- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CausalDrive, an autonomous driving framework consisting of two major components: (1) a Nominal Intention Planner (NIP) and (2) a Style Execution Policy (SEP). Experimental results demonstrate strong benchmark performance, achieving good performance on NAVSIM v1 and NAVSIM v2.
Critical strengths
- NIP + SEP seems to be novel
- Causal ambiguity is critical in driving domains
Critical weaknesses
- Limited real-world validation
- Incomplete related work
- Limited methodological novelty
Questions for authors
CausalDrive achieves 91.2 PDMS on NAVSIM v1 and 89.5 EPDMS on NAVSIM v2
-
Although the proposed method achieves strong benchmark performance, these results alone do not sufficiently establish its safety, robustness, or generalizability in real-world driving environments. While the authors provide additional evaluations on the NAVSIM navhard subset, the experiments remain limited to benchmark-based assessments. Could the authors provide more comprehensive evaluations in realistic, reactive closed-loop environments, particularly under safety-critical scenarios, unforeseen traffic interactions, and out-of-distribution conditions?
-
Incomplete discussion of related work. The related-work section overlooks several relevant studies on causal imitation learning, counterfactual reasoning, and generative modeling for autonomous driving, including [1][2][3]
CausalDrive, a causal decomposition framework that models nominal intention deterministically and driving style probabilistically
-
Limited methodological novelty. The proposed framework appears to be an incremental extension of existing diffusion-based planning approaches, particularly DiffusionDrive and DiffusionDriveV2. Although the ablation studies demonstrate improvements from these components, the results do not clearly establish whether the gains arise specifically from causal reasoning or from the additional supervision and architectural decomposition.
3.1 Could the authors provide a more rigorous justification for why causal reasoning is necessary for the proposed framework? Additional comparisons with non-causal trajectory decomposition or residual-learning baselines would help isolate the contribution of the claimed causal mechanism.
3.2 Given that ResAD [4] already introduces residual trajectory modeling, could the authors clarify the fundamental methodological differences between these approaches and the proposed framework?
3.3 It remains unclear why the proposed decomposition necessarily requires causal reasoning rather than conventional conditional modeling. Could the authors specfically explain what aspects of the framework are uniquely enabled by causality and cannot be achieved through standard trajectory decomposition or residual learning?
3.4 Insufficient theoretical justification of the causal framework. The causal formulation requires further clarification. Section 3.1 introduces a causal graph and uses the intervention notation do to motivate counterfactual nominal trajectory generation. However, the underlying causal assumptions and their relationship to a formal structural causal model (SCM) are not sufficiently established.
4 Lack of statistical reliability
4.1 Evaluation error bars? Could the authors report results across multiple random seeds, including standard deviations or confidence intervals, to demonstrate the statistical reliability of the reported performance improvements?
4.2 Missing ablations about causal mechanism: Could the authors provide ablations comparing the proposed causal decomposition with non-causal residual-learning baselines under identical architectures and training settings to demonstrate that the improvements arise specifically from causal reasoning?
Lots of other ablations on matched architectures vs. non-causal, training objectives, and candidate-ranking procedures seem to be missing.
- Typos?
We then develop a diffusion-based \textbf{Interactive Response Policy} to model the multimodal residual between vs. We then develop a diffusion-based Style Execution Policy to capture the multimodal residual between nominal
[1] "Learning human driving behaviors with sequential causal imitation learning." Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence. Vol. 36. No. 4. 2022.
[2] "CausalDrive: Real-time causal world models for autonomous driving." European Conference on Computer Vision. Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, 2026.
[3] "Causalaf: Causal autoregressive flow for safety-critical driving scenario generation." Conference on robot learning. PMLR, 2023.
[4] "ResAD: Normalized residual trajectory modeling for end-to-end autonomous driving." Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition. 2026.