- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper targets weakly‑supervised temporal action localization and proposes the LDPR model. It leverages LLMs to decompose each action into start, middle and end sub‑actions. Four modules are designed for sub‑action temporal structure, representation discriminability, boundary transition and boundary refinement based on Wasserstein distance. The model achieves competitive results on THUMOS’14 and ActivityNet v1.3. Its main merit is mitigating semantic mismatch via LLM‑driven fine‑grained sub‑action text. However, this work contains multiple concerning flaws including insufficient experimental validations, weak motivation for several designs, non‑trivial inference overhead and incomplete analysis.
Critical strengths
-
This paper addresses the common boundary offset problem in weakly‑supervised temporal action localization. The idea of using LLMs to produce start‑middle‑end sub‑action descriptions for fine‑grained semantic guidance is reasonable.
-
The paper provides comprehensive ablation studies covering modules, hyper‑parameters and loss combinations. It also reports boundary offset as an auxiliary evaluation metric.
Critical weaknesses
-
Sub‑action texts are generated offline by an LLM. The paper does not test robustness against noisy or incorrect LLM outputs. Unstable LLM generations may hurt overall performance in real‑world usage.
-
Table 6 shows heavy per‑video inference latency for the full model. The PDR module runs on CPU and no acceleration solution is provided. Practical deployment will be difficult and limitations from high latency are not discussed.
-
Boundary refinement depends on a fixed window‑size hyper‑parameter. Though ablation is provided, generalization across videos with variable action speed and action duration is not discussed.
-
Evaluations are limited to two public datasets. Experiments on extra benchmarks or cross‑domain settings are absent. It remains unclear whether the LLM‑guided sub‑action pipeline can generalize to other action datasets.
-
Table 6 shows heavy per‑video inference latency for the full model. The PDR module runs on CPU and no acceleration solution is provided. Practical deployment will be difficult and limitations from high latency are not discussed.
-
The straight‑through estimator is adopted for proposal structure loss. Does it bring gradient bias? Have you monitored whether sub‑action temporal assignment stays stable during training?
-
The work uses GPT‑5 for prompt generation while feeding text into frozen GPT‑2 Large encoder. Justification for this hybrid setup is missing. The authors do not report results using GPT‑5 as the text encoder directly.
Questions for authors
see the above weakness