- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscript proposes a diffusion forcing-based framework designed for longitudinal Knee OA radiographic prediction. The design is with three major components to adapt the diffusion forcing to this specific application. First, the time-index is encoded into the latent state to accommodate irregular clinical follow-up schedules. Second, temporal relation alignment distills structural prior knowledge from a frozen pre-trained expert model by aligning frame-to-frame similarity matrices. Third, based on the random nature of the diffusion setting, trajectory candidates are created and selected based on the specific criteria. The authors compare with the existing generation approaches and achieve the best results on two datasets (one public and one in-house) in image generation metrics and OA longitudinal grading accuracy.
Critical strengths
- A reasonable engineering practice to adapt GenAI with longitudinal medical image prediction.
- The problem is worthwhile for exploration and clinically meaningful.
Critical weaknesses
-
The overall framework looks incremental and lacks sufficient new insights to the domain. There are exisiting studies conducting knee OA image prediction in a longitudinal manner using diffusion models. Such generation results are further used for KL grading prediction.
-
The design of the proposed components is not well justified and verified.
Questions for authors
-
The choice of DF is considered by its general flexibility. I was wondering if there is any theoretical or empirical proof that it is superior to other relevant sequential generation strategies.
-
The delay controls the denoising process. Yet, its alignment with actual disease progression is not demonstrated. Using this to predict clinical-meaningful sequence is not well justified.
-
What evidence supports the candidate ranking and its selected output as the "most clinically probable progression"?
-
Missing "Direct-Forecasting" baseline: The paper lacks a comparison against classic direct prediction (e.g., using historical frames to directly predict future KL grades). I hope to see that the generated-image-based prediction can outperform this baseline to demonstrate the clinical values.
-
While an SSIM of 0.81 suggests the images look similar, in a clinical context, it still indicates noticeable differences (roughly 20% structural mismatch). The authors need to further analyze such differences and their clinical impacts, especially with the discussions of failure cases.
-
Can the authors provide an external-cohort ablation of time encoding and controlled experiments at follow-up intervals unseen during training?
-
How does performance vary by baseline severity, progression rate, and prediction horizon?
-
The human study only proves relative preference among different methods, not absolute clinical usability. It lacks the perspecitve whether generated images improve actual clinical decision-making.
-
The methods is with multiple components and with somehow complex designs. The reviewer has the concern regarding the reproducibility, while only the appendix states that 'For detailed implementation please refer to the source code.'
-
While SOTA, the absolute KL accuracy drops to ~62% at 96 months (nearly 40% of the predictions are misgraded and two-year observation has been conducted already). The image metric gains are marginal. These raise concerns about whether the generated images are reliable enough for real-world clinical use.