- Rating
- 4
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focus on a real-world problem in traffic signal control. When one node is controlled by an intelligent agent, the traffic will go to the downstream node and cause traffic jam. The author propose a novel method to solve this problem, the method propose an adaptively policy to add control node and adjust traffic to improve the recovery performance after node fault. The experiments are comprehensive and presentation is good.
Critical strengths
-
This paper focus on a real-world traffic problem which is very important to research. The author propose CAPE to solve this problem by adaptively adding control node and adjust traffic to improve the recovery performance after node fault.
-
The experiments are comprehensive, the author design a fault-recovery experiment to test the recovery ability for different method, which is convincing.
-
The presentation looks good and enough to publish in ICLR.
Critical weaknesses
-
Images should enhance the visual presentation. For example, we should use the same colour for one module and different colour for different moudle, of course, this is just my suggestion for your consideration.
-
The counterfacual rollouts may be difficult to obtain in real-world traffic environments. This raises concerns about the practicality and general applicability of the proposed online adaptation mechanism.
Questions for authors
-
Can the author have a more deep think about the counterfactual training problem? Because in the real-world this is difficult to simulate. I found a paper called CFLight[1] which uses counterfactual learning to improve the safety, the author can refer it.
-
Can the author investigate more papers for this problem and compare with your method? I found some papers called MalLight, DiffLight, FuzzyLight[2,3,4] which has the similar problem with yours. I would like to improve my score if the author can resolve these problems.
[1] CFLight: Enhancing Safety with Traffic Signal Control through Counterfactual Learning. KDD, 2026.
[2] MalLight: Influence-Aware Coordinated Traffic Signal Control for Traffic Signal Malfunctions. CIKM, 2024.
[3] Difflight: a partial rewards conditioned diffusion model for traffic signal control with missing data. NeurIPS 2025.
[4] FuzzyLight: A Robust Two-Stage Fuzzy Approach for Traffic Signal Control Works in Real Cities. KDD 2026.