- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose the Code-Driven Agentic Image Generation paradigm and instantiate it as GenClaw. The system follows a Conceptualize → Sketch → Color workflow. In the conceptualization stage, the agent constructs relevant knowledge and context via search and reasoning. In the sketching stage, it generates executable visual sketches using code (e.g., SVG, HTML, or Three.js). In the coloring stage, an image generation model is used to add textures, materials, and photorealistic details. Code functions as a controllable intermediate canvas that bridges linguistic reasoning and pixel-level synthesis.
Critical strengths
- The motivation is clear and easy to follow. The analogy to human artistic practice and the identification of the lack of a direct “brush” for structural control provide a coherent rationale for the proposed workflow.
- The experimental evaluation is comprehensive, and the reported results on GenEval++ and Mind-Brush are convincing. The quantitative gains on compositional control and knowledge-grounded generation support the practical effectiveness of the approach.
Critical weaknesses
- In essence, GenClaw is a decoupled agentic workflow in which each stage (search/reasoning, code-based sketching, and generative rendering) has been proposed and validated in prior work. The contribution appears to consist primarily of combining these existing components rather than introducing additional technical novelty. While the empirical results are compelling, this raises concerns about limited conceptual inspiration for the broader research community.
Questions for authors
- Is the framework robust across multiple underlying models? As a compositional system, its generality with respect to different generator choices would be valuable to understand. In particular, does GenClaw enable smaller or open-source generators to approach the performance of strong closed-source models? Such evidence would strengthen the case for its practical application value.
3 comments
Overall, the response addresses my concerns. I am satisfied with the clarifications and will consider updating score.
Thank you for the follow-up. We are glad that our clarifications address your concerns, and we appreciate your careful reading and constructive suggestions throughout the discussion.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the thoughtful review, and for finding the motivation clear and the evaluation comprehensive and convincing. We address each point below.
W1: Technical novelty
We thank the reviewer for this thoughtful comment, which gives us the opportunity to clarify our contribution. The core question GenClaw addresses is who leads image creation. In current image generation, including existing image-generation agents, the image model leads: the agent can only describe its intent in text, and a black-box model fits an image to that description in a single pass. GenClaw hands the lead to the agent and follows how humans create: it first gathers knowledge and conceives the content, then sketches the structure with code, and only then lets the image model add texture and realism. Image generation thus changes from single-shot fitting into a long-horizon creative process, in which the agent writes, renders, inspects, and revises its work before any pixels are synthesized.
This shift leads to four differences from prior work:
We agree that search, code sketches, and generative rendering have each been explored before. Our tool ablation (see our response to Reviewer gm6z (W1)), however, shows that the gains come from letting the agent draw rather than from simply combining strong components: with the same LLM, review, generator, and generation budget, removing only the code-rendering tools lowers GenEval++ from 0.879 to 0.805, and the prompt-level agents in Table 1 likewise remain between 0.72 and 0.78.
We hope this offers the community a broader insight: image generation can move from a model that fits pixels to a prompt toward an agent that creates through tools and editable intermediate representations. Just as code agents are reshaping software engineering, this paradigm lets advances in code-capable LLMs carry over directly to visual creation.
Q1: Robustness across generators
Thank you for this valuable question. Yes. GenClaw is generator-agnostic by design: the agent policy stays unchanged, and only the renderer is replaced (Section 3.4). We evaluate it on GenEval++ with the open-source Qwen-Image (Wu et al., 2025a) and two closed-source generators, Gemini-3.1 Flash-Image (Raisinghani, 2026) and GPT-Image-1.5 (OpenAI, 2025b):
GenClaw improves all three generators. With GenClaw, the open-source Qwen-Image (0.825) surpasses every closed-source model under direct generation in Table 1, including GPT-Image-1.5 (0.750), Nano-Banana Pro (Raisinghani, 2025; 0.761), and Gemini-3.1 Flash-Image (0.775). With GPT-Image-1.5 as the renderer, GenClaw reaches 0.895, the best result we have obtained, which shows that GenClaw continues to benefit from stronger generators.
We hope our responses address the reviewer's concerns, and we would be grateful if the reviewer could take them into account in the final assessment. We are happy to discuss any further questions.