- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies whether feedback on competing model behaviors can improve LLM-driven code evolution beyond scalar task scores. It introduces ConflictGuide, which uses a literature-grounded skill to identify model-specific conflicts and define measurable probes. Search begins with scalar feedback, then introduces probe feedback to guide edits and assess candidates with marginal task gains.
Critical strengths
- Testing five different model families across three search rounds makes the results more persuasive than a demonstration on a single task. These controls are a substantial reason for my positive assessment.
Critical weaknesses
-
It remains unclear whether the gains come from probe measurements, specific guidance, or the retention rule. Table 7 separates guidance from retention, but guidance still includes both mechanism descriptions and probe values. In Table 8, the prompt-only baseline receives only a generic reminder, and the baselines use different retention rules (Appendix H).
-
The novelty beyond existing diagnostic feedback methods is unclear. Self-EvolveRec [1] uses model diagnostics to guide code changes. GoalEvolve [2] uses gaps across multiple objectives to locate bottlenecks and guide edits. ConflictGuide focuses on competing behaviors, but the experiments do not clearly show what this adds over equally specific task diagnostics.
References:
[1] Sein Kim et al. Self-EvolveRec: Self-Evolving Recommender Systems with LLM-based Directional Feedback. 2026. arXiv:2602.12612.
[2] Haixu Liu et al. GoalEvolve: From Handcrafted Algorithm Priors to Goal-Driven Evolution of Physical Design Algorithms. 2026. arXiv:2608.16733.
Questions for authors
-
What information does the guidance-only setting in Table 7 provide? Do any experiments keep the descriptions and retention rule fixed and change only whether probe values are shown?
-
How much human input was needed to produce the final probes in the five settings? Which parts were generated automatically, and which were manually revised? Were failed probe proposals revised or discarded?
5 comments
W2: The novelty beyond existing diagnostic feedback methods is unclear. Self-EvolveRec [1] uses model diagnostics to guide code changes. GoalEvolve [2] uses gaps across multiple objectives to locate bottlenecks and guide edits. ConflictGuide focuses on competing behaviors, but the experiments do not clearly show what this adds over equally specific task diagnostics.
Thank you for asking about ConflictGuide’s added value over existing diagnostic feedback methods. We address this through the methodological distinction and additional experiments.
1. Methodological distinction: Identifying competing behaviors and turning them into measurable design guidance.
As discussed in the Introduction, managing trade-offs between desirable behaviors has long been an important problem in machine learning model design. One of ConflictGuide’s key contributions is to identify desirable behaviors that are coupled through a shared mechanism and difficult to improve jointly, and use validated probes to turn their responses to code changes into guidance for automated model design.
Compared with task-specific diagnostics or bottleneck identification driven by predefined goal gaps, ConflictGuide focuses on which behaviors interfere, which shared mechanism causes that interference, and whether a code change alleviates the conflict. This information guides the agent toward changes to the relevant components. When task gains are marginal, the retention rule further uses probe feedback to assess whether conflict alleviation is sufficient. ConflictGuide thus connects behavioral trade-offs in model design to conflict identification, measurement, and search decisions. We have clarified this distinction in the Introduction and Related Work.
2. Additional experiments: Comparing task-diagnostic, goal-gap, and conflict-guided feedback.
To examine this value, we added comparisons with Self-EvolveRec and GoalEvolve on GCNII and ESN. Both methods’ feedback mechanisms were adapted to the current tasks and are marked with an asterisk. These experiments evaluate task-adapted implementations rather than reproduce the original recommender-system or physical-design benchmarks. Results are from search round 2 and are reported as mean ± standard deviation.
| Method | Feedback | GCNII clean NLL ↓ | GCNII contaminated NLL ↓ | ESN NRMSE ↓ | ESN ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Self-EvolveRec* | Task-diagnostic | 0.5708 ± 0.0923 | 0.5716 ± 0.0939 | 0.2969 ± 0.0309 | 0.9109 ± 0.0139 |
| GoalEvolve* | Goal-gap | 0.5584 ± 0.0870 | 0.5572 ± 0.0891 | 0.2964 ± 0.0263 | 0.9115 ± 0.0119 |
| ConflictGuide | Conflict-guided | 0.5540 ± 0.0847 | 0.5488 ± 0.0863 | 0.2890 ± 0.0297 | 0.9156 ± 0.0170 |
These comparisons are reported in Section 4, Table 9.
ConflictGuide achieves the best performance on all four metrics across GCNII and ESN, outperforming task-diagnostic Self-EvolveRec* and goal-gap-driven GoalEvolve*. Under our task configurations, GoalEvolve* performs slightly better than Self-EvolveRec* on all four reported mean metrics. Task adaptations, implementation details, and comparison protocols are provided in Appendix H.6.
Q2: How much human input was needed to produce the final probes in the five settings? Which parts were generated automatically, and which were manually revised? Were failed probe proposals revised or discarded?
Thank you for asking about human involvement and unsuccessful proposals. We have added a workflow diagram and five case records in Appendix L, alongside an independent automated evaluation on new configurations.
1. Probe development and roles in the five cases.
The conflicts in Table 1 and probes in Appendix F were developed collaboratively by researchers, chat models, and coding agents. Chat models assisted with literature and mechanism analysis and drafted probe specifications and experimental plans. Coding agents implemented, tested, and repaired code.
Figure 12 in Appendix L maps this process to the current Skill workflow. Steps 3 and 7 mark the main human review points: draft and result review. Case Records 1–5 document each case’s development and revisions. These procedures were subsequently standardized as ConflictGuide-Skill, with the five cases forming its development basis. We have clarified the development roles and history in Section 3.2, with supporting records in Appendix L.
2. Revision, replacement, and rejection of unsuccessful proposals.
Repairable specification or implementation issues were revised and checked again; designs unsuitable for the target mechanism or experimental constraints were rejected or replaced. Examples include:
| Case | Issue or change | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| SpecB-FNO | Editable component boundaries needed alignment | Researchers requested revisions, followed by adjustments and checks |
| SNGP | Analysis shifted from OOD to ID classification margins and distance preservation | Mechanism and probe design revised |
| ESN | A candidate required an additional trained diagnostic readout | Rejected and replaced with Jacobian probes |
| GCNII | Implementation and test failures | Problems repaired and tests rerun |
The standardized Skill specifies candidate rejection and abstention criteria. A candidate should be rejected if either behavior lacks a supported task benefit, the shared coupling is unclear, or the interference hypothesis is inadequately justified. If no candidate meets these requirements, the Skill should abstain with a specific reason. Probe measurements must correspond to the claimed behaviors and specify key formulas and evaluation conditions; design gaps require revision or replacement. Appendix L documents case-specific revisions and rejections; Appendix C details the standardized screening and probe-design requirements.
3. Independent evaluation without human editing.
We evaluated the standardized workflow on 20 model/task configurations not used in development, previous evaluations, or scoring-rule calibration. We compared A: literature-assisted analysis; B: workflow without taxonomy; and C: workflow with taxonomy (ConflictGuide-Skill). Each configuration was run independently three times per condition, yielding 180 generation runs.
All conditions shared the same frozen literature and source code, evidence-retrieval budget, generation model, and core output format. GPT-6 Luna generated the outputs, and GPT-6 Astra scored them. Assessment used original outputs without researcher editing or repair. The scoring rubric was calibrated and frozen before generation; condition labels and taxonomy identifiers were hidden during scoring.
| Condition | Grounded mechanism candidate | Complete probe specification | Joint qualification |
|---|---|---|---|
| A: Literature-assisted analysis | 30/60 (50.0%) | 6/60 (10.0%) | 3/60 (5.0%) |
| B: Workflow without taxonomy | 42/60 (70.0%) | 12/60 (20.0%) | 10/60 (16.7%) |
| C: ConflictGuide-Skill | 48/60 (80.0%) | 13/60 (21.7%) | 11/60 (18.3%) |
All rates use the 60 planned runs per condition as the denominator. Compared with A, B and C increased joint qualification by 11.7 and 13.3 percentage points, respectively. Compared with B, C increased the grounded mechanism candidate rate by 10.0 percentage points.
These results show that the workflow can generate grounded mechanism candidates and probe specifications meeting the assessment criteria on new configurations without human editing. This evaluation covers automated analysis and specification design. Section 4 (Table 10) reports the results and scope; Appendix C.6 provides the evaluation protocol, scoring criteria, and supporting analyses.
Thank you for highlighting this ambiguity. The original Guidance only setting included both model-specific mechanism descriptions and numerical probe values. We have added ablations to Tables 7 and 8 that separate these inputs and explicitly specify the retention rules. In particular, A3 versus A4 and B3 versus B4 hold the mechanism description and retention rule fixed while varying only whether probe values are shown to the agent. Additional comparisons assess the scalar threshold, description specificity, and retention rule. Setting definitions, feedback contents, and retention criteria are detailed in Appendix H.
1. Table 7: Separating the threshold, mechanism description, and probe values.
Note. Gt denotes task improvement, and τS is the scalar-improvement threshold. “Full” denotes Eq. (6), including the model-specific task-gain bands, probe conditions, and guards in Appendix G.3. All settings share the same validity checks.
A1, A4, and A5 correspond to the original Baseline, Guidance only, and full ConflictGuide settings; A2 and A3 are added ablations. Results are mean ± standard deviation. SNGP OOD AUPR is evaluated on SVHN.
2. Table 8: Comparing descriptions with and without probe values under the same positive-gain rule.
Note. All settings receive standard task feedback. “None” under additional feedback means no additional quantitative feedback. Gt and “Full” are defined above. All settings share the same validity checks.
B1, B2, and B5 correspond to the original multi-metric feedback, trade-off-only prompting, and full ConflictGuide settings; B3 and B4 are added ablations. Results are final-evaluation mean ± standard deviation from search round 2. SNGP OOD AUPR is evaluated on CIFAR-10.
B2 → B3 compares generic and specific descriptions. B3 → B4 adds only probe values and improves all four reported mean metrics. B4 → B5 changes only the retention rule and further improves the reported means. Together with Table 7, these results show that probe values can help beyond specific descriptions, but their benefits vary across settings; mechanism guidance and retention also contribute. We have revised Section 4 to distinguish these incremental effects from the gains of the full framework.