- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
- This paper introduces a method called ForeSense, which attempts to equip vision-language-action models with better capabilities for reasoning about future dynamics. They do so by distilling a future-conditioned teacher's latent reasoning chain into a current-only reasoner to learn a form of "latent visual intuition".
Critical strengths
- The paper is written in an acceptably clear manner, and their motivation is good. They provided good reasoning for latent future intuitive reasoning: for simple/automatic tasks, VLAs should not be producing text chains of thought. The proposed concept and idea of latent visual intuition seems useful.
Critical weaknesses
- For the real-world evaluations, it would be useful to compare this method against baselines that use other forms of reasoning, e.g., those that use latent reasoning or action-centric traces (MolmoAct) or 3D point tracks. I am not saying that the proposed method must outperform those alternatives, but it would be good for scientific understanding to know how this method compares to others. This is especially important because the simulation results on LIBERO are somewhat saturated and the proposed method's performance is pretty close to alternatives there.
- In my view, an important benefit of reasoning in text or action-centric traces / 3D point tracks is interpretability. This may be useful in future when it is important to understand how embodied robots are reasoning and acting in the world. It would be good to enable this latent visual intuition to operate in a kind of interpretable manner.
Questions for authors
None.
4 comments
W2: Interpreting the latent predictions
Thank you for highlighting the interpretability benefits of explicit reasoning. The ForeSense reasoner can continue generation after producing its latent chain to describe the expected future interaction in natural language. During routine action inference, the reasoner stops at the end of the latent chain, and the policy uses the chain’s K/V memory to generate actions. For analysis, we let the reasoner continue generating so that we can inspect what it expects to happen next.
Table F shows these forecasts alongside reference descriptions and observed policy actions. In F2, the forecast correctly describes the gripper approaching and pausing above the gray bowl, and the policy completes the task. In F3, the reasoner predicts an approach toward the gray bowl, and the policy approaches that same bowl even though the intended target is the plate. In F1, the forecast captures the bowl’s leftward movement but misses the lifting and lowering, and the rollout fails after imprecise placement. Continuing generation lets us inspect which interactions the reasoner anticipates, which details it misses, and whether its predicted target matches the object the policy actually approaches.
Table F. Future interaction predictions and observed policy behavior.
| ID | Decoded prediction | Reference description | Agreement | Observed action | Task Success |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | A robotic arm moves over a black platform on a wooden table, rotating its gripper and shifting slightly to the left while holding a small metal bowl-like object. A red-rimmed plate, a small metal cup, and a colorful rectangular packet remain stationary on the table. | A robotic arm grips a small metal bowl on a black platform, lifts it, and carries it leftward over the tabletop. It lowers the bowl near a small round container, but the clip ends before it releases it. A second bowl, a circular ring, and a small rectangular packet remain stationary on the table. | Partial match. The prediction captures the leftward motion while holding the bowl but misses the lifting and the subsequent lowering near the container. | Lifts the metal bowl and moves it leftward, but positions it imprecisely, causing the subsequent step to fail. | ✗ |
| F2 | A robotic arm moves slowly downward and to the right over a kitchen countertop, bringing its gripper close to a small bowl behind a dark bottle. Nearby are a plate, a stovetop burner, a small rectangular device, and a black appliance. The arm does not visibly pick up or move anything during the clip. | A robotic arm lowers and slightly rotates its gripper toward a small gray bowl on a wooden countertop, then pauses just above it. Nearby are a stovetop, a dark bottle, a red-rimmed plate, and a black appliance. No object is visibly picked up or moved. | Match on key events. The prediction captures the downward approach toward the bowl and the absence of object pickup or movement. | Lowers the gripper toward the gray bowl and pauses just above it. | ✓ |
| F3 | A robotic arm moves above a ktchen countertop, lowering and rotating its gripper toward a small gray bowl behind a red-rimmed place. It pauses just above the bowl without visibly picking anything up. A stovetop, a small blue rectangular object, a knife block, and a black appliance remain stationary nearby. | A robotic arm lowers its two-finger gripper toward a small plate with a pink patterned rim on a wooden tabletop. It makes slight sideways adjustments until the fingers are positioned over the plate’s edges, then pauses without visibly lifting it. Nearby are a small bowl, a blue rectangular object, a hot plate, and a black cabinet-like unit. | Incorrect target object. The prediction captures the gripper lowering and pausing without a pickup, but identifies the gray bowl as the target. The reference shows the gripper aligning with the edges of the pink-rimmed plate. | Approaches the gray bowl instead of the intended plate and continues the task with the wrong object, resulting in failure. | ✗ |
Agreement assesses how well the decoded prediction matches the reference clip. Task Success records the outcome of the full rollout (✓ for success and ✗ for failure).
Thanks. The authors addressed my concerns. I support the paper being accepted.
I do have comments below, though.
On (1) -- thanks for running the real-world evals. Their approach's results are strong. Real-world evals are always hard to do adequate controls, but nevertheless some attempt was made.
On (2) -- This is interesting. It seems like a glass half-full; sometimes it works, but other times it's challenging to interpret. I do think a greater attempt can be made -- methodology-wise -- at interpreting the latent visual intuition (but this is difficult, I understand).
For instance, the model produces the latent chain, followed by the natural language reasoning trace. But nothing actually guarantees (or even encourages) them to be aligned. That is, in the current interpretability setup, it might be that the two are completely independent, and the text trace tells us nothing about the latent chain.
Thank you for your follow-Up
Thank you for your thoughtful and positive feedback. We truly appreciate your support and constructive suggestions.
Thank you for your thoughtful review and encouraging comments on the motivation for latent visual intuition. We especially appreciate your attention to interpretability and are glad to share an initial exploration of this question below.
W1: Real-world comparison with other reasoning-based policies
Table H. Real-world task success rates (%).
MolmoAct and VLA-JEPA were adapted using the same real-world demonstrations as ForeSense.
Thank you for suggesting a comparison with policies that use different forms of reasoning. We evaluated MolmoAct and VLA-JEPA on the same six real-world tasks as ForeSense. Among the two baselines, VLA-JEPA is closest to ForeSense overall and matches it on paper disposal and cup filling. ForeSense’s largest gains over VLA-JEPA occur on bucket stacking, towel-wrapped transfer, and cylinder–arch assembly. The task-level comparison therefore shows where the two policies perform similarly and where their performance diverges on the robot.