acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Lifting 2D Stylizers to 3D: Plug-and-Play Style Transfer for Gaussian Splatting

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

We present StyleLift3D, a plug-and-play feed-forward framework for transferring expressive 2D stylization to existing 3D Gaussian Splatting scenes. Existing methods typically require per-scene optimization or reconstruct a new stylized representation, while independently stylized multi-view images provide inconsistent supervision across viewpoints. StyleLift3D instead lifts such 2D style cues directly into a coherent 3D representation in a single forward pass. Our framework combines three components: Geometry-Aligned Style Lifting aligns multi-view style features with the content scene; Octree-Local Style Fusion establishes fine-grained style-content correspondence through scalable local cross-attention; and Structure-Preserving Gaussian Decoding predicts residual appearance and bounded geometry updates, with optional dynamic splitting for additional capacity. By performing style fusion directly in 3D, StyleLift3D preserves scene structure while maintaining consistent stylization across novel viewpoints. Experiments on diverse scenes, styles, and 2D stylizers demonstrate improved content fidelity, favorable overall user-study preference, efficient single-forward lifting, and plug-and-play compatibility with multiple 2D stylizers, compared with the evaluated optimization-based and feed-forward baselines.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
3D Gaussian Splatting, Style Transfer, Differentiable Rendering, Scene Stylization

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 4 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_f73uOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

StyleLift3D transfers independently stylized multi-view images into an existing 3D Gaussian scene. It aims to preserve scene structure while producing a coherent stylized representation through a single forward pass of the lifting network.

The architecture extracts and aggregates image features, lifts them into 3D using content depth, and fuses them with Gaussian features through octree-local cross-attention. A decoder predicts appearance changes, bounded geometric residuals, and optional Gaussian splitting.

Training uses 9,000 scene–style–stylizer combinations constructed from 100 scenes, 30 style references, and three 2D stylizers. Experiments report strong content preservation and perceived naturalness, while style matching and multi-view consistency show less conclusive advantages.

Critical strengths
  • The system has a clear and useful scope: transferring interchangeable 2D stylization outputs into an existing Gaussian reconstruction. Reusing the input geometry avoids requiring the lifting network to reconstruct the entire scene from mutually inconsistent stylized observations.

  • The architecture addresses the computational demands of large Gaussian scenes through local fusion and constrained updates. The reported training scenes contain up to approximately 1.5 million Gaussians, demonstrating a meaningful implementation effort beyond small object-scale examples.

  • The appendix provides a thoughtful analysis of optical-flow-based consistency metrics. Its controlled experiment shows that changing texture frequency can alter warping scores despite unchanged scene geometry and camera motion, and the paper reports the complete benchmark results, including unfavorable cases.

Critical weaknesses
  • The methodological novelty appears primarily architectural and integrative. Depth-based feature lifting, local cross-attention, residual Gaussian updates, and splitting are established design elements, so stronger evidence is needed to identify the distinct insight contributed by their proposed combination.

  • The principal quality measurements do not exclude more conservative stylization as an explanation for improved performance. Content-referenced PSNR and LPIPS reward remaining close to the original scene, while the user study gives StyleLift3D a lower style-matching score than Stylos and AnyStyle, suggesting a trade-off rather than an unambiguous improvement.

  • The central claim of improved multi-view consistency lacks sufficiently direct supporting evaluation. The criticism of flow-based metrics is reasonable, but the user-study questions assess reference-style matching, content preservation, and naturalness rather than cross-view flicker or texture attachment, and a shared Gaussian representation alone does not rule out view-dependent artifacts.

  • The efficiency and ablation evidence should be interpreted more narrowly. Training the kNN variant for three epochs versus 100 for the full model under an equal-time budget demonstrates a computational difference but does not isolate fusion quality at comparable convergence; additionally, the single-forward-pass claim excludes the cost of generating the stylized input views, for which an end-to-end runtime comparison is needed.

Questions for authors

See the weaknesses above

Reviewer_UjxbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents StyleLift3D, a feed-forward, plug-and-play framework for transferring the output of an off-the-shelf 2D stylizer onto an existing 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) scene. Instead of optimizing a 3DGS scene per style, the method renders multiple views of the input 3DGS, stylizes each view independently with a frozen 2D stylizer, and then lifts the resulting multi-view style evidence into the existing 3DGS coordinate frame. The framework has three main modules: Geometry-Aligned Style Lifting (GASL), which encodes input Gaussians into content tokens and unprojects DINOv2 style features using rendered depth; Octree-Local Style Fusion (OLSF), which builds a shared octree over content and style tokens and applies cross-attention only within octree leaves; and Structure-Preserving Gaussian Decoding (SPGD), which predicts bounded residual updates to Gaussian geometry and optionally splits Gaussians to increase local capacity. The model is trained on a 9K-scale dataset built from 100 DL3DV scenes, 30 WikiArt style references, and three 2D stylizers. Experiments compare against several baselines on TnT, Mip-NeRF360, and DL3DV-10K.

Critical strengths

(1) The three proposed components have relatively clear responsibilities: GASL aligns style evidence with the existing geometry, OLSF performs local feature fusion, and SPGD converts the fused representations into Gaussian parameter updates. The use of content tokens as queries to spatially localized style features is a reasonable alternative to directly blending independently stylized RGB images.

(2) SPGD constrains changes to Gaussian parameters and initializes residual prediction heads to zero, allowing the network to begin near an identity mapping.This is appropriate when the input scene already contains useful geometry and the goal is to modify its appearance without unnecessarily disrupting its structure. Adaptive Gaussian splitting also provides a plausible way to increase representational capacity where the original primitive set is insufficient.

Critical weaknesses

(1) Novelty is incremental relative to existing feed-forward 3DGS reconstruction and stylization work. Most components are existing ideas: DINOv2 features, depth-based unprojection as in pixelSplat/MVSplat-style methods, VGGT-style global self-attention, octree partitioning as in OctNet, local cross-attention, and residual parameter prediction. The paper cites these works appropriately, but the core novelty is system-level integration for 3DGS stylization.

(2) The content-preservation metrics are not sufficient to establish stylization quality. The paper evaluates content fidelity using LPIPS, grayscale LPIPS, and PSNR relative to the original scene. These metrics can be informative, but stylization intentionally modifies color, texture, and local appearance. Thus, a result that remains close to the original image may achieve favorable content-similarity scores without transferring the target style effectively. A model that produces weaker stylization may appear better under metrics that reward similarity to the original content.

(3) OLSF is an important technical contribution, but the current ablation does not provide a fair comparison of final quality. The kNN variant runs 3 training epochs, whereas the full model completes 100 epochs. The paper attributes the weaker stylization of kNN to this training-budget limitation. However, this comparison only proves that the current kNN implementation is more expensive under the chosen training budget, rather than the claim that octree attention achieves better quality at comparable convergence. The paper also states that octree partitioning adapts to local spatial density, but does not directly demonstrate that this property reduces boundary leakage or improves local correspondence relative to fixed-size neighborhoods.

Questions for authors

(1) How does StyleLift3D differ technically from A3GS, Stylos, AnyStyle, StyleGaussian, and G-Style? I would like a structured comparison of inputs, outputs, optimization requirements, geometry modification, dependence on the stylizer during training, and generalization to unseen stylizers. The key issue is whether GASL, OLSF, and SPGD provide demonstrably distinct capabilities beyond the combination of existing architectural components.

(2) Does octree attention really outperform kNN beyond differences in training budget? It is better to provide a comparison at matched optimization progress, or an explanation of the exact computational bottleneck in the current kNN implementation. The goal is to distinguish a more favorable training-time budget from the quality–efficiency trade-off.

(3) Can the authors report a style-oriented metric, an evaluation of appearance retention relative to the 2D guidance, or another analysis that separates structural preservation from stylization strength? If no reliable single metric exists, the authors should explicitly acknowledge this limitation and avoid treating similarity to the original image as a comprehensive measure of stylization quality.

(4) What is the end-to-end efficiency advantage? Does the single-forward pass referd exclusively to the StyleLift3D network, or does it include the generation of stylized guidance views? A breakdown of stylization, feature extraction, octree construction, attention, and Gaussian decoding times would make the efficiency claim much more precise.

(5) The authors ignore some recent highly related works[1-6] on 3DGS style transfer.

Reference:

[1] P. Wang et al., “Styl3R: Instant 3D Stylized Reconstruction for Arbitrary Scenes and Styles”, In NeurIPS 2025.

[2] Y. Zhao et al., “Tune-Your-Style: Intensity-Tunable 3D Style Transfer with Gaussian Splatting”, In ICCV 2025.

[3] K. Howil et al., “CLIPGaussian: Universal and Multimodal Style Transfer Based on Gaussian Splatting”, In NeurIPS 2025.

[4] M. Bang et al., “Geometry-Aware Style Transfer in 3D Gaussian Splatting”, In ECCV 2026.

[5] Y. Li et al., “Diff-StyGS: 3D Gaussian Splatting Stylization via Tuning-Free Multi-view Sparse Diffusion”, In ICPR 2026.

[6] Z. Wen et al., “Capacity-Controlled Multi-view Stylization of 3D Gaussian Splatting”, In ECCV 2026.

Reviewer_3YFROpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

StyleLift3D transfers the output of a 2D stylizer to an existing 3D Gaussian scene. It uses depth rendered from the scene to lift features from independently stylized views, fuses them with nearby Gaussians using octree-local attention, and predicts residual updates with optional Gaussian splitting.

Critical strengths

Reusing an existing scene is a practical way to preserve fine structures. Figure 3 shows this on the vehicle and the interior scenes, and the user study supports the gains in content preservation and naturalness. I also appreciated the checkerboard experiment in Appendix A.6. It shows how smoothing a perfectly consistent texture can improve a warping score.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Missing comparisons. A³GS (Fang et al., ICCV 2025) is the most important omission. It also takes a reconstructed 3DGS and stylizes it in a feed-forward pass. Comparing the two on the same Gaussian scenes and style images would show whether the extra multi-view guidance improves the result. Styl3R (Wang et al., NeurIPS 2025) would also be a useful second RGB-based baseline alongside Stylos.
  2. Unequal access to geometry. Stylos takes unposed content RGB images and a style reference, as does Styl3R. StyleLift3D starts with a scene already reconstructed from multiple views and uses its rendered depth. It can retain a railing that Stylos first has to recover from images. Table 1 therefore mixes reconstruction quality with content preservation. Table 3 illustrates a related issue. The weakly stylized kNN variant beats the full model on all three content metrics.
  3. Evidence for view consistency. The style question in Table 2 measures agreement with the reference image. Whether brushstrokes stay attached to a surface as the camera moves is a separate question. Tables 7 and 8 give mixed results, and Appendix A.6 explains why those metrics are sensitive to texture. A direct comparison of stroke drift or flicker along the same camera path would address the claim.
  4. Section 4.2 describes Stylos as reconstructing from stylized views, while its inputs are ordinary content images and a separate style reference. The timing discussion would also benefit from reporting how long it takes to generate the 2D guidance for a new style.
Questions for authors
  1. Do you have results against A³GS using the same base Gaussians, reference styles and evaluation cameras? If this comparison was infeasible, what prevented it?
  2. For Table 1, how many views were used to reconstruct each base 3DGS, and which content views were provided to Stylos?
Reviewer_S355OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

StyleLift3D explores how to rapidly transfer multi-view images—generated independently by off-the-shelf 2D stylizers—onto existing 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) scenes. It leverages the depth of the original scene to back-project DINOv2 style features into 3D space, then integrates these with the original Gaussian features via octree-based local attention. This process predicts appearance, constrained geometric residuals, and optional Gaussian splits. The network was trained on a dataset of 9,000 samples, comprising 100 scenes, 30 style images, and three different 2D stylizers; during inference, no further network optimization is required for new scenes. Experimental evaluations include metrics for content preservation, human subjective scoring, and multi-view consistency, alongside ablation studies on various stylizers and model components.

Critical strengths

(1) The task formulation is practical. By retaining an existing 3DGS reconstruction as a geometric anchor and directly fusing multiple 2D stylized views—rather than re-estimating the scene from potentially contradictory images—the approach offers a streamlined workflow. It supports various 2D stylization methods, and the 3D editing network generates a new scene in a single forward pass; this is particularly advantageous for iterative experimentation with different styles.

(2) The analysis regarding content preservation and the limitations of evaluation metrics is rigorous. As shown in Table 2, the method achieves human-rated scores of 4.520 for content preservation and 4.288 for visual naturalness. Furthermore, in Appendix A.6, the authors provide a counterexample—where geometry remains fixed while only texture frequency is altered—to demonstrate that traditional optical flow-based warping metrics cannot serve as reliable measures of consistency for stylized scenes. By reporting these results, even though they are unfavorable to their own method, the authors enhance the transparency of their experimental evaluation.

Critical weaknesses

(1) The core claim regarding cross-view consistency lacks direct supporting evidence. The metrics in Table 1—LPIPS, grayscale LPIPS, and PSNR—measure the distance from the original content frames rather than the intensity of the style transfer. Although the authors acknowledge that the "warp" metric is influenced by texture, they fail to propose an adequate alternative for evaluating cross-view consistency. Consequently, while the current results demonstrate effective content preservation, they are insufficient to substantiate stronger claims regarding consistency.

(2) The specific contribution of the local octree-based fusion remains unclear. In cases where style features conflict at the same 3D location, the paper does not analyze whether the attention mechanism learns to select reliable information or primarily functions to perform averaging and smoothing. Furthermore, the kNN baseline in Table 3 was trained for only 3 epochs, compared to 100 epochs for the full model; this makes it impossible to assess differences in fusion quality at comparable levels of convergence. Providing results at similar convergence stages would strengthen the evaluation. Additionally, the computational cost of pre-generating multi-view 2D stylized images is not accounted for in the single-pass forward inference time.

Questions for authors

Q1. Could you report the reference style fidelity, content preservation, and true cross-view stability separately for the held-out scenarios—specifically for the exact style-scene combinations used in testing? Were the human evaluations conducted using paired samples (i.e., comparing outputs for the same input case)? Additionally, what statistical tests and confidence intervals were applied? This information is crucial for my assessment of your core conclusions.

Q2. When controlling for similar training convergence levels and style intensities, does the octree-based local attention mechanism still offer an advantage over simpler methods like 3D feature pooling or kNN-based fusion? Furthermore, please clarify whether the gating regularization for the "splitter" and the ablation studies were evaluated using an independent held-out dataset.

Q3. Could you include a strong baseline that also leverages existing 3DGS (e.g., A3GS) and report the end-to-end runtime and VRAM usage, including the generation of stylized 2D views? Additionally, could you provide separate quantitative results for unseen styles and unseen stylizers?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.