- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
DisINR introduces a shared encoder–decoder pair together with subject-specific encoders, whose features are concatenated and jointly decoded to reconstruct the image. The shared pair is pre-trained across diverse subjects; during test-time adaptation it is frozen, and only a subject-specific encoder is optimized. The authors claim this effectively incorporates learned population priors into INR optimization, enabling faster and higher-quality reconstruction.
Critical strengths
Unlike STRAINER, DisINR places the shared pair (f_ϕ*, g_ψ*) where it can be frozen at test time, so that population priors are injected into the INR optimization while only the subject-specific encoder f_φ is optimized. This is a meaningful structural difference. The design yields the best reconstruction performance in PSNR and SSIM among the evaluated methods, consistently across the three tasks.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper credits its gain to freezing, on the grounds that freezing keeps the population prior. Two simple reference points would test this.
First, what happens with no prior at all? Keep the same architecture, remove the the population information, for example, start the prior encoder from random weights and still freeze it (not sure whether it is reasonable).
Second, what happens with only a trivial prior? Replace the shared feature with the average image of the training subjects. The paper states that the shared representation is “not simply the mean image,” but did not compare against the mean image.
These controls are inexpensive here. Because the input is a fixed coordinate grid and the shared modules are frozen, the shared branch produces the same output for every test subject, and the two branches are combined only by concatenation. Keeping one branch at a time would likewise show whether the shared branch carries real population information or merely keeps the frozen decoder within a working input range. The paper describes the shared representation as capturing “higher-level semantic structure,” but the term is never defined and no measurement supports it, and the decoder is not analyzed at all. Without these reference points there is no basis for judging how much the prior is actually worth.
- Is The shared pair pre-trained on a homogeneous cohort? Must the pre-training cohort match the test case in modality, anatomy, and contrast for the prior to be useful? If the shared pair were pre-trained over a diverse mix of subjects, would it still provide a useful prior? This matters for the claimed applicability across practical scenarios: if one shared pair is needed per anatomy and protocol, the pre-training cost must be paid repeatedly for different cohorts.
Questions for authors
Fundamentally, why should freezing the shared pair and fitting a subject-specific encoder be better than STRAINER’s shared-encoder/subject-decoder arrangement? Please make this argument explicit rather than resting it on the aggregate results.
It is seen from the results that fine-tuning the shared pair lowers the performance, probably due to the losing the prior, especially as finetune reuses the pre-training learning rate on already-converged weights with no stopping criterion. Can the author try intermediate settings: a small learning rate on the shared weights, a penalty for departing from the original shared pair of (f_ϕ*, g_ψ*) , or freezing the shared encoder while lightly adapting the decoder with the subject-specific encoder?
Responses to Authors
Thank you for the additional experiments. The rebuttal substantially alleviates my original concerns. I will maintain my weak accept recommendation.