- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper addresses the problem of learning latent variables that are persistent across trajectories for world modeling. The proposed method SPRII, uses relationships between interactions to learn said persistent latent variables. Empirical evaluations across a large number of tasks shows that SPRII is able to learn the persistent latent variables and also improves downstream task learning.
Critical strengths
N/A
Critical weaknesses
The paper suffers from extremely poor clarity/writing that obscures the meaning of the paper, and makes it challenging to assess the paper meaningfully. I provide two examples below. As such, I do not believe that the paper meets the standard of the conference.
-
The paper uses abstract terminology to refer to easily understood concepts, that really do not need a special term: namely, "Align", "Cross", "Formation", "Use", "Value", are all used throughout as proper nouns. The first two, "Align" and "Cross" are used to describe the principles of learning that SPRII relies on, while the latter three are used to describe the evaluation setting. Using these terms, over using plain English, actually obscures meaning.
-
Some sentences rely on terms that have not been defined, and do not seem to be plain english.
- For example in the sentence, "Controlled experiments show that more reliable relations yield better organization, yet requiring pairs to share an additional property can make a still-shared property less accessible," it is unclear what a "relation" is, what is being organized, and what the "pairs" or "still-shared property" refers to.
Independent of the abstruse language, it is unclear what the reader should learn from this paper. The paper fails to make it clear what the main technical contribution is over prior work in world modeling with latent variables.
Questions for authors
N/A