- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes STAR, a method for fine-tuning image-to-video generators to preserve facial identity while limiting the loss of facial motion. It selects a window of denoising timesteps and applies identity-reward gradients through one sampled step per update. The results across several generators and human evaluations provide encouraging evidence of identity improvement. However, my main concern is whether the proposed timestep selection offers a better balance between identity and expression preservation than simpler alternatives. The window ablation reports only identity similarity, while the complete method reduces facial-motion amplitude by 11%–12%. This leaves unclear how much of the improvement comes from better identity preservation versus restricting facial variation.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses a relevant problem and provides reasonable evidence of identity improvements across several generators. The evaluation includes both automatic metrics and human judgments. The authors also acknowledge the remaining reduction in facial motion.
Critical weaknesses
- Figure 1 does not convincingly separate identity improvement from changes in expression and pose. In the second row, STAR mainly appears to reduce the smile, making the face look closer to the reference expression. Enlarged face crops and expression trajectories would help clarify the difference. The caption should also define “Base” and identify the generator used in each row.
- Table 2 reports only identity similarity, although the proposed window aims to balance identity and motion. Reporting both metrics for nearby windows, fixed anchors and the existing sampling alternatives would better establish the benefit of calibration.
- In Table 4, the author shows that changing the identity reward contributes substantially to the improvement. A joint ablation of verifier choice and timestep selection would help establish how much each component contributes.
- The paper reports an 11%–12% reduction in facial-motion amplitude. Although the human evaluation is useful, stronger evidence is needed to show that requested expressions remain intact rather than becoming weaker. Targeted expression judgments and examples of failure cases would help.
Questions for authors
See the critical Weaknesses