- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
For wireless image transmission over noisy channels, existing methods that transmit vector-quantized representations often rely on recovering discrete codewords before reconstruction. The paper proposes AsymVQ-JSCC, which learns the QAM constellation according to source representations and directly maps the received signal to the latent used for image reconstruction without hard detection or codeword lookup.
Critical strengths
The paper studies a meaningful problem in wireless image transmission, namely how to reconstruct images effectively when vector-quantized representations are affected by channel noise. Questioning whether exact codeword recovery is necessary is relevant because it directly concerns how channel observations should be used for reconstruction.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed mechanism lacks necessary ablation studies. The paper mainly reports overall performance comparisons, but does not provide matched ablation experiments that isolate the proposed components. In particular, although the title emphasizes "recover semantics," the paper does not clearly define or directly evaluate what "semantics" means or how it differs from codeword recovery. The proposed continuous receiver is also closely related to existing soft decoding for noisy vector quantization [1] and neural reconstruction from noisy finite constellation observations [2], but these alternatives are not discussed or compared experimentally. A matched comparison among hard codeword recovery, conventional soft decoding, and the proposed continuous receiver is therefore necessary to establish both the effectiveness and novelty of the proposed mechanism.
-
The experimental comparison does not provide a sufficiently fair or complete baseline. The separated baseline uses fixed rate- LDPC and 64-QAM over the entire SNR range. At high SNR, this introduces unnecessary channel redundancy and leaves fewer bits for source coding under the same channel-use budget, which can lower the achievable reconstruction quality of the separated system. At low SNR, 64-QAM with the same code rate can be too aggressive and lead to frequent LDPC decoding failures, producing a sharp waterfall effect. This setting can directly contribute to the abrupt transition of ProGIC+LDPC observed in Figure 3. Therefore, the current results cannot clearly determine whether the reported advantage comes from the proposed system or from a weak fixed-MCS separated baseline. A more appropriate evaluation is to adapt the modulation order and LDPC code rate to the channel condition using an MCS table [3], as adopted in recent image transmission studies [4,5]. The separated comparison also omits recent strong image codecs such as OneDC [6], DiT-IC [7], and EF-LIC [8]. Finally, the paper does not report model size, computation, or encoding and decoding latency, making it difficult to determine whether the reported gains come from the proposed communication design or additional computational cost.
References
[1] M. Skoglund and P. Hedelin, "Hadamard-Based Soft Decoding for Vector Quantization Over Noisy Channels," IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, vol. 45, no. 2, pp. 515–532, 1999.
[2] T.-Y. Tung, D. B. Kurka, M. Jankowski, and D. Gündüz, "DeepJSCC-Q: Constellation Constrained Deep Joint Source-Channel Coding," IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Information Theory, vol. 3, no. 4, pp. 720–731, 2022.
[3] 3GPP, "NR; Physical Layer Procedures for Data," 3GPP TS 38.214, Table 5.1.3.1-1.
[4] Y. Huang and Z. Qin, "Image Semantic Communication With Quadtree Partition-Based Coding," IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, vol. 44, pp. 2765–2778, 2026.
[5] G. Zhang, P. Yang, Y. Cai, Q. Hu, and G. Yu, "From Analog to Digital: Multi-Order Digital Joint Coding-Modulation for Semantic Communication," IEEE Transactions on Communications, vol. 73, no. 6, pp. 4257–4271, 2025.
[6] N. Xue, Z. Jia, J. Li, B. Li, Y. Zhang, and Y. Lu, "One-Step Diffusion-Based Image Compression with Semantic Distillation," Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, vol. 38, 2025.
[7] J. Shi, M. Lu, X. Li, A. Ke, R. Zhang, and Z. Ma, "DiT-IC: Aligned Diffusion Transformer for Efficient Image Compression," in Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, pp. 25719–25729, 2026.
[8] H. Cao, W. Guo, Z. Qin, and J. Han, "Efficient Learned Image Compression without Entropy Coding," in Proceedings of the 43rd International Conference on Machine Learning, PMLR 306, pp. 11158–11181, 2026.
Questions for authors
-
We would like the authors to clearly define what “semantics” means in this paper and quantify the gain of recovering “semantics” rather than codewords. We also expect explicit ablation experiments comparing hard codeword recovery, conventional soft decoding, and the proposed continuous receiver, so that the contribution of the proposed mechanism can be directly identified.
-
We would like the authors to provide a fairer and more complete separated-system comparison. The LDPC rate and QAM order should be selected according to an MCS table for each SNR, stronger recent image codec baselines should be included, and model size, computation, and encoding/decoding latency should be reported to clarify fairness and reproducibility.