- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PILOT, a world action model that uses learned Motion-CoT tokens to guide action generation. It combines future-representation supervision with asymmetric attention to separate motion semantics from trajectory refinement, while avoiding explicit future-frame generation during inference. Experiments on simulation benchmarks and real-world robotic tasks evaluate its manipulation performance, robustness, and data efficiency.
Critical strengths
- The paper presents a clear motivation supported by qualitative analyses. The method is coherent, well justified, and closely aligned with the identified problem.
- The evaluation covers multiple simulation benchmarks and real-world tasks, demonstrating competitive performance. The ablation studies further support the effectiveness of the proposed components.
Critical weaknesses
1.The real-world evidence for generalization and data efficiency is limited. Although eight standard tasks are evaluated, both the generalization and few-shot experiments are restricted to the Pen task. Broader evaluations across different manipulation skills and demonstration budgets are needed to establish whether the reported benefits extend beyond this specific setting.
Questions for authors
1.Could the authors evaluate whether Motion-CoT representations remain consistent under appearance changes that preserve the underlying motion, while remaining sensitive to changes in motion under similar visual conditions? 2. Could the authors provide more direct comparisons with motion-based methods such as HiF-VLA, CoWVLA,. etc? These comparisons would help clarify the advantages of Motion-CoT in representation learning and downstream control.
3 comments
Question1: Is Motion-CoT stable to appearance changes and sensitive to motion changes?
Answer: Thank you for proposing this targeted analysis. Using a frozen PILOT model trained on RoboCasa-GR1, we designed two experiments to quantify how stable Motion-CoT is under appearance changes and how sensitive it is to motion changes.
First, we separately vary motion instructions and object appearance to quantify Motion-CoT's sensitivity to motion semantics and visual appearance using cosine distance. Second, we construct two sets of replacement query keys/values: one generated for the same pick-and-place action type but a visually different target receptacle in the same scene, and another generated for a different action under unchanged object appearance. We substitute each set into the Receiver while keeping its original input fixed. Comparing task success under these interventions tests how action generation responds to changes in the instruction-conditioned query content while the Receiver's own inputs remain fixed.
1. Appearance sensitivity versus motion-instruction sensitivity. For each task, we select 40 episodes with different initial scenes. From each episode, we construct two variants through randomly sampled changes. The motion variant changes the action instruction while preserving the original visual observation and robot state. The appearance variant changes the target object's visual appearance while preserving the motion-instruction, object positions, robot configuration, and camera pose. We run frozen PILOT on the three matched initial inputs and extract their Motion-CoT representations.
We compare each variant with the original using cosine distance between their flattened Motion-CoT representations. Smaller distances indicate greater representational consistency. We average the appearance-induced and motion-induced distances separately across the 40 episodes.
| Task | Scenes | Appearance variant distance | Motion variant distance | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CuttingboardToPot | 40 | 0.1338 | 0.4209 | 3.15 |
| PlacematToBowl | 40 | 0.0519 | 0.1437 | 2.77 |
Appearance variations preserve what the robot should do and leave Motion-CoT comparatively close to its original representation. Changing the requested movement produces a larger shift in both tasks, with a pooled distance 3.04 times that induced by appearance changes. This pattern suggests that Motion-CoT emphasizes information about how the robot should act while remaining relatively stable to visual differences that do not change the task.
2. Replacing query content. Receiver and Donor are two inference passes through the same frozen model. The Receiver and Donor receive identical visual inputs and noisy action tokens. The Receiver uses the original task instruction, while the Donor uses a modified instruction. At each Receiver observation, the Donor uses the identical image and robot state but receives a modified instruction. At each layer, we replace the keys/values of the Receiver’s query tokens with the corresponding keys/values from the Donor. The Receiver retains its original visual-language context, proprioception, and action noise.
The identical-input control gives the Donor the Receiver's original instruction and reproduces the original actions. We then compare two content interventions:
- Same action type, different target receptacle: Both instructions require picking and placing the same manipulated object, but refer to visually different target receptacles in the same scene. For example, the Receiver places the eggplant in the pot, whereas the Donor places it in the bowl. The visual observation is unchanged; the intervention changes which receptacle the instruction designates as the destination.
- Same object, different action type: Both instructions refer to the same object, but require incompatible operations. For example, the Receiver places the eggplant in the pot, while the Donor cuts the eggplant with a knife.
Each condition uses 12 paired scenes per task. Success is measured against the Receiver's original instruction.
| Task | Original | Same action type, different destination | Same object, different action type |
|---|---|---|---|
| CuttingboardToPot | 8/12 | 6/12 | 0/12 |
| TrayToPlate | 10/12 | 10/12 | 1/12 |
Preserving the action type while changing the destination retains substantial task performance, with success changing from 66.7% to 50.0% on CuttingboardToPot and remaining at 83.3% on TrayToPlate. Changing the action type while retaining the same object reduces success to 0% and 8.3%, respectively. Thus, incompatible action content in the queries disrupts execution much more strongly than a conflicting destination, even though the Receiver retains its original observation and instruction. These results show that Motion-CoT encodes how to act, rather than merely what objects look like, providing motion-specific guidance for action generation.
Question2: How does PILOT compare with HiF-VLA and CoWVLA in downstream control?
Answer: Thank you for recommending these motion-based methods. We add their reported results on standard LIBERO:
| Success (%) | Spatial | Object | Goal | Long | Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HiF-VLA | 98.8 | 99.4 | 97.4 | 96.4 | 98.0 |
| CoWVLA | 97.2 | 97.8 | 94.6 | 92.8 | 95.6 |
| PILOT | 97.1 | 99.2 | 98.1 | 97.2 | 97.9 |
PILOT achieves comparable overall performance to HiF-VLA, 97.9% versus 98.0%, with higher success on Goal and Long by 0.7 and 0.8 percentage points. Compared with CoWVLA, PILOT improves the average by 2.3 points, with gains of 1.4/3.5/4.4 points on Object/Goal/Long. Its strongest results are therefore on goal-conditioned and long-horizon manipulation, where coordinating motion intent with trajectory execution is especially important.
The methods also differ in how motion guidance is learned. HiF-VLA integrates motion-vector representations with action learning, while CoWVLA learns latent motion from a video representation factorized into structure and motion. PILOT learns its queries inside the flow-based action model and supervises them as conditions for current-to-future representation prediction. This lets the same action model learn predictive motion guidance and fine-grained trajectory generation, with asymmetric attention keeping the guidance independent of action sampling noise. We have included these results and the method comparison in the revised manuscript.
Thank you for your suggestion. We have added the comparative results and discussion of HiF-VLA and CoWVLA to Appendix A.5 (p. 19) of the revised manuscript.
References
- [HiF-VLA] Lin, Minghui, et al. "HiF-VLA: Hindsight, Insight and Foresight through Motion Representation for Vision-Language-Action Models." arXiv preprint arXiv:2512.09928, 2025. Table 4.
- [CoWVLA] Yang, Fuxiang, et al. "Chain of World: World Model Thinking in Latent Motion." arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.03195, 2026. Table 1.
Summary of Responses and Revisions: We sincerely thank you for your thoughtful review and suggestions on real-world generalization, motion-versus-appearance sensitivity, and motion-based VLA comparisons. In response, we added Book experiments under visual perturbations and reduced-data training, provided representation-distance and query-replacement analyses, and compared PILOT with HiF-VLA and CoWVLA in performance and motion-guidance design. We also replaced “few-shot” with “reduced-data” terminology and specified the demonstration counts. We have revised the manuscript based on your feedback and re-uploaded the updated version, with revisions highlighted in blue.
Weakness1: Real-world generalization and data efficiency need broader experiments.
Answer: Thank you for your suggestion. We additionally evaluate generalization and reduced-data performance on the "Book upright-placement" task, which requires grasping, orientation adjustment, and precise placement into a storage rack. For reduced-data training, PILOT and pi0.5 use the same fixed subset of 400 Book trajectories. The Standard column retains the previous full-data results from 50 rollouts. The next three columns evaluate lighting and camera changes (F+C), a changed desk surface/background (Desk), and changed object color (Color), with 20 rollouts per condition. The final column evaluates the reduced-data models under standard visual conditions, also with 20 rollouts.
PILOT improves over pi0.5 by 10/15/15 points under F+C/Desk/Color and by 25 points in the reduced-data setting. It retains 62.5% of its full-data success with 400 demonstrations, compared with 23.8% for pi0.5. Despite pi0.5's higher full-data score, PILOT performs better in every generalization and reduced-data condition. These results demonstrate PILOT's stronger robustness to visual changes and better data efficiency on orientation-sensitive placement. Thank you for this helpful suggestion. We agree that "reduced-data training" is a more accurate description of the 400-demonstration setting than "few-shot learning." We have revised this terminology throughout the manuscript and explicitly stated the demonstration counts to clarify the scope of our data-efficiency evidence.
Thank you for your suggestion. We have added the discussion and additional experiments on Book-task generalization and reduced-data performance to Appendix A.4 (p. 18) of the revised manuscript.