- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The authors use a shared local energy profile to make targeted edits to a piece of text for the purposes of adversarially "humanizing" the text to evade AI detection. They evaluate their humanizer on detectability reduction as well as token sequence dissimilarity and embedding similarity. They achieve stronger AI detection reduction with a claimed "lower textual edit cost".
Critical strengths
The strengths of this paper lie in the novelty of the approach, as I have not seen wavelet energy approaches to guide adversarial generation in prior work. The methodology seems sound and correct.
Critical weaknesses
I have concerns about the metrics the author uses. First, the detectors used to measure detectability reduction are several years old and not representative of the current state of the art in AI detection. Additionally, while embedding similarity remains a proxy for meaning preservation, no metric measures the stylistic preservation of the source text or that the proposed method preserves text coherence.
Questions for authors
- What additional detectors can you use to establish this method continues to work even on detectors specifically designed for adversarial robustness?
- What additional metrics can be used to establish stylistic features are preserved?
5 comments
Looking Forward to Your Reply
Thank you very much for your comments. As the rebuttal period draws to a close, we would be sincerely grateful if you could let us know whether our responses have adequately addressed your concerns. We would greatly appreciate any further feedback, and we would be more than happy to provide additional clarifications.🙏
Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Looking Forward to Your Reply Again
As the author-reviewer discussion comes to a close, we'd like to hear any final thoughts you might have. Please let us know if you have remaining questions or need further clarification on any points. We hope our responses have adequately addressed your concerns.
Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Thank you for your careful and valuable comments and questions. We will explain your concern and questions point by point.
Q1 & W1: Detector Age and Robustness
A: WaveHumanize lowers TPR on both corpora for both recent detectors. The largest drops are 33.9 percentage points for WaveDetect on HC3 and 27.7 points for desklib on HC3.
We use the same evaluation setup as in the paper. To assess transfer beyond the likelihood-based evaluator, we additionally rescore the frozen outputs using WaveDetect (ACL Findings 2026), which is designed to resist eleven RAID attacks, and desklib (2025), which was trained on RAID. Together with the evaluations reported in the paper, these results cover five detector families and detectors published between 2019 and 2026.
Here,
ΔAdenotes the AUROC drop, andTPR@1%is the detection rate at the fixed threshold.Q2 & W2: The problem of preserving stylistic features
A: With 11.6% token edits, WaveHumanize leads on three style measures, ties DIPPER on cosine similarity, and keeps the coherence-metric change below 1%. Human ratings show 77.4% of evaluated outputs are coherent and 74.2% natural.
Following Evaluating Style Transfer for Text [1],
WMDmeasures lexical distance;fw-JScompares function-word distributions. Using eight features from the Stylometric AI Detector toolkit [2],cosandrank ρmeasure stylometric-profile similarity and feature-order consistency, respectively. WaveHumanize leads on WMD, fw-JS, and rank ρ, and ties DIPPER on cosine. Its coherence metric changes by 0.0039; DIPPER has the smallest change (0.0019). These automatic results indicate low measured drift.In our human evaluation, raters see one human-written text and one WaveHumanize rewrite and select the human-written text. Their choices are nearly evenly split: 52.7% choose the human-written text and 47.3% the rewrite, suggesting they have difficulty distinguishing the two (185 valid responses per item). Raters also judge whether texts are coherent and natural; 77.4% judge them coherent and 74.2% natural (201 valid responses per item). Overall, WaveHumanize shows low measured style drift and favorable human ratings for coherence and naturalness. We will report the survey data and protocol in the final appendix, in accordance with ICLR’s ethical principles.
We sincerely thank you for your valuable feedback and hope these additional results adequately address your concerns.
[1] Mir, Remi, et al. "Evaluating style transfer for text." Proceedings of the 2019 Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics: Human Language Technologies, Volume 1 (Long and Short Papers). 2019.
[2] Aityan, Sergey K., et al. "A lightweight approach to detection of AI-Generated texts using stylometric features." arXiv preprint arXiv:2511.21744 (2025).