1. Limited novelty and incomplete comparison with prior work. TAR’s central retrieval signal, AQ/(AG+ϵ), is the relative-attention ratio introduced by Khayatkhoei et al. (ICLR 2025). That work also extracts attention from a single selected layer and combines global and zoomed-in views for answering. Section 2.2 cites it as general inspiration, while Sec. 3.2 presents the ratio as a design choice supported by the paper’s own ablation. I would like the authors to make this connection explicit and clarify what TAR adds. As I understand it, the main additions are to aggregate spatial attention into a temporal score, select a fixed-width contiguous window, and sample frames more densely within it. These are sensible adaptations to video, but the methodological advance appears incremental.
The paper also leaves out several closely related training-free methods that use the video model’s own attention or confidence to select frames or temporal intervals, including FlexSelect (arXiv:2506.00993), DyToK (arXiv:2512.06866), and Temporal Search / Iterative Zoom-In (arXiv:2507.02946). AKS is cited but is absent from the experimental comparisons. Discussing and comparing these methods would help clarify where TAR advances the existing work.
2. The experiments leave open how large the gains are, whether they justify the added cost, and what drives them. In addition to the 48-frame answering pass, TAR requires two attention-extraction passes over the 64-frame coarse view (Secs. 3.4 and 5). On MLVU, uniform sampling with 128 frames already reaches 49.80%, close to TAR’s 50.20% in the 64-frame setting (Table 4). Moreover, TAR’s margin over uniform sampling at the corresponding frame budget narrows from 5.78 percentage points at 64 frames to 2.99 points at 128 frames. A comparison at matched end-to-end cost would help establish whether the additional passes are worthwhile. The baseline scores also fall substantially below those in the Qwen3-VL technical report. For Qwen3-VL-8B, the paper reports 58.39% versus 71.4% on Video-MME and 34.60% versus 58.0% on LVBench. Explaining the protocol differences behind these gaps would put the reported gains in context.
The attention score, layer, and frame budget appear to have been selected on the same MLVU set used for the headline result. The controls that help isolate the effect of interval selection, Uniform-48 and random-window resampling, are also limited to that set. The random-window result uses three seeds, and neither comparison includes a paired significance test. I would like to see whether the gains over these controls hold on a benchmark held out from configuration selection.
Finally, the LVBench localization results are modest, with Recall@1 of 23.34% and mean temporal IoU of 3.20%. As the paper acknowledges in Sec. 4.7, a matched random-window baseline is needed to establish how much localization improves over chance. Since the selected window spans about one eighth of the video, some overlap with annotated evidence is expected even from random selection. The larger gains for questions with evidence overlap in Fig. 4 could therefore reflect useful retrieval, differences in question difficulty, or both. Repeating the same analysis with random windows of equal length would help distinguish these explanations.