- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates whether behavioral monitors can be reused after language model updates or need to be retrained. Using OLMo-3 and Tulu models, it examines how different AUROC aggregation methods affect monitor evaluation and how limited audit data influence reuse decisions. The results highlight the importance of choosing appropriate evaluation metrics and accounting for uncertainty when deciding whether to reuse existing monitors.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a practical problem in maintaining monitoring systems as language models evolve. The distinction between pooled and within-benchmark evaluation provides useful insights into how monitor performance can be interpreted.
- The paper includes experiments on two language model families, together with controlled analyses and audit simulations. The detailed examination of evaluation procedures helps explain why different metrics and audit settings can lead to different conclusions.
Critical weaknesses
- The main findings are based on two language model families and two reasoning benchmarks, limiting their generalizability to other model architectures, update strategies, and monitoring tasks. In addition, the observed reversal between pooled and macro AUROC is not statistically conclusive and is not consistently reproduced across models.
- The paper mainly analyzes existing evaluation procedures rather than introducing a new monitoring or adaptation method. While the findings are useful, the practical benefits of the proposed audit analysis remain unclear, particularly because reuse decisions depend heavily on the chosen performance threshold, sample budget, and partitioning strategy.
Questions for authors
- Do the findings hold for other language model families, reasoning tasks, or types of model updates?
- Can the authors clarify what new methodological insights the analysis provides beyond established differences between pooled and macro AUROC?
- How sensitive are the audit conclusions to the selected performance threshold, sample budget, and partitioning strategy?
Response to Reviewer WzW2
We categorically reject the unfounded accusation regarding our rebuttal text. The response was written by the authors to convey exact numerical results, statistical decompositions, and experimental controls with precision. Accusing researchers of relying on AI simply because a rebuttal is tightly structured and directly addresses the critique is an unconstructive ad-hominem distraction that avoids evaluating the substantive evidence.
Furthermore, in the original review, the "Questions for Authors" section contained zero questions ("See weaknesses"). In our response, we systematically decomposed those weaknesses with concrete data. Dismissing empirical facts without identifying a single technical flaw is a departure from constructive peer review. We leave the evaluation of this interaction to the Area Chair.