- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes anatomy-aware pretraining for intraoral photographs by combining crop-to-image overlap alignment, FDI-based tooth-relation regularization, masked reconstruction, and teacher–student consistency. It introduces YoungDent and evaluates localization, feature probing, anatomical relations, and tooth segmentation. The application is relevant, but the methodological advantage over DINOv2 and the clinical significance require stronger evidence.
Critical strengths
- Useful domain-specific formulation: Tooth-level and sextant-level crops provide a reasonable way to incorporate dental structure into representation learning.
- Valuable data collection: YoungDent contains 5,377 smartphone photographs from 1,027 adolescents, with five-view coverage and subject-level train/test separation.
- Promising transfer results: The Swin-based model improves frozen-feature segmentation and transfers to the external Odontify dataset without retraining.
Critical weaknesses
- The advantage over DINOv2 is not consistently established under the same backbone. In Table A4, the ViT variant improves decoder-based in-domain mIoU only from 0.510 to 0.521 with 10% labels and from 0.574 to 0.578 with full labels. In Table 2, its logistic-probe FDI and tooth-category scores are lower than DINOv2. The larger Swin gains cannot be attributed solely to the proposed objectives.
- External supervision and evaluation-label quality need clearer treatment. Structural crops and FDI targets rely on SegmentAnyTooth. Appendix C.3 further states that YoungDent segmentation masks are generated using SegmentAnyTooth boxes and SAM-HQ. Without an expert-verified test subset, in-domain results may partly reflect agreement with the annotation pipeline rather than anatomical accuracy.
- Several evaluations closely follow the training targets. Localization measures the correspondence explicitly optimized during pretraining, while FDI-relation evaluation measures agreement with the imposed anatomical prior. These are useful representation diagnostics but provide limited independent evidence of broader transfer.
- Clinical relevance remains preliminary. No disease-detection or clinical-workflow task is evaluated. Furthermore, segmentation evaluation merges 32 tooth identities into eight categories, potentially hiding laterality and jaw-identification errors that matter for dental charting.
- The distinct methodological contribution needs stronger isolation. The framework combines established self-distillation, positional alignment, and masked reconstruction with dental priors. Comparisons against simpler pseudo-label supervision and a dental adaptation of VoCo would help establish the necessity of the full design.
Questions for authors
- Can you compare against DINOv2 using identical backbones, initialization, training budgets, resolutions, and structural crops, adding each proposed objective separately?
- Were the YoungDent test masks and FDI labels reviewed by dental experts? How accurate are the upstream predictions, and how sensitive is pretraining to their errors?
- Does the approach outperform direct tooth-number pseudo-label supervision using the same SegmentAnyTooth outputs?
- Can you report 32-FDI-class segmentation and numbering accuracy, rather than only eight-category metrics, with uncertainty across runs?
- Does the representation improve an independently annotated disease-related task? Could the symmetry prior suppress clinically meaningful differences between anatomically corresponding teeth?
Q1: Detailed comparison with DINOv2.
A1: Thank you for this comment. We acknowledge that the current results do not establish a consistent advantage over DINOv2 under the same backbone.
Q2: Prediction quality of upstream SegmentAnyTooth and verification.
A2: A subset of YoungDent annotations has been reviewed by dental experts. We will report the subset size, review protocol, and the accuracy of the predicted tooth boxes and FDI identities.
Q3: Relation of evluation metrics with training objectives.
A3: We agree that localization and FDI-relation evaluations are closely aligned with the training objectives. These evaluations were designed to examine the properties motivating our framework: correspondence across spatial scales and anatomical organization across subjects. Their alignment with the objectives makes them useful representation diagnostics, but limits their independence as evidence of broader transfer.
Q4: 32-FDI segmentation results and clinical diagnosis applications.
A4: Thank you for these suggestions. In our study, we followed the eight-category reporting convention used in tooth segmentation but agree that it may conceal laterality and jaw identification errors, a key limitation given that your question concerns full 32-tooth FDI segmentation. We also acknowledge that clinical utility remains preliminary, since the current experiments do not include a disease-related task. The symmetry prior encourages similarity between anatomically corresponding teeth without requiring identical representations; however, it could reduce sensitivity to clinically meaningful asymmetries. A disease-related evaluation, including asymmetric cases, would help assess this limitation.
Q5: Comparison with simpler pesudo-lable-guided supervised learning and VoCo.
A5: Thank you for these suggestions. The random-crop experiments in Table 2 provide a partial comparison, but do not fully isolate the contributions of the proposed components. We agree that comparisons with a 2D VoCo-style random-crop baseline and direct tooth-number pseudo-label supervision would help determine the benefits of our alignment objectives and relation objectives beyond the available external guidance.