- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper tries to tackle the "instrument-performance-video to music" task, which is a sub-task in video-to-audio generation.
The audio backbone of this model is built upon the AudioLDM framework: mel VAE, vocoder. Addtionally, Flow-Matching was used to train the generative model.
However, there are severe problems regarding the citation and baselines. For example, MMAudio is one of the most famous V2A model, but is not cited in this paper. This paper's baseline models are mainly from early 2024, competitive models like Frieren or MMAudio are never mentioned. In 2025 and 2026, we see other progresses in V2A built upon MMAudio, and none of them is cited or compared in this paper.
Moreover, the paper considered flow-matching as a novel V2A generative model in line 76 - 77, which is not true in the year of 2026.
My impression is that, the paper is either a manuscript completed in early 2024, or the paper is trying to pick up weak baselines to unfairly improve the performance of their proposed method.
I have to give a "clear reject" to this manuscript
Critical strengths
Clear presentation.
This helped me to realize the context of this paper stopped in the year of 2024.
Critical weaknesses
As mentioned in the Summary session, all strong V2A baselines since the late 2024 are not compared or mentioned or cited.
Specificly, the missing of MMAudio is inacceptable, because this is the first paper that solved the temporal alignment challenge in V2A tasks.
Questions for authors
Did I miss the supplementary file for audio samples? If they were not provided, could you consider to share some audio samples during the rebuttal?