- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose a supervised way for understanding Persistence Diagram (PD), i.e. separating noise and true topologiccal features. This is important for inferring the underlaying structure of objects.The authors propose Topology Understanding Net (TUN), which uses deep feature of each PD point for an intial label. And it lates uses deep point cloud geometric feature for correction. The corrected $s_{base}} are then used to identify PD point label. TUN is then shown to outperform old unsupervsied 2-meana, confidence set methods and supervised baselines.
Critical strengths
- Unlike traditional confidence set method, it is novel that this paper propose a \textbf{supervised} way to idenitify topological features and nosie points in persistence diagram. And the proposed method TUN use geometric feature in addition to topological feature for correction.
Critical weaknesses
-
The intuition of the ambiguity of point labeling is questionable. The ambiguity of point labeling shown in Figure 2 can be avoided by simply useing Fermat distance [1] to build Persistence Diagram instead of plain alpha complex, even with the addition of outliers. For figure 1, supervised filtration leanring [2] can be used to find the correct topology. If the noise point can be eliminated with suitable filtration choices, then what is the point of study the persistence diagram from alpha filtration?
-
A minor issue: insufficient demonstration of the ground truth labels. The benchmark labels are initialized by selecting the top- persistence entrioes and then manually revised by one author. The criteria for these revisionsa are not sufficiantly specificed. No systematic geometric validation is reported. This weakens the benchmark contribution.
-
The contribution of geometry conditioning is limited. The PD-encoder only already achieces near-perfect performance in Table 1. And both deepsets and set transformer, i.e., pure geometric and non-topological baselinses, also have near-perfect performance. The performance gain from geometry conditioning is very limited.
[1] Fernández X, Borghini E, Mindlin G, et al. Intrinsic persistent homology via density-based metric learning[J]. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 2023, 24(75): 1-42.
[2] Nishikawa N, Ike Y, Yamanishi K. Adaptive topological feature via persistent homology: Filtration learning for point clouds[J]. Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, 2023, 36: 9131-9143.
Questions for authors
- What motivates the specific form of the Conditional Point-Cloud Correction, ?