the setting for this paper was so unclear that i had to go to one of the main citations of this paper (guney et al. 2025) to understand the problem statement (which i was able to understand within 3 sentences of reading their abstract, as that is a properly written paper). my understanding is now that this paper critiques the "empirical oracle" line of the guney paper, and similar other "empirical oracles" under the adaptive feature selection problem.
as far as i can tell, the paper doesnt audit guney's oracle per se; guney is just a motivating citation. instead, the experiments are on world-model setups (dino-wm, td-mpc2, dreamerv3) where the eval is a learned model that imputes probe outcomes. its more of a critique of Guney et al.'s assumptions (and other papers that make similar assumptions) than a direct improvement / modification to their results.
i am not sure why the experiments the authors chose are the appropriate setting for comparison here.
even under a generous reading, allowing for all the presentation issues, the paper's contribution is clearly below the bar at ICLR.
the paper is poorly written and reads like AI slop:
language like "we validate the decision rather than the gap" reads like ai slop. what? please ground everything better, properly set up the problem with sufficient background. reading an ICLR paper should not be such a puzzle.