- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
Summary: The paper tackles how to automatically select the best combination of resources like LLMs, tools, and skills for an AI agent to successfully complete a given task. The authors define this problem as Task-Conditioned Agent Resource Composition. Instead of just finding individually useful tools, the goal is to create a complete bundle of resources that work together for a specific need.
Key COntributions: The paper's main contribution is a framework called Retrieval-Grounded Bundle-Aware Agent Generation. This system works in three main steps: 1) Retrieve: It first searches a large catalog to find relevant resources (models, tools) and historical examples of successful resource combinations for similar tasks. 2) Recombine: Using the retrieved items as a guide, a fine-tuned AI generator intelligently creates new, promising combinations (or "bundles") of resources and 3) Rerank: A special "bundle-aware critic" then evaluates these new bundles, scoring how well the components are predicted to work together. It reranks them to find the optimal configuration.
Evals: The aUthors validated their method on two benchmark datasets, AgentSelect and SkillsBench, comparing it against other baselines, including GPT-4
findings:
- THe optimal selction of the bundle outperforms baselines
- Showed that LLMs struggle to find good optimal composition of tools
- The framework can adapt to unseen resource domains.
Critical strengths
- High-Impact Problem Formulation: The paper introduces and formally defines AgentComposition (Task-Conditioned Agent Resource Composition). It uniquely shifts the paradigm from simple, individual tool retrieval to the holistic composition of synergistic "bundles" consisting of models, tools, and skills.
- Principled Three-Stage Architecture: The proposed Retrieve-Generate-Rerank framework is highly structured. By leveraging in-context historical compositions, constrained beam search, and a dedicated "bundle-aware" critic, it provides a robust and principled approach to generating compatible resource configurations.
- Strong Benchmark Performance: The methodology delivers good results on two major benchmarks, AgentSelect and SkillsBench, shows composition-aware modeling is superior to standard LLM selection.
- Empirical Execution Alignment: Rather than relying solely on static metric overlaps, the paper includes end-to-end execution validation. It successfully demonstrates a strong positive correlation between the critic's offline rankings and actual runtime success when the composed agents are deployed.
- Cross-Domain Generalization: The framework demonstrates transferability and adaptability. When evaluated on unseen resource domains, the model adapts and generalizes much more effectively than standard LLMs.
Critical weaknesses
- Post-Hoc Critic Disconnect: The bundle-aware critic is used only as a final reranker because incorporating its feedback directly into the beam search generation process actually degrades performance. This exposes a lack of architectural integration between the generator and the critic, which is a major methodological weakness.
- Low-Scale eval: The framework’s actual task-execution validation is limited to a very small sample size of 30 queries, resulting in high statistical variance.
- Incremental Architectural Novelty: The pipeline relies on a highly standard "Retrieve-Generate-Rerank" workflow common in recommendation systems. There is no formal mathematical formulation of the unique combinatorial challenges in agent resource composition, this seems more of a systems engineering paper rather than a foundational machine learning contribution.
- Training Cap from Teacher Dependency: The critic is trained entirely on preferences synthesized by a teacher LLM rather than actual runtime execution outcomes. This creates a performance ceiling where the system is bound to replicate the teacher's inherent biases and errors, rather than learning to discover novel, optimal tool combinations from real-world trial and error.
Questions for authors
- How does the proposed framework scale and perform when the underlying resource catalog is highly dynamic—such as when APIs, models, or skills are frequently updated, deprecated, or added in real-time?
- Your ablation studies (Section 5.1) revealed that integrating the Bundle-Aware Critic directly into the beam search generation process (Beam+Critic) actually degraded performance compared to using it as a post-hoc reranker. What is your hypothesis for why real-time guidance failed, and what architectural adjustments might allow the critic to constructively prune search paths during generation?
- Currently, the critic is trained using preference feedback synthesized by a "teacher" LLM. Have you explored training the critic directly on actual runtime execution success or error codes (RL from environment feedback) to bypass the performance ceiling imposed by a teacher model?
10 comments
rebuttal_G2FX_part2of7(W1,Q2)
W1: Post-Hoc Critic Disconnect: The bundle-aware critic is used only as a final reranker because incorporating its feedback directly into the beam search generation process actually degrades performance. This exposes a lack of architectural integration between the generator and the critic, which is a major methodological weakness.
Q2: Your ablation studies (Section 5.1) revealed that integrating the Bundle-Aware Critic directly into the beam search generation process (Beam+Critic) actually degraded performance compared to using it as a post-hoc reranker. What is your hypothesis for why real-time guidance failed, and what architectural adjustments might allow the critic to constructively prune search paths during generation?
Summarized W1 & Q2: ① The critic only reranks, and guiding search with it lowers performance. ② Why does this guidance fail? (Reviewer BU35 asked the same in W2.) ③ What changes would let the critic prune search usefully?
A1 for W1 and Q2 (Clarification, Explanation, Additional Experiments, Revised Paper): We thank the reviewer for this comment and question on the role of the critic. We apologize that the original submission did not clearly explain the design purpose of the critic. Below, we first clarify why we designed the critic (①), then explain why guiding search with it lowers performance (②), and finally report how it performs inside search (③). The changes are highlighted in (Sections 3.3 and 5.1, Figure 2).
① Design motivation. The critic is a proxy for real execution. Executing candidate configurations at scale is costly and often not possible, especially for a cold-start system. The critic therefore estimates how well a complete configuration will execute without running it. It learns from an LLM teacher (Stage 1) and from counterfactual perturbations judged against references (Stage 2). When execution feedback is available, the new Stage 3 adapts it to that feedback.
See screenshot: Revised Section 3.3
② Why guidance during search fails. The critic is trained to score complete configurations. A partial configuration can score low even when it would grow into a strong one, so applying the critic during search prunes promising paths too early.
③ The critic guided search. Retrieval is the main bottleneck: of the 162 queries whose reference configuration is missing from the candidate pool, 147 miss a backbone or tool that retrieval never returned. Better search can fix at most 15 queries (2.4%), and better ranking up to 41 (6.5%). The critic therefore pays off in reranking, not in guiding search. Larger gains need wider retrieval coverage, or using the critic as a training reward for the generator (see A4). Details follow.
Evidence that guidance adds little. We further train a prefix value model (V) and a critic (Q) on partial configurations. V guides search, and Q reranks the final list.
Setting (200 held-out queries) Top-1 execution score (0–10) No critic (generator only) 7.58 Final reranking, Stage 1+2 critic 8.37 Final reranking, + Stage 3 8.78 Stage 3 prefix value model guiding search and critic reranking 8.57
- Reranking helps, and direct guidance hurts. As a final reranker, the critic lifts the score from 7.58 to 8.78. Guiding search lowers it to 8.57.
- Prefix-value guidance adds nothing. Against reranking by the same Q, the Top-1 score is unchanged on 198 of 200 queries: guidance swaps a beam slot on 34 queries but changes only 4 Top-1 configurations (2 tied, 2 lower). RDCR@10 is 59.36% vs. 59.43%.
Why search has little room. For each of the 629 AgentSelect test queries, we trace where the reference configuration ends up.
Where the reference configuration is Queries Already in the Top-10 426 In the candidate pool, but ranked outside the Top-10 41 Not in the pool: reference backbone missing 100 Not in the pool: reference tool combination missing 50 Not in the pool: both missing 12
- Better search can recover at most 15 queries (2.4%). It can only fix the 50 tool misses, and in 35 of them retrieval never returned the needed tools.
- Better ranking can recover up to 41 queries (6.5%). This is where the critic acts.
rebuttal_G2FX_part3of7(W2)
W2: Low-Scale eval: The framework's actual task-execution validation is limited to a very small sample size of 30 queries, resulting in high statistical variance.
Summarized W2: Concern that the execution validation uses only 30 queries, so its results have high variance.
A2 (New Datasets, Additional Experiments, Revised Paper): We thank the reviewer for raising this point, which Reviewer mdAD also raised in W6. We agree that 30 queries are too few for the task-execution validation.
→ In the revision, we evaluate on more queries and add datasets with execution outcomes:
| Mode | Dataset | Executed by | Evaluated by | Queries | Agents | Executions | Evaluations | Used for (where) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Offline | AgentSelect-Exec (new) | Us | Us (GPT-5.6-Terra judge) | 506 | 10 per query | 5,060 | 5,060 | Training the critic on execution feedback (Stage 3), structural ablation, and alignment of rankings with execution (Section 5.1, Figure 2, Appendix F) |
| Offline | BFCL (new) | Official release | Official execution check | 240 | 18 per query | 4,320 | 4,320 | Transfer to a new domain with native rewards, with and without target training (Section 5.2, Table 4, Appendix G) |
| Offline | SWE-Skills-Bench (new) | Official release | Official hidden tests | 980 | 8 per query | 7,840 | 7,840 | Same as BFCL, on software-engineering tasks (Section 5.2, Table 4, Appendix G) |
| Offline | SkillsBench (new) | Official release | Official hidden tests | 21 | 93 in total | 255 | 255 | Ranking strong and closely matched agents (Appendix M.4, Figure 6) |
| Online | SkillsBench | Us | Us (GPT-5.6-Terra judge) and official native verifier | 5 | Top 1 agent × 2 (ours + 1 baseline) | 40 (1 + 3 runs each) | 80 | Executing the recommended agents of ours and a baseline under native verifiers (Section 5.3, Appendix M.3) |
| Online | AgentSelect | Us | Us (GPT-5.6-Terra judge) | 25 | Top 10 agents (ours) + Top 1 agent × 2 baselines | 300 | 300 | Executing the recommended agents of ours and two baselines, and our full top-10 list (Section 5.3, Appendix M.5) |
The changes are highlighted in .
See screenshot: Revised Section 4.1 and Table 1
See screenshot: Revised Appendix D.1, execution datasets
rebuttal_G2FX_part1of7(Opening)
Thank you for your careful review and for
We sincerely thank you for this insightful review.Your questions went beyond what the paper reported and asked how the method itself could improve: how the critic could guide search, whether it could learn from execution feedback, and how it would cope with a changing resource catalog. These questions shaped much of our revision. The new experiments directly address most of your concerns: the scale of the execution evaluation (W2), learning from execution outcomes (W4, Q3), and dynamic catalogs (Q1).Two points are more a matter of perspective than of evidence: why the critic reranks complete configurations instead of guiding search (W1, Q2), and how to view our contribution beyond a standard pipeline (W3). We explain our reasoning in detail and warmly welcome further discussion on both. All revisions, and how they are marked, are summarized in the General Response.