Part 1/6: the operator
We thank the reviewer for a review that engages the construction; it changed what we claim. Naming: the revision writes μ (L=μH, μ∈{1,3,5,7,9}) for the multiplier, leaving τ for the time coordinate; where your review writes τ, read μ.
What changed. Claims narrowed (feature-axis gate, coordinate-conditioned modulation, "selective retrieval" withdrawn, sparsity figure removed); §4.4 and the limitations state the operator properties (per-variable coefficients over a shared basis, rank ≤ D+1, no variable mixing); we measured the operator's spectrum (Table B1) and ran the two linear comparisons (Table B2); the zero-filled experiment is replaced by position removal with a shared retained set (§5.1.4, Table 4); the lookback rule is stated where applied (Appendix A); W5's presentation errors are corrected. Both tables appear in this response, not the manuscript.
W1.1 The operator
Agreed. With D=2h, for fixed (L,H),
y^H=AϕX,Aϕ=Z~H(Z~L⊤Z~L+λI)−1Z~L⊤,rank(Aϕ)≤min(D+1,H,L),
which is 9 on Weather at H∈{336,720}. Section 4.4 draws the corollary and Appendix B the derivation; the submission stated the head in prose without drawing it --- our omission.
The property is definitional for closed-form meta-learned time-index models, DeepTime included: φ holds the outer-loop meta-parameters, θ={W^(K)} the base parameters fitted per window, and the inner solve is Bertinetto et al.'s. DeepTime states the consequence itself --- "the adapted time-index model it yields is purely a function of time-index features" --- because the formulation exists to restrict the hypothesis class to ℋ_DeepTime={g_φ*(τ)ᵀ W^(K)}, which is what lets a window be extrapolated from. We agree with the identity; we do not accept the step to "the gate is not selective", since what separates such models is what φ pins the directions to, and baseline (b) measures exactly that. A linear readout is also not a linear function class: given φ, predictions lie in the span of the basis on the horizon --- affine with the raw coordinate, band-limited trigonometric polynomials with FFE, nonlinear mixtures with TDGN (§4.2, Appendix E).
The ridge solve returns W∈ℝ^D× C, b∈ℝ^1× C, so ŷ_H,c=A y_L,c+b_c: one H× L map shared by every variable and window, acting column-wise. Three properties follow, the third now in Section 6 --- one basis and one map shared across variables with coefficients fitted per variable; rank at most D+1, independent of L and H; no variable mixing. Alterum is a per-variable forecaster over a shared basis; cross-variable correlation is not exploited, and we expect that to matter on datasets such as Exchange.
For the framework itself we point to the source rather than restate it: DeepTime's Section 3 sets out the meta-optimisation loop and the closed-form ridge regressor, and its appendix gives the resulting model as a function of time-index features alone. Those are inherited constructions of that paper; ours is the basis generator h_φ and the operator reading of Section 4.4, which is why we measure A_φ rather than re-derive it.
Table B1. From the trained meta-parameters alone (one forward pass of h_φ at the L+H coordinates plus the learned λ, no retraining), H=720. Effective rank is |A_φ|_F²/|A_φ|₂²; r_90% counts the directions carrying 90% of the spectral energy.
| Dataset | L | D+1 | eff. rank | r₉₀% | top-1 |
|---|
| ECL | 720 | 65 | 16.6 | 44 | 6.0% |
| ETTh1 | 720 | 17 | 2.1 | 7 | 47.7% |
| ETTh2 | 720 | 17 | 4.6 | 10 | 21.6% |
| ETTm1 | 5040 | 33 | 4.0 | 14 | 24.9% |
| ETTm2 | 3600 | 9 | 1.2 | 2 | 85.2% |
| Exchange | 96 | 17 | 1.3 | 2 | 79.2% |
| Solar | 2160 | 33 | 1.9 | 16 | 53.0% |
| Weather | 3600 | 9 | 1.5 | 4 | 65.1% |
Two readings. The bound is analytic and empirical: energy beyond the first D+1 directions is zero to machine precision (relative tail 2.9×10⁻⁹ to 2.0×10⁻⁸), round-off from a resolvent with condition number up to 6.1×10¹¹, not extra directions. And the operator is not degenerate: ECL needs 44 directions for 90% of its energy, Solar 16, ETTm1 14, ETTh2 10, ETTh1 7, while ETTm2 and Exchange are 1--2-direction dominated (top-1 85.2% and 79.2%); over 32 cells r_90% spans 1--68.
Part 2/6 continues with the two linear comparisons (Table B2) and the gating ablation.
We thank the reviewer. Two documentation problems and one fairness issue. Naming: the revision writes μ for the lookback multiplier (L=μH), reserving τ for the time coordinate.
W1 FFE and CFF
We claim neither random nor multi-scale Fourier features as new, and CFF already spares a per-run single-scale sweep. The difference is what is parameterised. DeepTime lists (0.01,0.1,1,5,10,20,50,100) and uses it unchanged across datasets, having swept single scales; CFF thus answers "one scale does not fit all" with a constant that never says how many scales a new dataset needs. FFE replaces the constant with a rule --- exponential spacing over [ω_min,ω_max], one hyperparameter N under the budget N≤d/2, realised as N_eff=min(d/2,N) scales --- so "which scales" becomes "how many".
N now has a derivation: scales above the L+H grid's Nyquist limit alias and carry no resolvable information, so cutting there gives N=8. Every cell is in Appendix P, Table 30 (168 runs): 17 of 28 differ by at most 1% (median +0.5%); 15 are worse under truncation, 8 better; six degrade by over 2%, largest ETTh1 at H=720 (+18.5%), ECL at 192 (+3.4%), Solar at 720 (+2.8%). Pooled +1.8%, +0.5% without ETTh1. A local cost, not a global equivalence: N=8 suffices when no per-cell optimum is required (within ±1% on 61% of cells at ~1.8%), otherwise search N; N=8 is released in the search space.
The contribution is the scale rule and TDGN's decomposition gating, not multi-scale use. At a matched 10,329-parameter budget, same backbone (Table 19), FFE + TDGN is lowest, alone or tied, in 30 of 32 cells and never beaten; CFF draws level in the rest (median 1.4% worse elsewhere), the sinusoidal encoding worse everywhere (53% median). FFE also concentrates less than CFF (r_90% 8.9 vs 5.8) and still forecasts better, so this is not a concentration effect.
W2 Lookback and tuning protocol
W3 Reconciliation
Both are real documentation errors, and neither changes a reported number.
(a) Eq. 1 presupposes d≥2N (one frequency per scale), never stated in the submission. The implementation halves the column budget for the sine/cosine pair, divides it over N_eff=min(d/2,N) and gives ⌊d/(2N_eff)⌋ frequencies per scale; every other dataset satisfies d=2Nm. Exchange is the exception: with d=8 the realised count is 4, the requested 16 scales collapse to 4 with one column each, and the "quarter frequency per scale" is the trace of a configuration violating d≥2N. The printed N=16 was also wrong; the realised value is 4. Eq. 1 and the appendix now carry N≤d/2, m=⌊d/(2N)⌋, and the Exchange row prints d=8, N=4; the configuration is untouched.
(b) One sentence wrote tr((Σ̂+λI)⁻¹), another tr(Σ̂(Σ̂+λI)⁻¹); they differ by Σ̂ and you are right that they disagree. Tables report the second, the only form bounded by D=2h; reported r never exceeds D, while the first diverges as λ*→0 and would exceed D exactly where r approaches D, so the entries identify the form used. The definition sentence was wrong, not the numbers; the revision rewrites it to the second form, with no table value changing. r_90%/r_95% come from the energy spectrum, independent of λ*.
Closing. The configuration and every table value stay as they are.