- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper propose to use point maps from Moge3 as the conditioning signal so that the visible surface is align with the image and use generative prior from Pixal3D to fill in the hidden parts. Their contribution is to incorperate point maps with Pixal3D through new conditionings.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- The paper is poorly written. There are so many notation without clear explaination and notation definition.
- The novelty is very limited. Just unproject the point maps back to the voxel space and recast Trellis2 for inpainting
- There is no explaination why the authors propose concatenation architecture. There are so many design choices that you could condition it on, for example, through cross attention [1] or injecting it directly in each voxel [2].
- The paper constructs their own datasets which might be unfair to others. The author should have provided the comparisons from the publicly-available dataset.
[1] RecGen 3D Multi-Object Scene Reconstruction from Sparse Observations
[2] GenRecon: Bridging Generative Priors for Multi-View 3D Scene Reconstruction
Questions for authors
- If we were to generate transparent objects, how can this approach help as Moge3 will give the point maps only on, for example, the bottle surface but not fish inside the bottle. I don't see any transparent reconstruction in the paper and supplementary.
- How do you get camera pose ? This is single image reconstruction so camera pose doesn't have any meaning here? could be identity matrix.
- Why do you need training for this? Can you just doing outpainting from Trellis2 using point maps to constraint the generation?
- How do you render normal maps? Which camera angles do you use?