- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors of this paper introduce a diffusion process for symmetry breaking, allowing to jointly generate all aspects of crystal structures without sampling from empirical distributions.
Critical strengths
Interesting new approach, clear conceptually new idea compared to previous work. Some ablations and overall results look promising.
Critical weaknesses
The evidence that the approach has a clear advantage over other (simpler) approaches is not strong. The ablations in the last lines of Table 2 are good, but the manuscript would be stronger if other ablations are performed that actually demonstrate the advantage of the new approach over an empirical non-learned marginal distribution over G, as assumed in other models.
Comparison and benchmarking, especially on MPTS-52 (Table 3): Latest SOTA methods are missing. Please add and discuss the latest baseline models. While some metrics improve, others are worse than SOTA, which is overrated in the abstract.
According to P4.2, it seems like only symmetry-breaking effects from any space group directly to P1 are modelled, which is not well justified (see question below).
Questions for authors
Please better explain the ablations you introduced in Section 5. All SbCD variants are described in only one sentence, which makes it very hard to follow.
Where do you model the symmetry hierarchy of space groups? Does the process only allow jumps to P1 directly? This seems to severely limit what was promised throughout the paper.
3 comments
Thank you very much for the answers. I am sure this will make the manuscript more accessible.
Dear Reviewer sgvf,
We have updated our revised manuscript with additional results. Particularly, we would like to highlight our recent benchmark using multiple MLIPs.
We evaluate SbCD on MP-20 using LetMat GenBench [1], a recent, highly standardized benchmark for crystal generation. To evaluate thermodynamic stability, Betala et al. [1] compute the energy above the convex hull, , using an ensemble of advanced MLIPs comprising MACE-MP [3], UMA [4], and Orb-v3 [5]. They also use LetMat-Bulk [2], which contains approximately million structures and provides the broadest coverage of competing phases relaxed under consistent DFT settings. The same database serves as a reference for accurately assessing the novelty of generated structures. As recommended by Betala et al. [1], we generated structures and pre-relaxed them to assess their thermodynamic viability better. We report the performance across three runs alongside leaderboard results [1] for the baselines listed in Table 2.
| [count] | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MatterGen | 0.5 | 0.08[2] | 36 | 15.8 |
| ADiT | 0.1 | 0.00[0] | 37.1 | 1. |
| DiffCSP | 1.1 | 0.04[1] | 32.2 | 9.3 |
| DiffCSP++ | 0.7 | 0.16[4] | 27.6 | 5.3 |
| SymmCD | 0.5 | 0.04[1] | 19.4 | 2.5 |
| SbCD (run1) | 1.88 | 0.36[9] | 61.48 | 6.64 |
| SbCD (run2) | 1.92 | 0.16[4] | 59.06 | 5.96 |
| SbCD (run3) | 2.08 | 0.24[6] | 62.24 | 6.52 |
We observe that SbCD outperforms all the baselines on multiple metrics. SbCD generates significantly higher numbers of stable and metastable structures and also yields more S.U.N. structures. Note that novelty is assessed against million structures from LetMat-Bulk, so sampling a S.U.N. structure is particularly meaningful. Given the promising results on LetMat GenBench and the availability of our open-source code and model weights, we hope that SbCD, with its principled approach to modeling symmetry breaking, can make meaningful contributions toward addressing real-world materials discovery problems. We have released the CIF files for each run via the anonymous link (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UIB-MONgBlZsj8CQ-6gNHML5spcagueN/view?usp=sharing).
We sincerely thank the Reviewer again for their valuable feedback, which has improved the quality of our manuscript significantly.
References
[1] (Betala et al.) Lemat-genbench: A unified evaluation framework for crystal generative models. In arXiv:2512.04562
[2] (Siron et al.) Lemat-bulk: aggregating, and de-duplicating quantum chemistry materials databases. In arXiv:2511.05178
[3] (Batatia et al.) A foundation model for atomistic materials chemistry. In arXiv:2401.00096
[4] (Wood et al.) UMA: A family of universal models for atoms. In NeurIPS 2025.
[5] (Rhodes et al.) Orb-v3: atomistic simulation at scale. In arXiv:2504.06231
We thank the Reviewer for their constructive and detailed feedback. We address the raised weaknesses (W) and questions (Q) as follows.
W1+Q1. Details of the SbCD variants and an ablation using an empirical marginal distribution over G
We have clarified the descriptions of the SbCD variants in the revised manuscript. Below, we explain the design and purpose of each variant.
(1) SbCD♯ learns site symmetries using the 15×13 binary matrix representation introduced by Levy et al. [1]. This representation specifies the generators of the site-symmetry group along 15 possible crystallographic axes, including body and face diagonals, with up to 13 distinct symmetry operations per axis (Lemma 3.2). Figure 3 and the second ablation study (lines 491–503) show that SbCD, which uses a simple one-hot encoding of oriented site-symmetry symbols (Section 4.4), is more robust than SbCD♯. This result suggests that our simpler representation helps address the challenges of modeling complex site symmetries.
(2) SbCD♢ is an SbCD variant with a smaller architecture comparable in size to DiffCSP and DiffCSP++. It generates less stable structures but achieves better S.U.N. results, suggesting slightly less overfitting on MP-20.
(3) SbCD♢ (w/o SB) is an ablation of SbCD♢ that removes symmetry breaking and explicitly conditions on space groups drawn from the empirical marginal distribution during both training and inference. We used the smaller architecture for this ablation to speed up training and inference. Under the same experimental setup, SbCD♢ outperforms SbCD♢ (w/o SB) across multiple evaluation metrics. This ablation demonstrates the benefit of explicitly modeling crystalline symmetry breaking relative to sampling space groups from the empirical distribution.
W2. Missing recent baselines on MPTS-52 and overstatement in the abstract
In Table 3, we add two recent baselines for MPTS-52, MCFlow (Seong et al., ICLM 2026) [2] and SymADiT (Karmush et al., NeurIPS 2026) [3]. Both baselines are transformer-based and have significantly more parameters than SbCD. Few existing baselines can scale to a dataset as large as MPTS-52. MCFlow did not report thermodynamic stability results, and SymADiT reported results based on 100 DFT calculations. Neither method has released its code or model weights, which makes it difficult to evaluate them using a more feasible MLIP-based protocol. Because of this limitation, we have revised the abstract to state that our thermodynamic stability results are competitive with those of baselines for which results are available.
We also include additional metastability results in Tables 4 and 9, as requested by Reviewer 6eUs, to further support our claims about SbCD’s performance. In both the original and revised versions of the manuscript, our claim of strong performance on MPTS-52 is restricted to thermodynamic stability.
W3+Q2. SbCD's approach to modeling symmetry breaking
In the manuscript, we present the first proof of concept for modeling symmetry breaking in crystal generative models. SbCD breaks the symmetry of crystal structures by transitioning directly to P1, the space group with the lowest symmetry. During generation, SbCD reverses this process starting from the P1 prior (Algorithm 1, page 28). We acknowledge that this approach to modeling symmetry breaking is simplified. As discussed in the conclusion and future work (lines 803–809), the framework of Proposition 4.2 could also incorporate more physically realistic transition pathways.
We have revised the manuscript accordingly. We sincerely thank the Reviewer for their valuable time.
References
[1] (Levy et al.) SymmCD: Symmetry-preserving crystal generation with diffusion models. In ICLR 2025.
[2] (Seong et al.) Multimodal crystal flow: Any-to- any modality generation for unified crystal modeling. In ICLM 2026.
[3] (Karmush et al.) Symadit: Symmetry-aware crystal generation with latent flow matching. In NeurIPS 2026.