- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes OpenWan-Light, which consists of a high-quality, motion-oriented dataset and an open acceleration pipeline. A scalable two-stage data curation framework is developed, combining lightweight standard filter operations and a VLM-based review process. The authors accelerate the Wan2.2 model with the proposed acceleration pipeline on the curated dataset. The results deliver a better VBench total score against the original teacher model with a 76$\times$ speedup.
Critical strengths
- The paper presents a practical end-to-end framework for accelerating video generation. It combines a standardized motion-centric video dataset with a complete Wan2.2 acceleration pipeline. The results deliver a better VBench total score with a 76$\times$ speedup.
- The generator-matched refiner is well-motivated and practical. Figure 5 also shows significantly better performance with the generator-matched degradation.
Critical weaknesses
- The unique contribution of the curated dataset compared with existing datasets needs further clarification. The paper doesn't provide a fair comparison of fine-tuning or distillation results on different datasets.
- The effectiveness of motion-centered selection remains unclear. First, the improvement in mean optical flow between the curated dataset and the pre-curation dataset is relatively small (from 3.28 to 3.36). Second, the proposed method achieves the lowest dynamic degree metric in VBench among the baselines (77.22 for the Wan2.2 teacher model; 71.94 for OpenWan-Light; 88.06 for TurboDiffusion; 75.56 for LightX2V).
Questions for authors
- Could you provide controlled fine-tuning comparisons using matched numbers of clips and matched training budgets for existing datasets and the proposed curated set? Results beyond distillation would also be helpful. For example, could you provide comparison results for direct fine-tuning on the proposed dataset and other datasets?
- How effective is the motion-centered selection pipeline? The median of the per-clip mean RAFT optical flow increases only from 3.28 before curation to 3.36 after curation. Could you explain why the improvement is limited? It would also be useful to distinguish and report improvements in subject motion from those in camera motion and artifacts. For example, could you locate or segment subjects in the video and calculate their locomotion?
- Please clarify how each baseline was implemented. Were LightX2V and TurboDiffusion evaluated using their official checkpoints, or were they retrained/fine-tuned on the proposed 450K curated dataset? If the baselines were not trained on the same data, please provide a controlled comparison under matched training data and compute budgets.
- Why does the final model have the lowest Dynamic Degree among all compared methods? OpenWan-Light obtains 71.94, compared with 77.22 for the Wan2.2 teacher model, 75.56 for LightX2V, and 88.06 for TurboDiffusion. Could you explain whether distillation or refinement suppresses motion amplitude or diversity?