- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2(−1)
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a framework for compressing semantic features attached to 3D Gaussian representations by adapting a pretrained FCGS compressor. Nonlinear projection encoder bridges the semantic and attribute feature spaces, while LoRA updates adapt the frozen feature transforms and hyperprior. An attention mechanism gated module further refines semantic latents before quantization. Experiments report near-lossless segmentation performance on Replica scenes, including 0.8124 mIoU at 3.67 BPE on room_0 versus 0.8164 uncompressed. Additional experiments investigate projection-only adaptation across scenes, semantic retrieval, qualitative editing, and compression of DF-3DGS features.
Critical strengths
-
The method maintains performance close to the uncompressed reference across multiple operating points on both evaluated Replica scenes. Its substantial gains over FCGS-Semantic-RD provide evidence that the complete adaptation framework is better.
-
The framework separates source-trained compression components from scene-dependent projection networks. Updating only the projections recovers useful reconstruction and segmentation performance on additional scenes, providing concrete evidence that the learned compression components can be reused.
Critical weaknesses
The evaluation is restricted to DF-3DGS, whose scene-specific compression module is omitted. Comparisons with other relevant approaches are also missing, limiting the evidence that the proposed framework offers a competitive compression–accuracy trade-off beyond this particular baseline. Broader benchmarking under consistent evaluation and storage conventions is needed to substantiate the claimed advantages.
Questions for authors
-
How much of the improvement is attributable to LoRA itself? Under the same architecture and training conditions, does LoRA achieve comparable rate–semantic performance to full fine-tuning with less adaptation time or lower peak memory usage?
-
Do the evaluated baselines fully exploit their compression capabilities? In particular, why is DF-3DGS evaluated without its scene-specific compression module, and do the reported advantages persist when this component is included?
7 comments
Dear Reviewer,
I hope this message finds you well. As the discussion period is nearing its end with less than three days remaining, I wanted to ensure we have addressed all your concerns satisfactorily. If there are any additional points or feedback you'd like us to consider, please let us know. Your insights are invaluable to us, and we’re eager to address any remaining issues to improve our work.
Thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our paper.
Please review the authors' responses and engage in the discussion
Dear Reviewers,
The authors have now responded to your concerns. It is time to review their responses and assess whether they adequately address your concerns or whether any further questions remain.
I would kindly ask you to read the authors' responses and actively engage in the discussion, as there are only a few days remaining.
Thank you for your time and contribution.
Best regards, Your AC
Thank you for recognizing semantic preservation and cross-scene reuse. We address the complete DF-3DGS baseline and the contribution of LoRA below.
1. Complete DF-3DGS comparison and storage accounting
Our semantic-accuracy advantage is retained when DF-3DGS's scene-specific compression is enabled. The original table in our paper emphasized semantic preservation and reported its higher-mIoU configuration without SC. We now include our reproduction of the complete, unmodified method, evaluated on Replica room0 with the same protocol as the manuscript's main comparison.
Following DF-3DGS's storage convention (Sec. 4.1), its 13.1 MB includes the complete semantic-field PLY (positions, scales, rotations, opacities, and semantic features) plus decoder weights, excluding the separate RGB field. For our coupled representation, we count semantic data and codec weights, excluding geometry/appearance shared with RGB.
Our entry is calculated from the manuscript's storage breakdown: 55.65 MB semantic data + 1.11 MB scene-specific parameters + 3.09 MB shared backbone, counted once. The 18.35 MB geometry/appearance component is excluded. With the backbone already available, per-scene semantic storage is 56.76 MB.
At these operating points, our method achieves 4.73 percentage points higher mIoU and remains close to its uncompressed reference (0.8164). This supports semantic preservation under compression. The table compares complete semantic representations with different storage budgets; controlled comparisons on fixed source features are discussed below. We will add the complete DF-3DGS result to Table 1 and specify the storage components.
Appendix E of our paper further demonstrates applicability to DF-3DGS's 512-D source features: our compression retains 0.764 mIoU versus 0.774 before compression.
2. LoRA versus full fine-tuning under the same architecture
To isolate the adaptation strategy, both variants use the same projection, GeoGuide, entropy modules, and loss, start from the same Stage 1 checkpoint, and receive the same number of training updates. The five operating points below use the same evaluation protocol on Replica room0. BPE denotes estimated semantic rate.
These results support competitive rate–semantic performance. For example, LoRA obtains 0.8077 at 3.0058 BPE, versus 0.8058 at 3.0917 BPE for full fine-tuning: 2.78% fewer estimated bits with 0.19 percentage points higher mIoU. At the higher-quality end, LoRA obtains 0.8117 at 3.5514 BPE, versus 0.8113 at 3.5310 BPE. Comparisons use achieved rates, since equal λ does not imply equal BPE.
A separate controlled implementation profile on an NVIDIA A100 measures adaptation costs for the same architecture:
The profile averages an earlier six-rate sweep with 1,500 Stage 2 updates per setting, excluding checkpoint I/O. LoRA/Full FT learning rates are 10−3/10−4. These costs are profiled separately from the five-point quality table. LoRA reduces adaptation-weight storage, but provides no training-time or peak-memory advantage in the current implementation. It reduces total trainable parameters by 72.26% and backbone adaptation parameters by 93.44%. We will add this comparison and describe LoRA's benefit as compact adaptation with competitive semantic preservation.
3. Task scope and baseline selection
Our primary task is to compress an existing semantic Gaussian representation while preserving its feature utility. We compare SVD and FCGS-Semantic-RD on fixed source features in room0 and office3. FCGS-Semantic-RD is fully fine-tuned with semantic reconstruction and rate losses, providing a learned compression baseline adapted to semantic data. On room0, SVD and FCGS-Semantic-RD obtain 0.762 mIoU at 4.00 BPE and 0.716 at 3.61 BPE, respectively, versus our 0.8124 at 3.67 BPE.
Complete DF-3DGS additionally evaluates a learned compact semantic representation, providing a system-level storage–accuracy comparison. We will clarify these complementary comparison settings and their storage accounting.