acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Latent Multimodal Memory Reasoning

Abstract

Long-term personalized agents are required to reason over distributed history across modalities and evolving dialogue states. While existing flat cross-modal methods compress visual evidence prematurely and struggle with temporally stale observations, they neglect the necessity to unify multimodal and cross-session evidence. Crucially, raw multimodal memories are inherently entangled and heterogeneous, making fine-grained visual grounding and cross-modal reasoning computationally prohibitive. To this end, we present latent multimodal memory reasoning, i.e., *LMMR*, a novel neuro-symbolic framework that shifts long-term multimodal memory organization into a continuous latent space. Specifically, instead of converting images to text and relying on static retrieval, *LMMR* maps both textual hidden states and visual patch features into a shared Sparse Autoencoder concept space, establishing sparse activations as common semantic addresses to dynamically construct a turn-level multimodal memory graph. A graph encoder then aggregates cross-modal and temporal dependencies across the task-specific latent subgraph, injecting the graph readout as a continuous residual rollout into the generation backbone while retaining native visual tokens to preserve fine-grained details. Extensive experiments on nine Mem-Gallery tasks and twelve MemEye settings demonstrate that *LMMR* significantly outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in capturing complex multimodal dependencies while enabling faithful and grounded responses.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
long-term memory, multimodal memory, memory reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_Ju19OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes LMMR, a framework for long-term multimodal memory reasoning that combines shared sparse semantic concepts, graph-structured memory organization, and continuous latent reasoning. The method maps textual hidden states and visual patch features into a shared sparse autoencoder concept space, uses the resulting semantic activations to construct query-conditioned multimodal memory graphs, and injects graph representations into the language model through a latent reasoning rollout. Native visual tokens are retained to preserve fine-grained visual evidence. The framework is evaluated on Mem-Gallery and MemEye, with experiments indicating improvements over several text-based and multimodal memory baselines. Ablation studies examine the contributions of textual memory, visual memory, and latent reasoning.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper targets an important problem beyond conventional multimodal retrieval. Correctly retrieving historical visual content is not sufficient when answering a query requires entity resolution, cross-session integration, and temporal validity. LMMR explicitly models these relationships through a query-conditioned memory structure rather than treating retrieved images and text as independent context. This is a meaningful direction for long-term multimodal agents.

  2. The proposed architecture integrates semantic organization with fine-grained visual evidence. Shared sparse concepts provide a potential mechanism for linking text and image content, while native visual tokens preserve perceptual information that would otherwise be lost through abstraction. The evaluation on both Mem-Gallery and MemEye, including transfer to an additional benchmark, is a positive aspect of the empirical study.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The necessity and novelty of the shared SAE concept space are not sufficiently isolated. Existing research has already investigated multimodal sparse autoencoders and shared cross-modal concept dictionaries. LMMR introduces a particular application of such representations to graph-based memory reasoning, but the current evidence does not establish why sparse concept addresses are essential for the observed improvements. Comparisons with dense cross-modal embeddings, conventional contrastive alignment, or alternative concept-linking mechanisms under the same graph architecture would be important for substantiating the contribution.

  2. The current ablations do not fully separate the effect of latent reasoning from the effect of structured evidence integration and model capacity. Removing the latent reasoning component produces a large accuracy decrease, but this does not by itself demonstrate that a continuous latent rollout is superior to other mechanisms for incorporating graph information. A parameter-matched alternative that directly conditions the decoder on the same graph representation would provide a more decisive comparison. Moreover, the additional complexity of SAE construction, graph encoding, and latent rollout deserves a clearer end-to-end efficiency analysis.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors replace the shared SAE dictionary with a dense shared representation trained using standard cross-modal alignment, while keeping the same graph construction, reasoning backbone, and training budget? How much of the performance gain specifically depends on sparse concept addressing?

  2. Can the authors compare latent graph injection against direct graph-to-decoder conditioning or cross-attention fusion using the same retrieved evidence and comparable parameter counts? This would clarify whether the benefit comes from the continuous latent reasoning process or from additional structured evidence integration.

  3. How is temporal validity operationalized in the memory graph? In particular, how does the method distinguish newer observations that supersede earlier states from observations that merely refer to the same entity at different times? Can the authors provide targeted temporal-update and conflicting-evidence evaluations?

  4. What are the end-to-end latency, peak memory usage, graph construction cost, and retrieval cost as the number of historical turns increases? How do these quantities compare with strong multimodal retrieval baselines at matched accuracy?

8 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Ju19 (1/5)

We sincerely appreciate your careful reading and your positive assessment of our work. We hope the following responses fully resolve the concerns you raised, and we would be grateful for your continued support as we finalize the paper.

Weakness #1 & Question #1

The necessity and novelty of the shared SAE concept space are not sufficiently isolated. Existing research has already investigated multimodal sparse autoencoders and shared cross-modal concept dictionaries. LMMR introduces a particular application of such representations to graph-based memory reasoning, but the current evidence does not establish why sparse concept addresses are essential for the observed improvements. Comparisons with dense cross-modal embeddings, conventional contrastive alignment, or alternative concept-linking mechanisms under the same graph architecture would be important for substantiating the contribution.

Can the authors replace the shared SAE dictionary with a dense shared representation trained using standard cross-modal alignment, while keeping the same graph construction, reasoning backbone, and training budget? How much of the performance gain specifically depends on sparse concept addressing?

Answer to Weakness #1 & Question #1.

We appreciate this thoughtful comment. Multimodal sparse autoencoders and shared concept dictionaries have indeed been studied, and we have cited and discussed this line of work in Sec. 2. Our use is different: the sparse dictionary is trained jointly with the answer generator and serves as the common address space through which the text and the images of a long dialogue meet, both in the alignment objective and in the concept message of the turn graph. Unless stated otherwise, all results in this response are on Mem-Gallery with Qwen2.5-VL-7B as the backbone.

To examine whether this shared sparse space is the right choice under the same graph architecture, we replace it by several alternatives. The memory, the turn graph, the backbone, the latent reasoning and the training recipe are kept fixed, and only the shared space or the way the nodes are linked changes. w/ Dense Embedding uses a dense cross-modal embedding model (the retriever of MuRAG) as the shared space. w/ Contrastive Alignment replaces the dictionary with a dense space aligned by a standard contrastive loss. w/ Dense Link and w/ Random Link, set apart by a dashed line in the table, keep the dictionary but link the turn nodes by dense nearest neighbours, or at random.

Table R1. Alternative shared spaces and linking mechanisms under the same graph architecture.

MethodF1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑
LMMR (Ours)79.1074.7963.4787.35
w/ Dense Embedding75.67 (↓3.43)71.54 (↓3.25)60.07 (↓3.40)83.45 (↓3.90)
w/ Contrastive Alignment75.91 (↓3.19)71.63 (↓3.16)60.79 (↓2.68)84.35 (↓3.00)
w/ Dense Link75.55 (↓3.55)71.34 (↓3.45)60.43 (↓3.04)83.81 (↓3.54)
w/ Random Link75.11 (↓3.99)70.82 (↓3.97)60.07 (↓3.40)83.27 (↓4.08)

Every alternative is below LMMR, and all of them stay well above the strongest baseline, MuRAG, so the shared sparse space and the concept-based graph are both needed for the best result. The reasons differ by alternative. With a frozen off-the-shelf embedding or a conventional contrastive space, text and images are compared by generic similarity, and nothing makes a turn and its images activate the same concept entries, so the graph cannot use shared concept addresses to bind them. With dense or random neighbours instead of concept links, the graph connects turns by overall similarity or by chance rather than by the concepts they share, so the memory state carries less of the evidence the question needs. MuRAG has neither a shared space nor a graph and falls furthest behind. In LMMR, the dictionary provides one set of discrete concept addresses for text and images, the concept message links turns through them, and the readout is a memory state tied to the right evidence. This is the advantage of the full design, and the sparse dictionary additionally provides addresses that can be read and inspected (Fig. 7).

What the shared sparse space contributes. The alignment is learned rather than given: image and text states are unrelated before training, and afterwards paired states are far closer than negatives and in-bank retrieval clearly improves, for both backbones (App. C.1–C.2). The dictionary is fitted once and frozen, and its entries remain coherent on MemEye without refitting (Fig. 7), where LMMR is evaluated zero-shot and obtains the best multiple-choice accuracy (Fig. 3). When more topics are mixed into one memory, LMMR stays stable while full visual context degrades (Fig. 4a). Dense cross-modal retrieval is already part of the comparison, since MuRAG retrieves with a dense cross-modal embedding model, and LMMR outperforms it (Table 1).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Ju19 (2/5)

Answer to Weakness #1 & Question #1, continued.

This comment led us to compare the shared space with alternative spaces and linking mechanisms under the same graph, which has made its role in LMMR considerably clearer, and we are grateful for it. We have added the shared-space and linking comparisons to Sec. 5.3, Table 2, and discussed related multimodal SAE work in Sec. 2.

Weakness #2 & Question #2

The current ablations do not fully separate the effect of latent reasoning from the effect of structured evidence integration and model capacity. Removing the latent reasoning component produces a large accuracy decrease, but this does not by itself demonstrate that a continuous latent rollout is superior to other mechanisms for incorporating graph information. A parameter-matched alternative that directly conditions the decoder on the same graph representation would provide a more decisive comparison. Moreover, the additional complexity of SAE construction, graph encoding, and latent rollout deserves a clearer end-to-end efficiency analysis.

Can the authors compare latent graph injection against direct graph-to-decoder conditioning or cross-attention fusion using the same retrieved evidence and comparable parameter counts? This would clarify whether the benefit comes from the continuous latent reasoning process or from additional structured evidence integration.

Answer to Weakness #2 & Question #2.

We appreciate this precise formulation. Table 2 removes the latent reasoning from the trained model, so it measures how much the trained model relies on it. It does not by itself separate latent reasoning from other ways of passing the graph output to the decoder.

To make this separation, we compare three ways of passing the graph output to the decoder, with the same retrieved evidence, graph, backbone and training recipe. LMMR passes it through latent reasoning. w/ Direct Conditioning maps it to a soft input token and decodes the answer directly. w/ Cross-Attention lets a few learned queries attend over the graph's node states to produce the input tokens.

Table R2a. Alternative ways of passing the graph output to the decoder: accuracy.

MethodF1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑
LMMR (Full)79.1074.7963.4787.35
w/ Direct Conditioning76.51 (↓2.59)72.03 (↓2.76)60.43 (↓3.04)83.99 (↓3.36)
w/ Cross-Attention76.62 (↓2.48)72.13 (↓2.66)60.07 (↓3.40)83.99 (↓3.36)

Passing the graph output to the decoder by direct conditioning or by cross-attention lowers the score relative to LMMR, and both remain far above MuRAG. We attribute this to the latent reasoning working on the graph representation: it integrates the graph readout with the dated turns step by step before the answer is written, whereas a single soft token or a one-shot fusion hands the graph evidence over once. In all three configurations, the structured evidence built on the shared space and the graph is what the baseline lacks, and the latent reasoning makes the fullest use of it.

End-to-end cost. The three configurations were also timed on one GPU, and Table R2b reports the time of each stage. Selection, the SAE with the graph, prefill and decoding are the same in all three, and the SAE and the graph together take under 7 ms, so the only stage that differs is the interface to the decoder. Their interfaces have a matched number of trainable parameters, so the comparison is not one of model capacity, and all three answer within the same order of time, about one to two seconds per query, with the same memory on top of the backbone weights. The comparison with the baselines and the scaling with the history length are in our response to Q4 (Tables R6 and R7).

Table R2b. Alternative ways of passing the graph output to the decoder: per-query time by stage.

MetricLMMR (Full)w/ Direct Conditioningw/ Cross-Attention
F1 ↑79.1076.5176.62
BLEU-1 ↑74.7972.0372.13
EM ↑63.4760.4360.07
L-Judge ↑87.3583.9983.99
Candidate selection and input assembly (ms) ↓19.519.018.1
SAE and graph (ms) ↓6.76.76.7
Prefill of the multimodal prefix (ms) ↓815809813
Interface to the decoder (ms) ↓4969097
Answer decoding (ms) ↓442462445
Total latency (ms) ↓1,7811,3881,381
Trainable parameters of the interface (M)12.912.99.4
Peak GPU memory over the weights (GB) ↓1.91.91.9
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Ju19 (3/5)

Answer to Weakness #2 & Question #2, continued.

LMMR reaches the higher scores of Tables R1 and R2a at a similar cost, and the extra time it spends, below half a second per query, is the interface itself, latent reasoning, which integrates the graph readout with the dated turns step by step before the answer is written. This is a trade-off between accuracy and time, and we consider it acceptable in the setting that LMMR is built for: a long-term assistant that answers once per user turn, where a response in under two seconds is natural in a conversation and where answering correctly about an earlier event, an update or a conflict is worth far more than a few tenths of a second.

What the existing results also separate. The gain is not more evidence: LMMR reads fewer retrieved tokens than the larger budgets of MuRAG, whose accuracy stays flat as its budget grows, and enlarging LMMR's own visible-image budget does not help (Table 3, Fig. 8). It is not more computation either, since the effect of latent reasoning saturates after a couple of steps (Fig. 8). All systems use the same backbone, and a latent step re-uses its weights (Eq. 6). The cost of the SAE, the graph and latent reasoning is broken down by stage in our response to Q4.

Your comment helped us state more clearly what Table 2 measures, and we are grateful for it. We have added the accuracy controls to Sec. 5.3, Table 2, the interface timings to Appendix C.3, Table 15, and the full-system stage breakdown to Appendix A.4, Table 10. Sec. 5.4 summarizes the runtime results.

Question #3

How is temporal validity operationalized in the memory graph? In particular, how does the method distinguish newer observations that supersede earlier states from observations that merely refer to the same entity at different times? Can the authors provide targeted temporal-update and conflicting-evidence evaluations?

Answer to Question #3.

We appreciate this question on temporal validity and reference, which is central to long-term memory. Deciding which state is valid takes two things: recognising that a later statement or image is about the same entity as an earlier one, and knowing which of the two is later. LMMR uses neither a hand-written recency rule nor an entity label for this. It gives the backbone dated, ordered evidence in which every image stays in the turn it came from, and it learns, from questions where the distinction decides the answer, whether a later statement replaces an earlier one or only mentions the same entity.

How validity and reference are handled.

  1. Provenance (Sec. 4.2). Every textual turn and every image entry stores its dialogue position and date, and the selected turns are shown in chronological order together with them.
  2. No name–image binding (Sec. 4.3). LMMR never ties a name to an image or an entity to a state. An image stays in its source turn, and the text, caption and image of that turn form one node of the graph. A later mention such as "the tag" is therefore read by the backbone together with the turns around it. There is no separate coreference module, and an image with two people is treated like any other image.
  3. Temporal message (Sec. 4.3). A turn node receives its temporal message from the current and earlier turns only, miT=∑j: tj≤tiβijxjm_i^{T}=\sum_{j:\,t_j\le t_i}\beta_{ij}x_j with attention weights βij\beta_{ij}, so a later turn is read relative to the observation it may revise. The concept message connects turns that activate the same dictionary entries. We have not ablated the temporal message on its own, so the evaluations below do not separate its effect from the rest of the model.
  4. Supervision. The answer loss covers the question types that depend on this distinction, and evaluation uses held-out conversations.

Targeted evaluations.

(a) Update, conflict and time questions in Mem-Gallery. Knowledge resolution asks for the currently valid fact after an update, conflict detection whether the history contradicts itself, and temporal reasoning for the order and dates of events across sessions. Table R3 gives LMMR minus the best baseline (Table 9). Conflict detection is a binary decision, which is why its four columns agree.

Reviewer_aa3zOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how multimodal agents can find and use relevant multimodal evidence from images and dialogue distributed across sessions and time. It maps text and image features into a shared concept space, organizes in a graph with temporal relationships, and provides the graph readout into a continuous latent reasoning stage. It also retains native visual tokens for selected images, keeping fine-grained evidence. Experimental results on Mem-Gallery and MemEye demonstrate the superior performance of LMMR. Also, the paper provides comprehensive ablations and implementation details.

Critical strengths
  • The paper investigates an important question with real-world use, how to use full multimodal dialogue memory to solve questions.
  • The performance is strong. Over two benchmarks, LMMR gains a substantial improvement against baselines. The authors also provide comprehensive analysis.
Critical weaknesses
  • One question is about the computational cost beyond tokens. Given the scenarios are real-world multimodal dialogue, whether constructing the graph and build time correlations will cost much more time than baselines would affect the usability of LMMR.
  • Also, I have some concerns about the performance and the experimental part. See the questions section. But I am not an expert in this area. I think some clarification will help.
Questions for authors
  • I am a little confused. The authors said that " MemEye is evaluated zero-shot using a model trained on Mem-Gallery" but "LMMR is instantiated on Qwen2.5-VL-3B/7B for MemGallery and on Qwen3-VL-8B for MemEye". How different models can zero-shot transfer.
  • I am wondering whether the authors could provide some failure cases of LMMR, which are also valuable for behavior analysis. Whether LMMR can find relevant but stale evidence, or just hallucinate misleading evidence.
  • Also, in Table 2, Latent Reasoning contributes super large performance improvement. I am not challenging the effectiveness of latent reasoning, which is shown effective in many latent reasoning papers. I am wondering why this affects so much. In most papers, even specialized latent reasoning papers, the improvement of latent reasoning would be substantial and moderate. The such large gap is a little wierd for me.
  • In Table 3, LMMR uses much less visual tokens but more textual tokens. My speculation would be that LMMR use visual patches instead of full images, while previous methods just keep the full images. If previous methods allow visual crops, whether their cost would be cutten much less?
7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer aa3z (1/4)

We thank you for the time and effort you devoted to reviewing our work. We hope the clarifications below address the points you raised, and we would sincerely appreciate it if you could re-evaluate our work in light of these responses and consider a more positive score in support of our contribution.

Weakness #1

One question is about the computational cost beyond tokens. Given the scenarios are real-world multimodal dialogue, whether constructing the graph and build time correlations will cost much more time than baselines would affect the usability of LMMR.

Answer to Weakness #1.

Thank you for the valuable question. Cost matters for judging whether LMMR is practical in real-world dialogue, and we are glad to address it directly. Unless stated otherwise, all results in this response are on Mem-Gallery with Qwen2.5-VL-7B as the backbone. To compare cost, we ran the official implementations of the baselines with the same backbone, on the same hardware and the same questions as LMMR. Table R1 reports the time to build the memory, the latency per query and the accuracy.

Table R1. Index time, latency and accuracy of LMMR and the official baselines.

MethodIndex time (s) ↓Latency (s) ↓F1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑
FC (T)–0.9336.2532.7925.1943.31
FC (V)–2.2233.5429.9922.7941.29
NaiveRAG3.9‾\underline{3.9}0.5359.7454.4141.6172.41
MuRAG19.70.8969.66‾\underline{69.66}64.32‾\underline{64.32}49.85‾\underline{49.85}82.29‾\underline{82.29}
NGM18.70.81‾\underline{0.81}66.9162.0049.4478.61
AUGUSTUS82.81.4766.1060.6947.5777.97
LMMR (Ours)2.11.8179.1074.7963.4787.35

Bold marks the best and underline the second best in each column. Three points stand out.

  • The graph is cheap. Graph construction and message passing take a few milliseconds per query, a negligible part of the latency, and grow only marginally with the length of the history.
  • Building the memory is fast. LMMR encodes each image once and forms the turn-level graph at query time, so indexing is about an order of magnitude faster than MuRAG and NGM.
  • A modest extra cost buys a large gain. LMMR needs under a second more per query than MuRAG, and in return improves every metric by a wide margin. Extra cost does not help the baselines: enlarging the budget of MuRAG several-fold leaves its score flat (Table 3).

We are grateful for this question, which led us to measure the cost of LMMR directly and made its practicality clearer. We have added the runtime comparison to Appendix A.4, Table 9, and updated the efficiency paragraph in Sec. 5.4.

Question #1

I am a little confused. The authors said that " MemEye is evaluated zero-shot using a model trained on Mem-Gallery" but "LMMR is instantiated on Qwen2.5-VL-3B/7B for MemGallery and on Qwen3-VL-8B for MemEye". How different models can zero-shot transfer.

Answer to Question #1.

Thank you for raising this point, and we are sorry that the wording in Sec. 5.1 caused a misunderstanding. We would like to clarify that no weights are transferred across backbones. LMMR is a recipe that we instantiate separately on each backbone, so that every comparison uses the same backbone as the published baselines of that benchmark.

"Zero-shot" refers to the data: the model evaluated on MemEye is trained on Mem-Gallery only and sees nothing from MemEye during training, and the shared dictionary is fitted on Mem-Gallery and kept frozen. MemEye therefore tests whether the learned concept space and memory organisation carry over to new tasks and new visual granularities.

We appreciate this question, which helped us make Sec. 5.1 more precise. To avoid this confusion, we have clarified in Sec. 5.1 that the Qwen3-VL-8B instance of LMMR is trained only on Mem-Gallery and evaluated zero-shot on MemEye.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer aa3z (2/4)

Question #2

I am wondering whether the authors could provide some failure cases of LMMR, which are also valuable for behavior analysis. Whether LMMR can find relevant but stale evidence, or just hallucinate misleading evidence.

Answer to Question #2.

Thank you for asking for failure cases, which are valuable for analysing the behaviour of LMMR and give a more complete picture than the successes shown in Fig. 6. To this end, we analysed all predictions behind Table 1. LMMR errs on a small fraction of the questions, and the errors fall into five groups, summarised in Table R2.

Table R2. Failure types of LMMR.

Failure typeFailuresMain tasks (failures)Share of failuresShare of all questions ↓
Evidence selection miss50VS 22, TTL 17, VR 1137.3%2.9%
Detail misread or miscounted36VR 30, TTL 626.9%2.1%
Wrong entity or decision29CD 11, VS 5, MR 521.6%1.7%
Outdated content10FR 4, MR 3, KR 27.5%0.6%
Incomplete or unsupported answer9TR 4, VS 36.7%0.5%
All failures134100%7.8%

Failures are answers with a judge score below 0.5. They make up only 7.8% of all questions, so LMMR does not fail on the other 92.2%, and none of the answer-refusal questions fails. The most frequent failure is an evidence selection miss: under the small, fixed visual budget, the needed image is not among the selected ones or another image of the same conversation is chosen. Answers that rely on outdated content are rare, 0.6% of all questions, and only 3 failures, 0.2% of all questions, are unsupported by the history.

We illustrate three cases from Mem-Gallery, with the images of the conversation and the answers of the official baselines run with the same backbone. The first two show how LMMR handles the two situations you ask about, relevant but outdated evidence and fabricated evidence, and the third is a case that LMMR and the baseline both miss.

Case 1: relevant but outdated evidence. "Does 'Leo chose travel faster than light as the natural law to change' conflict with the dialogue memory?" Over the session, Leo goes through several candidates and finally picks a different one, so the statement names a candidate that was later superseded and conflicts with the memory. LMMR answers Yes. MuRAG and the other official baselines answer No: none of them recognises that the earlier candidate was superseded. This is the situation the temporal message of the dialogue-turn graph is designed for (Sec. 4.3): a turn is read against the turns before it, so the final choice overrides the earlier candidates.

Case 2: no fabricated evidence. "List all types of clouds mentioned in the conversation." LMMR lists exactly the four types named in the history. The official full-context baseline with images adds two types that appear nowhere in the history. LMMR's answer contains only what the history contains.

Case 3: a failure beyond the method's scope. "What AI model did Lena use for her image classification project?" The reference names the model family, a convolutional neural network, while the next turn mentions starting from a pre-trained model such as ResNet. LMMR answers "ResNet" and MuRAG answers with the pre-trained models. Both answers are grounded in the history, and both are marked wrong because they name an instance rather than the family. Whether a question asks for the family or for the instance is a property of the question and its reference, not of the memory method. We count it as a failure.

We appreciate this request, which gave us a more complete view of how LMMR behaves, including where it fails. We have added the failure analysis and cases to Appendix C.8, Table 24 and Fig. 11, with a summary in Sec. 5.4.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer aa3z (3/4)

Question #3

Also, in Table 2, Latent Reasoning contributes super large performance improvement. I am not challenging the effectiveness of latent reasoning, which is shown effective in many latent reasoning papers. I am wondering why this affects so much. In most papers, even specialized latent reasoning papers, the improvement of latent reasoning would be substantial and moderate. The such large gap is a little wierd for me.

Answer to Question #3.

Thank you for this careful observation. We agree that a gap of this size calls for an explanation, and we are glad to give one. The Table 2 row removes more than a single component: it decodes from the same memory prefix without the whole learned reasoning stage of LMMR, that is, the adapted backbone, its memory modules and the latent reasoning. What this stage provides is the ability to read relations between observations: that a statement contradicts the memory, that one turn precedes another, that a picture shows the same breed as an earlier photo, how many images were shown. These relations are written in no single turn, so a backbone that only sees the retrieved text has nothing to copy, and this is where the gap lies.

The benchmark shows this pattern. Table R3 compares LMMR with MuRAG, the strongest explicit baseline, on each task. Where the answer is a relation, LMMR is far ahead, even though the retriever of MuRAG already returns the annotated evidence for most of these questions. Where the answer is stated in a single turn, or an image is simply found, the differences are small.

Table R3. Per-task difference between LMMR and MuRAG. Each metric is the score of LMMR minus that of MuRAG, and "Evidence retrieved" is the share of questions for which the retriever of MuRAG returns the annotated evidence.

Question typeTaskEvidence retrievedF1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑
Contradiction with the memoryCD76.5%+49.38+49.38+49.38+49.38
Order and relative timeTR69.9%+27.38+27.05+29.27+14.63
Latest state of a beliefKR69.1%+17.30+17.72+17.28+10.50
Counting across imagesVR67.2%+14.07+13.77+16.09+10.63
Matching a new picture to what was taughtTTL90.5%+8.02+13.94+22.55+2.22
Facts stated in a turnFR65.8%+6.42+6.98+5.03+1.83
Finding an imageVS94.8%−1.03−0.61+4.58−3.43
Recalling several entitiesMR76.2%+0.32−1.80+1.45−0.73

Table R4 gives one example for four of the types. In each question at least five of the six official baselines are wrong, and so is direct decoding, while LMMR answers correctly.

Table R4. Example questions that need a relation between observations. Direct decoding is the variant of Table 2 without the learned reasoning stage.

TypeQuestion and what is neededOfficial baselinesDirect decodingLMMR
Contradiction"Does the conversation show any conflict where Julian claims social robots cannot possibly affect human emotional well-being?" Julian says social robots offer companionship but carry a psychological cost. No turn says the claim is false.No (6 of 6)NoYes
Order"Did Alex complete building his team before analyzing Chinese e-commerce after-sales logistics?" The team-building turn comes before the logistics turn. No turn states the order.No (6 of 6)NoYes
Matching a picture"Is the dog in the picture the same breed as Lumi?" The picture matches Lumi's photos, and an earlier turn says Lumi is a Maltese. No text describes the pictured dog.No (6 of 6)NoYes
Counting"How many Abstract Floral Babydoll Dress options did Lena show?" Four turns each show one dress. The number is stated nowhere.wrong (5 of 6)34
Reviewer_cgA7OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Given long multi-session multimodal data, it is challenging for the models to retrieve the correct visual evidence and make fine-grained visual grounding and cross-modal reasoning accurately. Existing methods preserve finegrained details but return temporally stale evidence. To mitigate the issue, the paper proposes LMMR, which maps textual hidden states and visual patch features through modality specific projectors into shared SAE dictionary, which is then used as a query-conditioned memory graph that associate dialogues to related visual evidence to retrieve more temporally valid evidence for a given query. The paper demonstrates that LMMR outperforms existing methods on answering queries conditioned on input with complex multimodal dependencies.

Critical strengths
  • Provide novel method of using SAE to align shared concepts across modalities and link temporally valid evidence for new queries across sessions
  • Create both compact representation and native visual tokens to link concept more efficiently while preserving finegrained information
  • The method outperforms existing text-based and multimodal memory methods by a non-trivial amount on various benchmark metrics.
Critical weaknesses
  • Method description is unclear:
    • Lack mathematical, precise definition for temporal message for creating the graph
    • Unclear of how, for example, dialogue-text is selected given text memory ablation brings the largest effect
  • Effect of the core part of the method might not be as strong as first claimed / should include potentially stronger baseline:
    • The core of the method is to unify cross-modal information into shared, latent space for linking shared concepts, as opposed to the latent reasoning (has already done in other papers) steps added at the end of the entire pipeline. However, ablating out the latent reasoning causes significant performance degradation, less than but still close to ablating out the more core part of the proposed method.
    • A natural question is what if one adds latent reasoning to the baseline (e.g., MuRAG) as well as a stronger baseline
    • Also might need to give baselines more token budget and see if the method still outperforms given, for example, other baselines like MuRAG did not undergo training like what’s done in this paper
Questions for authors
  • Clarification questions on the method: same comments as weaknesses
    • Lack mathematical, precise definition for temporal message for creating the graph
    • Unclear of how, for example, dialogue-text is selected given text memory ablation brings the largest effect
  • Potentially more detailed ablation: there are a lot of components in the method and it’s unclear which one is more important or necessary. Would be helpful to have more ablation to see whether the core of the method does work better than the baselines
  • Clarification questions on the data (might be out of the scope for this paper):
    • Is the input data always fully specified? e.g., is it always guaranteed that there is always a one-to-one mapping between a text (”Carrie”) and the visual element (woman with red hair)? Are there underspecified cases (e.g., “Carrie” is associated with an image with two women in it)? How does the model handle these scenarios?
    • Do all past dialogue histories contain the correct answers? What if the queries in the past history are paired with the wrong image? It makes sense if the training data is like this, but how robust the model is when image-text pairs in the past history have contradictory information?
7 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer cgA7 (1/4)

We sincerely appreciate your careful reading and your positive assessment of our work. We hope the following responses fully resolve the concerns you raised, and we would be grateful for your continued support as we finalize the paper.

Weakness #1 & Question #1

Method description is unclear:

  • Lack mathematical, precise definition for temporal message for creating the graph
  • Unclear of how, for example, dialogue-text is selected given text memory ablation brings the largest effect

Answer to Weakness #1 & Question #1.

We appreciate the careful reading, and we are sorry that the description of the temporal message and of the text selection was not precise enough. We are glad to clarify both points below. Unless stated otherwise, all results in this response are on Mem-Gallery with Qwen2.5-VL-7B as the backbone.

Temporal message. Let xi(ℓ)x_i^{(\ell)} be the state of turn node ii at graph layer ℓ\ell, and tit_i the position of turn ii in the dialogue. The temporal message gathers information from the current and earlier turns:

miT,(ℓ)=∑j: tj≤tiβij xj(ℓ),βij=softmax⁡j: tj≤ti(WTxi(ℓ))⊤xj(ℓ)dc,m_i^{T,(\ell)}=\sum_{j:\,t_j\le t_i}\beta_{ij}\,x_j^{(\ell)},\qquad \beta_{ij}=\operatorname*{softmax}_{j:\,t_j\le t_i}\frac{(W_T x_i^{(\ell)})^{\top}x_j^{(\ell)}}{\sqrt{d_c}},

where WTW_T is a learned projection. Later turns are masked out, so a turn is read against what came before it, and an update can be told apart from the observation it revises. The concept message is defined over the dictionary DD:

miC,(ℓ)=∑c∈N(xi(ℓ))γic Dc,γic=softmax⁡c∈N(xi(ℓ))cos⁡(xi(ℓ),Dc)τ,m_i^{C,(\ell)}=\sum_{c\in\mathcal N(x_i^{(\ell)})}\gamma_{ic}\,D_c,\qquad \gamma_{ic}=\operatorname*{softmax}_{c\in\mathcal N(x_i^{(\ell)})}\frac{\cos(x_i^{(\ell)},D_c)}{\tau},

where N(xi(ℓ))\mathcal N(x_i^{(\ell)}) are the dictionary entries nearest to the node. Both messages enter Eq. 4 as written.

Text selection. Following the baselines, the memory context of every system is bounded by one shared limit, which keeps the comparison fair. It is a common interface of all systems, not a setting tuned for LMMR. Within this limit, LMMR does not simply keep the most recent turns. The history is cut at the question anchor, and every earlier turn is scored by its lexical relevance to the question and by its recency. The best-scoring turns form the candidate bank and are shown in chronological order with their date and turn index. The SAE module then selects, from this bank, the images whose native tokens are read (Sec. 4.2).

Why the text has the largest effect. Dialogue text is the context in which images become meaningful (Sec. 5.3), and it carries the temporal provenance that the graph relies on. To see which part matters, we ablated the text memory in three ways on the same questions; Table R1 gives the scores after each ablation.

Table R1. Ablation of the text memory.

Text memoryF1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑
LMMR (Ours)79.1074.7963.4787.35
w/ Random turns67.8663.3253.2475.18
w/o Date and turn index71.4767.0756.4778.06
w/ Shuffled order of the selected turns74.9070.4456.8381.83

Selecting the right turns matters most, followed by their temporal provenance, while their order matters least.

We hope this makes the method description precise. We have added the two definitions to Sec. 4.3, the selection rule to Sec. 4.2 and the text-memory controls to Appendix C.4, Table 16.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer cgA7 (2/4)

Weakness #2

Effect of the core part of the method might not be as strong as first claimed / should include potentially stronger baseline:

  • The core of the method is to unify cross-modal information into shared, latent space for linking shared concepts, as opposed to the latent reasoning (has already done in other papers) steps added at the end of the entire pipeline. However, ablating out the latent reasoning causes significant performance degradation, less than but still close to ablating out the more core part of the proposed method.
  • A natural question is what if one adds latent reasoning to the baseline (e.g., MuRAG) as well as a stronger baseline
  • Also might need to give baselines more token budget and see if the method still outperforms given, for example, other baselines like MuRAG did not undergo training like what’s done in this paper

Answer to Weakness #2.

We are grateful for these suggestions, which led us to extend the comparison in three directions. We address them in turn. In every comparison, all systems share the same evaluation and experimental settings.

Latent reasoning for MuRAG. We add a latent reasoning module to MuRAG, on top of its own retrieval. Latent reasoning helps, but the improvement is small and uneven. Table R2 gives, for MuRAG with the module and for LMMR, the change of each metric relative to MuRAG; the scores of LMMR are those of Table 1.

Table R2. Adding a latent reasoning module to MuRAG.

SystemF1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑
MuRAG––––
+ latent Reasoning+4.85+4.60+7.19−6.29
LMMR (Ours)+16.98+18.18+21.74+8.03

The module shortens the answers and so raises the token-overlap metrics, but it does not make them more correct: L-Judge falls, because without a better organisation of the evidence the shorter answers are more often guessed. LMMR improves all four metrics, by about 3 to 4 times as much as the module in F1, BLEU-1 and EM, and it is the only row that also improves L-Judge. The reason is what LMMR gives the reasoning stage to work on. The shared concept space ties text and images to the same concepts, so the right image is selected from the history. The dialogue-turn graph keeps each image with the turn in which it appeared and orders the turns in time, so a question about an earlier or later state is read against the correct turn. A latent module on top of retrieval has neither of these, so it reasons over the same fragments that retrieval returned.

Recent baselines from 2026. Table R3 compares LMMR with two recent systems for multimodal conversational memory, V-Mem (2026) [1] and Omni-SimpleMem (2026) [2]. We ran their released code on Mem-Gallery with the same backbone. The table gives their scores, and the number in brackets is the drop relative to LMMR (Table 1).

Table R3. Comparison with recent multimodal memory systems.

MethodF1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑
V-Mem (2026)40.95 (↓38.15)35.94 (↓38.85)22.03 (↓41.44)56.43 (↓30.92)
Omni-SimpleMem (2026)60.57 (↓18.53)54.77 (↓20.02)40.62 (↓22.85)75.37 (↓11.98)
LMMR (Ours)79.1074.7963.4787.35

Both systems fall behind LMMR in all four metrics. The gap is largest on the questions that need a relation between observations: on conflict detection, temporal reasoning, knowledge resolution and test-time learning, they are 25 to 75 F1 points below LMMR (Table 9). These systems organise the memory as separate text and image indexes behind a router, or as text units with an entity graph. Neither ties text and images to the same concepts, and neither represents the temporal order of the dialogue turns. What they return are fragments that the backbone still has to relate, which is where LMMR differs from a better retriever.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer cgA7 (3/4)

Answer to Weakness #2, continued.

A larger token budget. Table R4 follows MuRAG while its retrieval budget is raised, with all four metrics (from Table 3 and the retrieval-size study of the benchmark). Beyond K=10, the F1, BLEU-1 and EM of MuRAG do not improve and its L-Judge changes by less than a point, while the cost of the visual tokens grows several times over. At every budget, LMMR is ahead on all four metrics, and it uses fewer tokens than the two larger budgets.

Table R4. MuRAG under increasing retrieval budgets (K) versus LMMR, with total token cost.

MethodTotal tokensF1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑Avg ↑
MuRAG (K=5)2.3k67.9162.8849.1579.5764.88
MuRAG (K=10)4.5k69.6664.3249.8582.2966.53
MuRAG (K=15)6.9k69.2563.9349.1582.0966.11
MuRAG (K=20)9.1k68.8463.5748.7483.2066.09
LMMR (Ours)5.1k79.1074.7963.4787.3576.18

These suggestions have made our evaluation considerably more complete, and we are grateful for them. We have summarized these comparisons in Sec. 5.3 and added the full results to Appendix C.5, Tables 19-21.

References

[1] Dingyi Kang, Dongming Jiang, Yi Li, Guanpeng Li, and Bingzhe Li. V-Mem: Modality-Routed Retrieval for Long-Term Multimodal Agentic Memory. arXiv preprint arXiv:2608.01543, 2026.

[2] Jiaqi Liu, Zipeng Ling, Shi Qiu, Yanqing Liu, Siwei Han, Peng Xia, Haoqin Tu, Zeyu Zheng, Cihang Xie, Charles Fleming, Mingyu Ding, and Huaxiu Yao. Omni-SimpleMem: Autoresearch-Guided Discovery of Lifelong Multimodal Agent Memory. arXiv preprint arXiv:2604.01007, 2026.

Question #2

Potentially more detailed ablation: there are a lot of components in the method and it’s unclear which one is more important or necessary. Would be helpful to have more ablation to see whether the core of the method does work better than the baselines

Answer to Question #2.

Thank you for this insightful question. Table 2 already ablates the three modules of LMMR: removing the text memory, the latent reasoning or the visual memory costs between about 6 and over 30 F1 points, which makes them the most important parts of LMMR. To look inside them, we add two finer-grained ablations on this benchmark, one for each of the two design components of the text memory (relevance–recency selection and temporal provenance). Table R5 gives LMMR (Full) as in Table 1 and, for each ablation, the change of each metric relative to LMMR (Full) on the same questions.

Table R5. Finer-grained ablation of LMMR.

VariantF1 ↑BLEU-1 ↑EM ↑L-Judge ↑
LMMR (Full)79.1074.7963.4787.35
w/o Query-Conditioned Memory Selection71.36 (↓7.74)66.95 (↓7.84)56.28 (↓7.19)79.26 (↓8.09)
w/o Temporal Graph74.97 (↓4.13)70.71 (↓4.08)59.51 (↓3.96)82.13 (↓5.22)

Query-conditioned memory selection. The memory context of LMMR is bounded, so the turns that enter it must be chosen. LMMR scores every earlier turn by its relevance to the question and by its recency and keeps the best ones. Replacing this by random turns lowers all four metrics by about 8 points, and the loss falls on the questions that need a specific earlier turn, such as factual, multi-entity, visual-reasoning and knowledge questions. The evidence that the model reads is thus decided here, before any reasoning takes place.

Temporal Graph. LMMR stores the date and the index of every turn, which is what lets the graph place an observation relative to the ones before it. Removing them lowers the metrics by about 4 to 5 points overall, but the loss is concentrated on temporal reasoning, which falls by about 38 F1 points, while no other task loses more than 5 points. The text memory therefore contributes both the right evidence and its time.

Taken together, the ablations answer which parts matter. The three modules of Table 2, the text memory, the latent reasoning and the visual memory, are the core of LMMR and each is necessary: removing any one of them costs at least 6 F1 points, and removing the text memory or the latent reasoning costs 20 to 33 points. The finer components inside the text memory are secondary to the module they belong to, and they act on different questions: query-conditioned selection decides which evidence the model reads, and the temporal anchors decide when it was said. This core is also what separates LMMR from the baselines, which receive neither the dated, query-conditioned memory nor the learned integration stage.

We appreciate the chance to show which parts of LMMR are necessary. We have added Table R5 and this analysis to Appendix C.4 as Table 17.

Comments on the paper

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Revisions

Dear Reviewers and Area Chair,

Thank you for your time and helpful comments. We previously shared our detailed responses and have revised the paper, with changes marked in blue. With three days remaining in the discussion period, we would be grateful to hear your thoughts on our responses and revisions. If you have any remaining concerns, we would be happy to discuss and address them before the discussion ends. For convenience, we summarize the main updates below.

Reviewer cgA7. We have explained how we select dialogue text and defined the temporal message more clearly (Secs. 4.2–4.3). We have added experiments on text selection and timing information (Appendix C.4). We have also tested stronger baselines, added latent reasoning to MuRAG, and given MuRAG more retrieved images. We have examined what happens when images and text are paired incorrectly (Appendices C.5–C.7).

Reviewer aa3z. We have added results on running time and memory use (Appendix A.4). We have clarified that the model used for MemEye is trained separately on Mem-Gallery, without using MemEye data (Sec. 5.1). We have also tested cropped images for MuRAG and added an analysis of failure cases (Appendices C.6 and C.8). Table 2 now includes comparisons that help explain the role of latent reasoning.

Reviewer Ju19. We have expanded the related work on shared multimodal concepts (Sec. 2). In Table 2, we compare our method with other ways to connect text and images and to pass information from the graph to the language model. LMMR performs best in these comparisons. We have also added results on temporal updates, conflicts and computational costs (Appendices C.3–C.4 and A.4).

We would be grateful to hear whether these changes and our responses address your concerns. We are happy to answer any remaining questions. Thank you again for your time.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Summary

Dear Area Chair,

Thank you for considering our paper. The reviews highlight the practical importance of reasoning over long multimodal conversations (aa3z, Ju19), the novel use of shared concepts to link text and images (cgA7), and the gains on Mem-Gallery and MemEye (aa3z). They also recognize the value of combining structured memory with fine visual detail (cgA7, Ju19) and of evaluating transfer to a second benchmark (Ju19).

  • Shared concepts link evidence across sessions (cgA7, Ju19). Building on earlier work on concept discovery and alignment, LMMR uses shared sparse concepts to link text and images in a memory graph across dialogue turns. It retains the native visual tokens of the selected images. Under the same memory architecture, LMMR outperforms variants that use dense representations or alternative graph links (Sec. 2, Table 2, and Appendix C.3).

  • Latent reasoning makes better use of the same evidence (aa3z, cgA7, Ju19). With the same retrieved evidence, graph and backbone, LMMR outperforms direct conditioning and cross-attention. Direct conditioning uses the same number of trainable interface parameters as LMMR. LMMR also stays ahead when latent reasoning is added to MuRAG (Table 2 and Appendices C.3 and C.5).

  • Stronger reasoning about updates and conflicts (cgA7, Ju19, aa3z). LMMR selects relevant dialogue turns, keeps images tied to their source turns, and preserves the dates and order of the selected evidence. On Mem-Gallery, it improves on the best tested baselines on questions about event order, updated facts and conflicts. In one case study, LMMR correctly distinguished an earlier proposal from the final choice (Secs. 4.2–4.3 and Appendices C.4 and C.8).

  • Higher accuracy with fewer visual tokens (cgA7, aa3z, Ju19). On Mem-Gallery, LMMR outperforms V-Mem and Omni-SimpleMem using the same backbone. LMMR offers a favorable trade-off between accuracy and visual cost, with higher scores and fewer visual tokens than MuRAG across the tested retrieval budgets and in the crop experiments. LMMR also builds its memory index faster than MuRAG, and concept encoding and graph computation take only a few milliseconds per query (Table 3 and Appendices A.4 and C.5–C.6).

  • Zero-shot transfer and stable performance under image–text mismatches (aa3z, Ju19, cgA7). On MemEye, our Qwen3-VL-8B instance leads the reported baselines on all three average metrics after training only on Mem-Gallery (Sec. 5.1 and Appendix B.2). In separate Mem-Gallery tests, LMMR's overall scores remain stable under the tested image–text mismatches with the dialogue text kept intact (Appendix C.7).

We submitted our rebuttal one week before the discussion deadline and followed up several times to invite further feedback. To date, none of the three reviewers has responded. We put considerable effort into the additional experiments and clarifications, and we are disappointed that we have not had a chance to discuss them with the reviewers. We believe the rebuttal and the additional results fully address the concerns raised in the reviews. We would be grateful if you could consider our rebuttal and additional evidence alongside the strengths noted by the reviewers. We hope this evidence supports a favorable recommendation for the paper.

Best regards,
Authors of Paper 12142

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

A Gentle Follow-up on Our Responses

Dear Reviewers and Area Chair,

We submitted our responses to all three reviewers on November 12, but despite several follow-ups, we have not received any replies. Nearly 7 days have passed, and less than a day remains in the discussion period. We feel discouraged because, despite the effort we have put into our clarifications and additional evidence, we have not had the opportunity to discuss them or address any remaining concerns.

In our responses, we clarified the main points that were unclear and provided additional analyses and experiments to support our findings. We believe these responses have addressed most of the concerns raised.

We would be grateful if the reviewers could read our responses and, if they feel their concerns have been addressed, consider giving our work a more positive assessment. We would also appreciate the Area Chair’s help in encouraging the discussion and hope that our responses and new results will be considered when evaluating the paper.

We remain happy to provide any further clarification and look forward to hearing from the reviewers. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Best regards,

Authors of Paper 12142

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.