acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Termination Misalignment in Large Reasoning Models

Abstract

We characterize termination misalignment in Large Reasoning Models (LRMs) as the gap between recognizing input unresolvability and acting on that recognition by regulating reasoning to terminate or abstain accordingly. In approximately 73.94% of reasoning trajectories from an evaluation of 23 models over 6,210 inference runs, we observe two distinct behavioral manifestations of the phenomenon: the failure to either terminate reasoning (within 16,384 output tokens), or abstain from hallucinating after terminating reasoning. Crucially, at least 32.77% of these trajectories contained explicit statements recognizing input unresolvability, lack of progress, or drafts of conclusions semantically appropriate for actuating termination. Despite the generation of such statements, models continued to reason for thousands of tokens. We introduce Vocabulary-Based Adversarial Fuzzing (VB-AF), a gray-box fuzzing framework for language models, and use it to generate adversarial, unresolvable inputs to systematically isolate and reproduce this behavior. Context priming models with epistemic principles substantially increases early-termination and abstention behavior, without generally degrading performance on standard tasks or consistently altering the step-level log-odds of continuing to reason. Analysis of primed trajectories suggests that termination is associated with semantically appropriate contextual states rather than a gradual decline of the measured continuation preference. Our findings are consistent with termination misalignment being a reasoning regulation problem, where models can semantically generate termination-relevant statements under persistent unresolvability but still continue deliberation.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
large reasoning models, reasoning regulation, language model fuzzing, adversarial testing, abstention

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_uuktOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces “termination misalignment,” a phenomenon in which large reasoning models recognize that their reasoning has stalled or that an input is unsolvable, yet fail to stop reasoning or abstain from answering. It takes two forms: “non-termination” and “specious termination.” The authors develop VB-AF, a gray-box fuzzing framework that generates unsolvable inputs by surrounding a decryption instruction with random gibberish tokens. Across 6,210 inference runs involving 23 models, 73.94% of trajectories exhibit termination misalignment. In 32.77% of these failure trajectories, models explicitly acknowledge stalled progress or unresolvability, or draft termination-appropriate conclusions, yet continue reasoning for thousands of tokens, and model size does not correlate with performance. Adding a few epistemic principles to the system prompt saves more than 5,000 tokens on average and substantially improves correct abstention rates, with little impact on standard benchmark accuracy. A stepwise log-odds analysis shows that models strongly favor continuing to reason throughout their trajectories. The guidance does not weaken this preference; instead, it helps models reach a semantic state conducive to termination earlier. The authors argue that this is a problem of reasoning regulation rather than cognition and highlight VB-AF’s dual-use risks for resource exhaustion and safety bypasses.

Critical strengths
  1. VB-AF turns otherwise difficult-to-reproduce reasoning anomalies into a systematic experimental setting, enabling comparisons across 23 models and 6,210 runs. Ablations on instruction wording, vocabulary, delimiters, and insertion position, together with supplementary experiments on naturally unanswerable mathematical problems, strengthen the evidence for the phenomenon and provide a practical stress-testing tool for future research.

  2. Beyond examining whether models ultimately abstain, it distinguishes failure to terminate reasoning from failure to abstain after termination, and analyzes cases in which models continue reasoning after explicitly acknowledging unsolvability. The contextual guidance experiments further demonstrate that this gap can be mitigated, establishing “when to stop reasoning” as a control problem worthy of independent study.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The experimental setting differs from real deployment scenarios, limiting the generalizability of the headline failure rate. The main experiments rely on random noise and instructions that implicitly suggest the existence of a recoverable message. These differ substantially from situations such as tool failures or code-repair loops in real-world agents. The ablations show considerable sensitivity to instruction wording, so 73.94% should be interpreted as the failure rate under this particular stress test. The experiments on naturally unanswerable mathematical problems provide supplementary evidence but are insufficient to establish broad applicability to real-world agent scenarios.

  2. The measurement of “recognizing unsolvability” and the explanation of the termination mechanism remain insufficiently supported. Statements of unsolvability in reasoning traces do not directly establish that a model has formed a stable internal judgment, and the aggregate failure rate does not distinguish cases with and without such recognition. The Δthink analysis covers only a small number of models, and the observed patterns do not establish a causal mechanism in which contextual states trigger termination. The proposed explanation that early-termination trajectories are underrepresented in training also remains untested.

Questions for authors
  1. How reliable are the annotations of explicit recognition? The figure of 32.77% comes from manual screening assisted by regular-expression keyword matching, but the paper reports neither inter-annotator agreement nor whether a second independent annotator was involved. It also does not report how many of the 1,505 trajectories merely mention unsolvability as one possible hypothesis, rather than conclude that the input is unsolvable and then continue reasoning. Could the authors provide the annotation protocol, agreement metrics, and an estimate of the misclassification rate based on a random sample?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors

We thank you for your review, constructive feedback, and highlighting the strengths of our work.

W1

We agree and would like to point out that we have explicitly qualified the failure rate as confined to the 6,210 traces obtained from our specific VB-AF stress-test (Lines 14,18,48-51, 306-308). It should not be interpreted as a claim of the universal failure rate, which we do not attempt to measure. Our ablations (Appendix A.1, A.2) vary inductive bias of the payload (with neutral P3, P4 included) and test models on naturally unanswerable math problems respectively; they find that the phenomenon persists, albeit its prevalence is affected. In Section 3.1 (Lines 158-161) we motivate the introduction of VB-AF in the observation that relevant user reports are hard to reproduce due to specific interaction histories and environments. To reproduce the failure for systematic controlled analysis, we simulate persistent unresolvability and lack of meaningful progress through VB-AF inputs.

W2.1,Q1: Explicit semantic recognition

We took your feedback as an opportunity to conduct a conservative full-corpus, label-blinded re-annotation of all behavioral failure traces (Strict) using our formalized rubric, along with an independent automated LLM annotation pass (Auto, Gemini 3.8 Flash). During this audit we reconciled run-ID alignment and reverified borderline abstentions updating the overall failure count from 4,592 to 4,666 out of 6,210 runs (75.14%, of which 4,579 overlapped with the initial number (Original) after removing 8 runs reclassified as terminated abstentions). Sending the 16,384-token noisy traces to the LLM directly triggered erratic behavior and safety blocks, so we used truncated traces instead, created using ±\pm 400-char context windows around keyphrase hits identified by a regex similar to the one used to guide manual annotation.

We then made our semantic recognition rubric explicit with the following classes of common recognition patterns (each is a sufficient condition):

  1. C1: generates an explicit conclusion of input unresolvability, or drafts an abstention.
  2. C2: acknowledges that reasoning is stuck or not making progress.
  3. C3: hypothesizes that the input is unresolvable, or that abstention may be expected.

Inter-annotator agreement/misclassification:

  1. Strict vs Auto (N=4,666): raw agreement 88.47%, Cohen's kappa=0.7436, 96.20% of all positive traces in Strict were confirmed by Auto, the Strict rubric rejected 487 borderline Auto positives (that placed the recognition rate at 38.13%).
Auto=0Auto=1
Strict=02836487
Strict=1511292
  1. Original vs Strict (N=4,579): raw agreement 85.35%, Cohen's kappa=0.6575, revised the headline recognition rate from 32.77% to 28.78% (1,343/4,666).
Strict=0Strict=1
Original=02828250
Original=14211080

Condition class breakdown (N=4,666)

ConditionCount% of Recog (n=1,343)
C1∪C2∪C3C1 \cup C2 \cup C31,343100.00%
C1∩C2∩C3C1 \cap C2 \cap C3120.89%
C1∪C2C1 \cup C267049.89%
C2∪C3C2 \cup C31,31597.92%
C1∪C3C1 \cup C31,05378.41%
C1C1 (any)1309.68%
C2C2 (any)56842.29%
C3C3 (any)1,00975.13%
C1C1 only282.08%
C2C2 only29021.59%
C3C3 only67350.11%
C1∩C2C1 \cap C2282.08%
C2∩C3C2 \cap C326219.51%
C1∩C3C1 \cap C3866.40%

Nearly half (49.89%) of all recognized failure traces contain explicit acknowledgements of stalled progress or drafted abstention conclusions (C1∪C2C_1 \cup C_2), while 50.11% articulate unresolvability as a hypothesis/explanation (C3 only). There are hence 24.86% (1,544/6,210) terminated abstentions, 21.63% (1,343) failure runs with explicit recognition, and 53.51% (3,323) failure runs without explicit recognition.

W2.2: Logit analysis, causal mechanism, training hypothesis

As noted in Section 4.2,5 (Lines 441-443, 511-512) extracting the full-vocabulary logit distribution over a 32,768 token budget required vLLM V0 execution which constrained models to those that could fit within our compute budget and be representative of our non-Robust clusters. We do not claim to establish a complete mechanism, and the logit analysis serves its purpose to falsify the possible alternate hypothesis that priming may gradually decay step-level continuation log-odds instead of altering the reasoning trajectory to reach a contextual state earlier. We explicitly mention that training under-representation is included as a discussion of a possible mechanism to verify in future work rather than a formal hypothesis that has been proved (Section 4.2 Lines 500-503) in the paper.

We have updated the paper with the new experiment and metric deltas (Section 3.3,3.5; Appendix C.3), made the distinct value of logit analysis clearer (Section 4.2), and updated the AI use disclosure in light of the automated annotation pass.

Reviewer_wixxOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

Paper defines termination misalignment in LRMs as the gap between recognizing that an input is unresolvable and acting on it, either by terminating reasoning or by abstaining. The authors propose VB-AF, a fuzzing framework that embeds a "decipher the hidden secret message" payload into random token noise. They evaluate 23 models over 6,210 runs and find that 73.94% fail to terminate or abstain. About a third of these failing traces explicitly acknowledge the lack of progress. Context priming with epistemic principles largely improves the behavior. A Δthink analysis shows that the preference to continue stays high until the final step.

Critical strengths

The paper clearly defines the problem and distinguishes two behavioral manifestations, non-termination and specious termination, measured by TR and RAT, respectively. This framing is simple and practical. The experiments have broad coverage, including 23 models ranging from 1.5B to 1T, two architecture types (dense and MoE), and three decoding configurations. The main experiment comprised 6,210 runs, with an additional 1,740 ablation runs. VB-AF is low-cost, reproducible, and model-agnostic, and can reliably induce this behavior.

The paper also reports negative results candidly, including regression caused by priming, model-specific variations in performance, and a deterioration in Phi 4 Reasoning Plus; it explicitly labels the training-data explanation as an unvalidated hypothesis. Some secondary findings are also worth noting: the reasoning versions used 5–32 times more tokens than their corresponding non-reasoning models, yet the refusal rate increased by less than 20 percentage points at most; in fact, the R1 distillation model and Magistral even saw significant decreases. Increasing the temperature does not eliminate non-termination; it merely shifts it from a degenerative to ruminative token attractors. The release of all reasoning trajectories and annotations provides a valuable resource for future research.

Critical weaknesses

My main concern is that it identifies a problem without offering a solution or explaining why it happens. Context priming is not proposed as a fix, and it has clear side effects (Appendix A.3). The only mechanistic part is the Δthink tracking on three models. It looks only at output probabilities, with no probing or causal analysis. The training-data explanation is left as an untested hypothesis. In its current form, the paper is mainly an experiment confirming that the problem exists.

The difference from prior work is also unclear. Fan et al. (2025), Liu et al. (2026) and Gu et al. (2026) have already shown that LRMs recognize unanswerability but keep reasoning or fail to abstain. Gu et al. also treat early termination as a control decision. The only distinction I can see is the shift from final abstention to termination, which I do not think is enough to count as an independent contribution.

Questions for authors

Please address the weaknesses.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors

We thank you for your review, and identifying several critical strengths about the rigor and candor of our broad, reproducible, and statistically validated experiments. However, we respectfully note a mismatch between these identified strengths and the scores you assigned (Soundness: 1, Rating: 1). We address your concerns below:

W1

We firmly clarify that the scope of our work is a behavioral, diagnostic, and evaluation framework study that characterizes termination misalignment as a failure mode, through analysis enabled by our proposed VB-AF fuzzer (lines 512-514). Even though the logit analysis may resemble a mechanistic experiment, it is a proxy used to measure the continuation preference as expressed in the logits during reasoning. Mechanistic interpretability studies and training interventions are out of scope.

We believe that diagnostic characterization must precede principled training fixes, because a key finding of our work shows precisely why naive interventions may fail. Even though context priming is a probe for behavioral mutability, it causes premature abstention in models (regressions) on challenging solvable tasks and excess token expenditure in some architectures (e.g. Phi 4 Reasoning Plus, +2,427, Table 5). By first establishing the orthogonal specious- and non-termination failure modes, our results show that interventions must be carefully calibrated since they may risk optimizing for final abstention or reasoning conciseness while masking negative side-effects and missing evaluation on adversarial inputs similar to VB-AF, that can be designed to specifically exploit the failure mode(s).

The logit analysis experiment was designed to investigate how context priming interacts with the logit distribution during reasoning when it induces early termination and abstention behavior. The behavioral invariance of the trajectories regardless of priming or solvability is an important negative result that falsifies the possible assumption that the effect may be a consequence of gradual logit-decay under priming. It is consistent with the possibility that priming may alter the reasoning trajectory itself to allow semantically appropriate contexts for termination to be reached earlier. Along with our (payload-specific) token attractor analysis and observation of discourse continuation anchors in unprimed traces (Appendix D.2, D.2.3) we provide a behavioral explanation beyond simply "confirming the problem exists".

W2

We clarify the positioning of our work.

  1. Gu et al. (arXiv, 2026): First, per ICLR Reviewer Guidelines, recent unpublished arXiv preprints and contemporaneous works are not required baselines, and "the lack of such comparisons cannot be a basis for rejection." Even so, we proactively cited and discussed the work (lines 41-43, 119-123). Secondly, contrary to the review's claim, they do not treat early termination as a control decision of ongoing reasoning. They frame and design their JTS intervention to enforce early abstention as a commitment and control decision to make before standard reasoning commences (similarly, Liu et al. focus on final answer abstention based on information sufficiency of inputs). JTS judges the answerability of the problem based on information sufficiency and forbids standard reasoning on unanswerable problems. As a result, if a problem is solvable (or misclassified as one), but unresolvability/lack of progress emerges mid-reasoning due to model capability limits or the nature of the problem itself, the unanswerability gate has already been bypassed. In contrast, our definition explicitly includes the failure to regulate reasoning after recognizing lack of progress as it emerges, regardless of problem answerability.

  2. Fan et al. (2025) focus on how missing premises exacerbate overthinking in comparison to normal inputs. They attribute this to inadequate reasoning length constraints during RL-training, but this explanation fails to isolate why despite reporting high and early in-process suspicion rates, models continue reasoning or fail to abstain. In contrast, we study termination misalignment as a reasoning regulation failure following recognition of unresolvability/lack of progress, enabling a likely explanation of the detection to action gap.

Beyond the conceptual framing, our paper contributes and demonstrates the use of the VB-AF framework for automated stress-testing of language models, behaviorally analyzes the failure as two distinct orthogonal behaviors, studies entropy-driven attractor effects, and identifies several secondary findings which have been identified as critical strengths in the review itself.

Given that no critical flaws within the paper's scope were raised, we respectfully ask you to reconsider the Soundness (1) and Overall (1) ratings. We believe the assessment should focus on the substantive differences in research questions, methodology, and contributions, rather than the existence of closely related concurrent work.

I thank the authors for the response.

W1. I appreciate the clarification that the paper is intended as a behavioral, diagnostic study. Read that way, I see its value mainly in its empirical contribution: a reproducible stress test, broad evaluation across 23 models, the separation of non-termination from specious termination, and the secondary findings I noted in my review. My concern is that the paper frames its contribution as more than this. The abstract and contributions present termination misalignment as “a reasoning regulation problem” and claim the results provide “evidence that termination misalignment may reflect a learned behavioral tendency”. Section 4.2 states that the Δthink analysis “falsifies” an alternative hypothesis and offers a contextual state account of termination. The rebuttal also says the work enables “a likely explanation of the detection to action gap”, while placing mechanistic analysis out of scope. These are explanatory claims, and the evidence offered for them (step-level log-odds on three models, whose pattern also appears on solvable AIME inputs, as other reviewers note as well) cannot support them. It was this framing that led me to evaluate the paper as more than an empirical study. If the paper is positioned as diagnostic, I would encourage the authors to scope these claims accordingly: present the Δthink results as descriptive observations, and present the regulation-problem interpretation and the training-data account as hypotheses rather than findings. As it stands, the gap between the claimed and the demonstrated contribution remains my main concern.

W2. I thank the authors for the clarification. To be clear, my review did not ask for an experimental comparison with Gu et al., and I am aware it is contemporaneous work. The ICLR guideline cited in the rebuttal therefore addresses a request I did not make. My point concerned positioning. The authors chose to cite Gu et al. and present it as one of the most closely related work, so the paper itself should make the distinction precise. It was not explicit enough for me as a reader. The rebuttal now states it clearly: Gu et al. treat early abstention as a pre-reasoning control decision, whereas this work concerns regulation of ongoing reasoning after recognition emerges. I consider this concern resolved, provided this distinction is stated explicitly in the paper. I would also note that the scope highlighted in the rebuttal, lack of progress emerging mid-reasoning on solvable problems, is not evaluated in the current experiments, since all inputs studied are unresolvable from the outset.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Reply acknowledgement and further revisions

Thank you for your clarification and acknowledging our rebuttal. We agree that we should scope our claims more appropriately. Acknowledging your constructive feedback, we have revised our manuscript (changes highlighted in blue) with the following changes.

  1. [W1] Abstract (lines 25-31): qualifies logit analysis as descriptive, makes the behavioral reasoning regulation framing of termination misalignment explicit, qualifies our training hypothesis discussion as a potential mechanism to investigate for future work.

  2. [W2] Intro (lines 42-46): made the distinction with concurrent work more explicit earlier.

  3. [W2] Intro (lines 92-95): qualifies logit analysis as descriptive based on observations, frames training hypothesis as one to investigate for future work, since its verification is not in scope of our present paper.

  4. [W1] Intro / Contributions (lines 105-107): similar to point 1; abolishes claiming that the failure mode is a learned behavioral tendency, describes the priming effects and observations from logit analysis instead.

  5. [W2] Related Work (lines 119-123): makes positioning relative to concurrent work explicit.

  6. [W1] Section 4.2 (lines 488-491, 494-503): scopes the observations from the logit analysis to the experiment conducted, poses the under-representation hypothesis as a tentative interpretation to be investigated and verified in future work, retaining the qualification that we have not established the mechanism.

  7. [W2] Limitations (lines 511-515): we caveat that while our framing includes stalled progress/unresolvability that emerges mid-reasoning on solvable problems, our experiments utilize unresolvable inputs purposefully, and such evaluation on solvable inputs should also be further studied in future work.

Thank you for identifying these points.

Reviewer_pMvVOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies termination misalignment: reasoning models may express recognition of unresolvable inputs yet continue reasoning or produce unsupported answers. It introduces vocabulary-based adversarial fuzzing, evaluates 23 models, and examines context priming and token-level termination probabilities. The experiments reveal distinct termination and abstention failures, while showing that prompting can improve these behaviors with model-dependent trade-offs.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear presentation and useful evaluation structure. Separating failure to terminate from failure to abstain reveals distinct model behaviors that reasoning length or final-answer accuracy alone would miss.

  2. Informative intervention analysis. The experiments include natural unanswerable problems, prompt and input variations, and regressions on solvable tasks. Particularly useful is the finding that unchanged aggregate accuracy can conceal premature-abstention errors.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The advance over prior work remains unclear. Existing studies already show that models can recognize missing information yet continue reasoning or produce unsupported answers. The paper needs to clarify what its framing and VB-AF reveal beyond broader confirmation of these failures.

  2. The logit analysis has limited explanatory specificity. Similar continuation patterns are reported on both solvable and unresolvable inputs, so the analysis does not by itself distinguish termination misalignment from ordinary stopping behavior. The mechanistic interpretation should therefore remain tentative.

Questions for authors
  1. The paper distinguishes ongoing reasoning termination from final-answer abstention. Which empirical findings most clearly establish the additional value of this distinction relative to [1–3]?

  2. Can the authors clarify what the continuation log-odds establish beyond the usual behavior of a termination token? Do the existing traces show distinctive behavior immediately after explicit recognition of unresolvability?

  3. Given that a neutral conciseness prompt performs similarly on GLM 4.5 Air, and that priming introduces premature-abstention errors on some solvable tasks, how should the claimed benefits and specificity of epistemic priming be qualified?

[1] Missing Premise Exacerbates Overthinking: Are Reasoning Models Losing Critical Thinking Skill? COLM 2025.

[2] Answering the Unanswerable Is to Err Knowingly: Analyzing and Mitigating Abstention Failures in Large Reasoning Models. AAAI 2026.

[3] Bridging the Detection-to-Abstention Gap in Reasoning Models under Insufficient Information. arXiv, 2026.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal by Authors

We thank you for your thoughtful review and positive assessment.

W1 and Q1

We acknowledge the convergence of [1-3] and our work on the detection to action gap. Each work studies this gap differently. In our paper, we frame it as the failure to regulate ongoing reasoning following explicit semantic recognition of lack of progress or input unresolvability.

[1] Fan et al. primarily study MiP-overthinking as a reasoning efficiency problem, attributing it to inadequate reasoning length constraints during RL-training. Since they report a high in-process suspicion rate at an early index but observe that models continue to overthink and that MiP exacerbates the tendency compared to normal inputs, and also lowers abstain rates, they study a form of the gap indirectly. In contrast, we show that while a model may regulate its reasoning to terminate early (and not extensively overthink), it may still not directly act upon its in-process recognition and fail to ultimately abstain.

[2] Liu et al. (previously) and [3] Gu et al. (concurrently) focus on whether inputs contain sufficient information for answerability, and primarily concern with abstention capability. The JTS intervention [3] aims to make the model commit to abstention early, and denies reasoning on problems pre-emptively judged to be unanswerable; they treat abstention as a control decision over reasoning before it commences. Our definition of termination misalignment encompasses cases where inputs may be sufficiently answerable, but progress may stall mid-reasoning either due to unproductive rumination (alternatively, degenerative patterns) or as a consequence of a capability limit of the model.

This framing allows us to reveal two primary orthogonal failure modes, which may be obscured if evaluation is performed exclusively on reasoning efficiency or abstention capability. Models may abstain often, but usually fail to terminate (non-termination), or they may terminate early, but often produce unsupported answers (specious termination). Divergent manifestations of these behaviors can also be observed on naturally unanswerable problems (Appendix A.2): GPT OSS (20B) exhibits explicit recognition on non-terminated runs (62/73) but none on specious ones (0/7). DeepSeek v3.2 (58/68) and GLM 4.5 Air (67/72) show early explicit recognition in most runs but fail largely through specious termination.

VB-AF, in itself, is not a static dataset unlike MiP, UMWP, SUM or similar. It is a domain and model-agnostic, gray-box fuzzing framework for language models that can be used to design and generate arbitrarily many adversarial/unresolvable inputs with no recoverable signal. It allows for systematic ablation of all parameters, like noise scale, instruction inductive bias, and structural perturbations. It can also be used to expose practical dual-use risks, like vulnerabilities similar to denial-of-service in deployments.

W2 and Q2

We agree that the logit analysis (Δthink\Delta_\text{think}) does not distinguish termination misalignment from ordinary stopping behavior. The experiment (Section 4.2) was designed to investigate how context priming interacts with the logit distribution when it induces appropriate termination and abstention behavior. The negative result that the trajectory remains behaviorally similar regardless of priming or input unresolvability serves its purpose by falsifying the possible assumption that termination under priming could be associated with gradual logit-decay (Δthink\Delta_\text{think}) of expressed continuation. It is consistent with the possibility that priming may alter the reasoning trajectory to reach a semantically appropriate contextual state for termination earlier.

In unprimed traces, we observe that explicit recognition of unresolvability or lack of progress is not associated with a consistent change in the associated step's Δthink\Delta_\text{think}. Instead, as documented in Appendix D.2.3., we observe textual continuation anchors. For example, a model may explicitly state "I'm stuck.", but would continue generation after an immediate discourse marker like "But let me not give up yet..." and enter a relevant ruminative or degenerative, payload-specific token attractor (Appendix D.2).

Q3

We agree that we should be more precise about the claimed benefits and specificity of epistemic priming. While epistemic wording is not necessary to induce improvements, we observe that its effects are more consistent than the neutral conciseness prompt (which severely degrades GPT-OSS (20B): -50.00pp RAT, -0pp TR, -2.73% ATTT). We would also like to clarify that the priming experiment is a probe for behavioral mutability and not a drop-in fix of the problem, as mentioned in our paper.

We have foregrounded the regression measurement and caveats related to context priming to Section 4.1, made the positioning with prior and concurrent work more explicit in Section 2, and highlighted the distinct value of our logit analysis in Section 4.2.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Rebuttals and Incorporated Changes

We have updated our manuscript to acknowledge the feedback provided by the reviewers. All updated text has been highlighted in blue in the rendered PDF.

  1. Full failure corpus semantic recognition re-annotation and reliability audit (addressing uukt; Section 3.5, Table 3, Appendix D.1): We have formalized a stricter rubric of 3 sufficient conditions required to consider a trace to have depicted explicit semantic recognition of lack of progress or unresolvability, which separates explicit unresolvability conclusions/drafted abstentions (C1), stalled-progress acknowledgments (C2), and unresolvability hypotheses or explanations (C3). Following this strict rubric, we conducted a label-blinded manual re-annotation alongside an independent automated pass (using an LLM, Gemini 3.8 Flash as an annotator instructed on our rubric) across all behavioral failure traces (N=4,666N = 4,666, 88.47% raw agreement, Cohen's κ≈0.74\kappa \approx 0.74). Verifying and reconciling run alignment and borderline abstentions updated the stress-test failure rate from 73.94% to 75.14% (4,666/6,210) and the conservative explicit recognition rate from 32.77% to 28.78% (1,343/4,666), with minor metric adjustments made to Tables 1 and 10. The re-annotation exercise with its agreement metric and condition statistics has been included in Section 3.5 and Table 3. In light of this new experiment we have also updated our AI use disclosure section.

  2. Scoped diagnostic/behavioral framing, claims and interpretative hypotheses (addressing wixx, pMvV, uukt; Abstract, Introduction, Section 4.2): To align our claims with the scope of our study (behavioral evaluation), we have removed explanatory claims that go beyond interpretation from observations. We present the logit analysis' behavioral invariance as a descriptive observation, clarify our formulation and framing of termination misalignment as a behavioral reasoning-regulation problem, and qualify the contextual-state interpretation and training under-representation suggestion as a tentative hypothesis for future work to study and investigate.

  3. Foregrounded context priming and regression caveats (addressing pMvV, wixx; Section 4.1, Table 4): We moved our measurement of per-model regressions on challenging standard tasks to the main text to better qualify the side-effects of (epistemic or similar) context priming.

  4. Explicit prior and concurrent work positioning (addressing pMvV, wixx, uukt; Abstract, Introduction, Related Work, Limitations): We have restructured Section 2 to explicitly contrast our formulation of ongoing reasoning regulation under stalled progress or unresolvability against prior and concurrent works focusing on missing-premise overthinking, abstention under insufficient information, or upfront abstention commitments (Fan et al., 2025; Liu et al., 2026; Gu et al., 2026). In our Limitations we also explicitly note that while the scope of our framing includes mid-reasoning stalls on solvable tasks, our experiments purposefully utilize unresolvable inputs where objective progress is not possible, leaving evaluation on solvable task stalls for future study.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.