acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

LAMP: Lyapunov-Inspired Potentials for Latent Model Predictive Control

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Latent model predictive control ranks candidate actions using a learned model and a bootstrapped value function. During learning, errors in these components can distort candidate preferences, particularly when experience is limited. We introduce **LAMP**, a planning extension that learns an auxiliary state potential from reward-bin labels and uses it to penalize candidate trajectories. The potential uses a Lyapunov-inspired non-increase objective on sampled reward-improving transitions. It is trained on detached latents without Bellman-return targets. It guides planning through a scheduled hinge penalty. Our analysis characterizes the penalty's effects on candidate weights, conditions for reducing absolute and relative score errors, and limits of transferring reward supervision to planning queries. On 28 robotic control tasks from the DeepMind Control Suite, the reported results show improved learning performance over TD-MPC2, with the largest gains on Dog and Humanoid locomotion.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Robot control, Model-based reinforcement learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_MYH9OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents LAMP, an extension of latent model predictive control that augments TD-MPC2 with an auxiliary state potential for guiding candidate trajectory selection. The potential is trained from adaptive high- and low-reward bin labels on transition endpoints, together with a Lyapunov-inspired non-increase objective on sampled reward-improving transitions. It is learned on detached latent representations without Bellman-return targets. During planning, an EMA copy of the potential produces a scheduled cumulative hinge penalty over latent rollouts, which is subtracted from the original TD-MPC2 candidate scores. The paper also analyzes how the penalty changes MPPI candidate weights, distinguishes absolute score-error reduction from relative ranking-error reduction, and discusses limitations caused by distribution shift, label ambiguity, and misalignment between the potential and return-estimation errors. Experiments are conducted on 28 state-based DeepMind Control Suite tasks using five random seeds, with comparisons against TD-MPC2, DreamerV3, and SAC. The reported gains are most pronounced on the seven Dog and Humanoid locomotion tasks. Additional ablations examine the penalty schedule and the PD hidden-layer parameterization.

Critical strengths
  1. LAMP provides a clear and reasonably simple extension to latent MPC. The method adds an auxiliary potential and a planning-time hinge penalty while retaining the TD-MPC2 world model, value targets, and candidate sampler. The use of detached latents gives the auxiliary a clear optimization role: it changes action selection without directly modifying the backbone’s representation or return-learning objectives.

  2. The evaluation covers a reasonably broad set of control tasks. The paper evaluates LAMP on 28 DMControl tasks with five random seeds and reports both aggregate and per-task learning curves. The separate analysis of the seven Dog and Humanoid locomotion tasks is useful because this is where the reported differences from TD-MPC2 are most visible. The paper also reports a modest training-time overhead and uses shared LAMP-specific hyperparameters across the benchmark.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The methodological novelty is not sufficiently differentiated from existing planning extensions. The central contribution is an auxiliary reward-bin-supervised potential combined with a scheduled hinge penalty on TD-MPC2 rollouts. The paper itself relates these ingredients to prior work on Lyapunov-inspired structure, reward shaping, and model-based planning, but it does not clearly establish a distinct algorithmic principle beyond their combination. In addition, recent alternatives discussed in the related-work section, including TD-M(PC)2, MRS.Q, EfficientTDMPC, and Dream-MPC, are not included as experimental baselines. Therefore, the paper does not establish whether LAMP offers a meaningful advantage over other recent approaches to model-based planning errors.

  2. The experiments do not isolate the source of the reported performance gains. The main results evaluate episode return, but do not directly measure candidate-score calibration, pairwise ranking accuracy, or the error-alignment conditions used in the analysis. The two-task diagnostics in Figure 1 provide motivation but do not establish that the proposed penalty corrects the relevant errors across the benchmark. The ablations compare a dynamic versus constant penalty schedule and the PD hidden-layer parameterization against a matched MLP, but they do not independently remove the decrease objective, remove the reward-bin classification term, or compare against a penalty derived directly from the existing reward head. Consequently, the experiments demonstrate the behavior of the complete configuration without providing a clear causal explanation for why it improves performance.

  3. The scope and robustness of the proposed state potential remain limited. The potential is state-only and is trained from immediate reward-bin labels. When reward depends strongly on the action, the same latent state can be associated with conflicting high- and low-reward transition labels. Similarly, a low-reward transition may be necessary for reaching a valuable future state. The paper acknowledges these limitations, but does not report label-consistency diagnostics, sensitivity to the reward thresholds or penalty strength, or performance across different planning horizons and reward scales. Evaluation is also limited to state-based DMControl tasks and a single TD-MPC2 backbone, so the generality of the approach to other latent MPC methods, visual observations, or more complex environments is not established.

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide ablations that separately remove the reward-bin classification term and the decrease term, while also comparing against a penalty constructed from the existing TD-MPC2 reward head?

  2. Can the authors directly evaluate whether LAMP improves candidate selection, for example through candidate-return calibration, pairwise ranking accuracy, or the centered score-error criterion discussed in the analysis?

  3. How sensitive are the results to the penalty weight, threshold cc, reward-bin thresholds, schedule milestones, and planning horizon? Are the reported gains robust across different reward scales?

  4. Can the authors compare LAMP with the recent planning alternatives discussed in Section 2, or clarify which properties of those methods are complementary to LAMP?

Reviewer_ArpaOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The authors present an extension of MPC-style controllers for robotic problems where they learn an auxiliary potential function and a trajectory scoring function to help reduce the regret induced in the policies obtained, arguing that it minimises cumulated errors.

The main contribution is a small improvement over existing baselines in RL robotic benchmarks. They validated their proposed method in an extensive set of RL environments and compared against state of the art work.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  • The paper does not really justify any of the decisions made, or try to provide intuition over why the particular construction they propose (potential + penalty function) work. Furthermore, the connection to Lyapunov functions is merely through the positive definiteness of the functions, but no connection is drawn to Lyapunov theory or any of their main results regarding system stability.
  • The empirical results are extremely incremental. In most cases, the method provides a small improvement over existing baselines (which one would think it's obvious, given the additional ad-hoc scoring functions used).
  • The paper has many signs of being heavily AI generated ('and scope' appears multiple times as section titles, the sentence construction 'X does Y, it does not establish Z' as well...). While I understand this may not be a reason to reject, it is indicative that perhaps not a lot of work was put into evaluating whether the contribution was relevant enough for submission.
Questions for authors

What is the intuition behind using such a potential and penalty function? Why do we want to structure them in the ways proposed? What if instead we just used a similarly complex network to learn the error residuals in the world model?

Reviewer_rSStOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes LAMP (Lyapunov-Augmented Model-based Planning), a planning extension to TD-MPC2 which is aimed at making planning more robust to errors in the learned dynamics model and bootstrapped value function during training. Such errors can distort the relative ranking of candidate trajectories in MPPI, causing the planner to favor actions whose predicted returns are inaccurate. LAMP learns an auxiliary state potential from immediate reward labels, shaped by Lyapunov-inspired structural priors, and uses it to penalize candidate rollouts during planning, with a schedule that controls its strength over training. Since this method leaves the backbone's learning objectives untouched, it acts as a flexible modular addition to TD-MPC2. The stated claims are accompanied by a theoretical analysis of the penalty’s effect on candidate preferences, and an evaluation on various control tasks showing improvements over TD-MPC2, most notably in high-dimensional settings.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper identifies a specific and practically relevant failure mode in latent MPC, which is that errors in the learned model and value function can distort candidate rankings early in training. The analysis is usefully organized around the distinction between common score offsets, which cancel under the MPPI softmax, and candidate-dependent errors, which can reverse preferences. This distinction clearly informs the design. The theoretical analysis is careful and appears correct. It clearly derives or explains important quantities, including the separation of absolute from relative score error, the condition that the penalty must be positively correlated with candidate-level error, the conditional-mean interpretation of the reward-bin objective, and the total-variation bound on weight changes. It also states explicit failure cases rather than only sufficient conditions, which is valuable for understanding when the method should not be used.

  2. The proposed method has clear practical advantages and targeted empirical gains. LAMP is a drop-in extension that leaves TD-MPC2's world-model, value, and policy objectives unchanged. This makes it easy to adopt and to isolate experimentally, and potentially compatible with other improvements to the backbone. The empirical improvements seem to be concentrated where TD-MPC2 struggles most. For Dog Run and Dog Walk LAMP appears to reduce TD-MPC2's large variance across seeds. LAMP also uses a single shared configuration across all 28 tasks, and the reported wall-clock overhead is modest.

Critical weaknesses
  1. It is unclear whether the Lyapunov-inspired components of this method are actually driving the empirical gains. Several lines of evidence prompt this concern:

    a. The decrease objective (Eq. 7) appears to overlap substantially with the classification loss. Any pair passing the triple mask consists of two consecutive HI transitions, so the classification loss already regresses both toward the same target vhiv_{hi}. The decrease term therefore seems to be active mainly where classification has not converged, where it acts as an additional downward pressure on HI-band states rather than as an ordering constraint. Because the mask excludes transitions that cross bands (e.g., LO to HI), the decrease prior also never constrains the potential ordering between bins.

    b. In Figure 4, the MLP variant is nearly indistinguishable from full LAMP, both on average and on most individual tasks. The ablation therefore provides no evidence that the positive-definite parameterization is responsible for the gains, which weakens the paper's Lyapunov framing.

    c. The zero-preimage property cited from Richards et al. holds for the PD hidden layers, but the unrestricted 512→256512 \rightarrow 256 output projection has at least a 256-dimensional null space, so it does not carry over to ϕψ\phi_\psi.

    One plausible explanation for the reported gains is that the penalty shifts weight toward short-horizon reward relative to the bootstrapped terminal value, rather than contributing information specific to the Lyapunov-inspired potential. This limitation is briefly discussed (but not resolved) in Appendix E.

  2. The empirical evidence for LAMP’s practical advantages is somewhat limited. The improvement over standard TD-MPC2 is modest and concentrated on only a few tasks (noticeably Dog Walk, Dog Run, Humanoid Run, and Hopper Hop). The paper explicitly says its experiments don't establish superiority or complementarity relative to TD-M(PC)², MRS.Q, and the other recent alternatives. However, since they target the same failure mode on the same backbone, a comparison against at least one of these methods would be helpful to assess the practical efficacy of LAMP. The constant-alpha variant is also close to full LAMP on most tasks. The difference is most visible on Dog Stand, where it dips mid-training and seems to collapse at the very end with a wide confidence band, and to a lesser degree on Dog Walk. With 5 seeds and overlapping intervals, the evidence that the schedule matters is modest.

Questions for authors
  1. How were the shared LAMP hyperparameters chosen, and on which tasks were they tuned? In particular, were they tuned on any of the Dog or Humanoid tasks where the largest gains are reported?
  2. Could the authors run an ablation on the objective function, removing L_dec while keeping the rest fixed? It would also be helpful to see how often the triple mask activates, how often candidates incur a nonzero planning penalty, and how much the penalty changes candidate weights. This would clarify whether the Lyapunov-inspired component contributes beyond the reward-bin classifier.
  3. Were TD-MPC2, DreamerV3, and SAC rerun by the authors under identical conditions, or were curves taken from published results? In Figure 3, the DreamerV3 and SAC curves on the Humanoid tasks stay at zero until roughly 3M steps and then rise abruptly, could the authors explain this?
  4. LAMP modifies the planner's objective while leaving the policy prior and Q-function objectives unchanged, so the behavior that generates data is optimized for a different score than value learning assumes. Could this possibly widen the mismatch that motivates the paper?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.