations are held out in Table 3, and from which training stages are they excluded? Does any evaluation transfer constraints across unseen scenes, objects, or task families without additional training?

  4. Chunk-level supervision: For H=5H=5, how are positive pairs constructed across trajectories with different durations or action phases? How are reasoning annotations aligned with each chunk, and which encoder components remain trainable when the goal path is frozen?

  5. Metric definition and statistical reliability: Does ECSR require both goal completion and constraint satisfaction? If so, how should the execution-only result in Table 7 be interpreted, where ECSR is 45.2% but goal success is 41.5%? Please provide the constraint predicates, tolerances, evaluation counts, and confidence intervals.

  6. Underspecified instructions: How does the full model behave when the instruction specifies only a goal or constrains only some execution attributes? Table 7 evaluates code removal, but does not directly establish compatibility with such instructions.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.