- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PhyScale, which aims to correct implausible relative physical scales among objects in text-generated images by formulating the problem as explicit geometric inference, constrained planning, and controlled image editing. Its main contributions include a size observer based on object pose and scene geometry, a planner that jointly determines object size, depth, and placement, and a RoPE-controlled actuator built on Qwen-Image-Edit. Experiments show that PhyScale achieves scale-correction performance comparable to baselines on GenScale, while offering advantages in target fidelity, identity preservation, and inference cost.
Critical strengths
- The core insight is both clever and intuitive, cleanly separating physical-scale reasoning from image-space editing.
- The method is well-motivated and clearly presented, and the overall paper is polished and easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
- Unintended changes to other objects during scale correction. The proposed method does not always preserve other objects in the scene during editing. For example, in Figure 1(a), although the stated correction is to enlarge the stop sign relative to the trash can, the glasses become noticeably smaller relative to the trash can after editing. It would therefore be useful to quantitatively evaluate whether the sizes of other objects are preserved after editing.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors clarify how the proposed method prevents unintended scale changes to objects that are not targeted by the editing instruction? In particular, could the authors quantitatively evaluate the scale preservation of non-target objects before and after editing, for example by measuring changes in their relative sizes? If this concern is satisfactorily addressed, I would be willing to raise my score.
Response to Reviewer 4Wqg (1/2) — Methodological Novelty and Geometric Planning
Reviewer 4Wqg — Methodological Novelty and Experimental Evidence
We thank the reviewer for the thoughtful assessment. We would like to clarify three points regarding the methodological contribution and the evidence supporting our design.
W1/Q1. Methodological novelty.
The principal contribution of PhyScale is a physically grounded correction framework that determines what must be corrected and how to execute that correction.
Existing geometry-controlled editors, including RoPEMover and GIVE, primarily execute externally specified transformations. PhyScale instead (1) infers relative physical-size errors while accounting for depth and pose, (2) plans feasible size and placement corrections under physical and image-space constraints, and (3) executes these corrections through an actuator that independently controls physical size and depth.
The actuator is specifically designed for this task. Its size–depth parameterization and supervision include pure-size, pure-depth, joint, and compensating transformations, providing separate commands for physical size and depth. Our matched RoPE-versus-text-box experiment (Tables 6 and 25) isolates the contribution of this command interface using the same backbone, data, and training budget.
We additionally evaluated the official RoPEMover implementation on 188 real-image ObjectMover requests. PhyScale achieves 0.899 versus 0.861 target DINO (paired gain +0.038, 95% CI [0.028, 0.049]). When RoPEMover receives exactly the same edit parameters, its result is 0.866. PhyScale also achieves better identity preservation (0.856 versus 0.802) and DreamSim (0.105 versus 0.139) against the official implementation.
We cited RoPEMover as concurrent work. Its June 25 arXiv preprint was available at our initial submission on September 8. NeurIPS author notifications followed on September 24, and the inference code and pretrained weights were released on October 4. The ICLR 2027 Reviewer Guide makes comparisons with arXiv-only work optional and uses a two-month window for recent peer-reviewed work.
W2/Q2. Value of the geometric front end and full planning.
The geometric front end provides explicit physical reasoning, inspectable decisions, local inference without an external VLM, and substantially lower computational cost. In Table 3, both observers received the reference dimensions and had to identify the object with the size error and estimate its correction within 20%. PhyScale met both criteria on 56.9% of Blender scenes versus 44.8% for Gemini, and on 44.0% of photorealistic scenes versus 38.5%.
On GenScale, PhyScale achieves an aggregate error of 0.640 versus 0.649 for ReScale, while reducing estimated inference cost from $0.696 to $0.037 per image (approximately 19×). The geometric front end alone costs approximately $0.006 versus $0.454 for a Gemini-based front end (Appendix E.3). Table 4 shows that PhyScale can use Gemini as a substitute front end, with a lower size-error point estimate in that comparison.
The planner also addresses a concrete geometric problem that arises when resizing at the original position would violate placement constraints. In our 197-image placement ablation (316 edits), strictly in-place resizing produces 96 actions violating the planner's geometric constraints. Full planning resolves 91 of these cases, including all physical violations under the planner's checks. These conflicts arise when resizing would compromise support, cause overlap or occlusion, extend the object beyond the image boundary, or exceed the editor's range.
On 116 held-out Blender stress scenes, both planners received the same observations and prescribed resizes. Our planner satisfies the evaluated constraints in 87.9% of cases versus 80.2% for Gemini, a reported difference of 7.8 percentage points (95% CI [1.6, 14.5]).
We also measured downstream size error on the 21 development images whose plans changed under either order-preserving variant. With the same actuator, size commands, and seed, mean error was 0.627 with full placement and 0.730 with in-place resizing (in-place minus full +0.103, 95% CI [−0.151, +0.381], bootstrapped by source). Table 32 reports a size-gain difference of +0.038 in favor of full placement on the broader set of 197 images (95% CI [−0.021, +0.104]).